Jill Zarin from The Real Housewives of New York City agreed with Bethenny Frankel and said a winning RHONY cast would consist of the original group. And while she would love to see the original five women return, she’s confident at least one person would never appear on the show again.

Some RHONY fans have long wondered if Alex McCord would return, especially after she moved to Australia. Kelly Bensimon, who said she’d love to join the RHONY spin-off Legacy cast hoped McCord would also return. Zarin isn’t confident fans will see McCord on RHONY any time soon.