Marvin McClendon


Melissa Ann Tremblay was 11 years old when she was stabbed to death and then left on train tracks in Lawrence, Massachusetts, where a train ran over her. Her body was found on September 12, 1988.

Now, 33 years later, authorities have charged someone with her murder.

On Friday, 74-year-old Marvin C. McClendon, Jr. was arraigned in Lawrence District Court and pleaded not guilty to a charge of first-degree murder in connection with Tremblay’s death, the New Hampshire Union Leader reports. He is being held without bail.

Police say McClendon had long been a “person of interest” in the case, but it wasn’t until last month that authorities had enough evidence to arrest McClendon, prosecutor Jessica Strasnick said, according to WCVB-TV.

“Using various DNA advancements, the commonwealth was able to focus on the name McClendon,” Strasnick said, the television station reports.

Investigators said evidence collected from the girl’s body was “instrumental” in cracking the case, according to the Union Leader.

“Melissa has never been forgotten,” Essex County District Attorney Jonathan W. Blodgett said in a press conference announcing McClendon’s arrest, WMUR-TV reports.

Tremblay, who was from Salem, New Hampshire, was reportedly playing in the neighborhood near the LaSalle Social Club in Lawrence, while her mother and the woman’s boyfriend were inside, according to the Boston Globe.

The establishment is about a block away from the old Boston and Maine Railway Yard, where the sixth grader’s body was found.

At the time of the girl’s death, McClendon was reportedly working in the carpentry field. He had been employed by the Massachusetts Department of Corrections at various times between 1970 and 2002 before he retired and moved to Alabama.

Thomas Murphy, a retired police detective who worked the case decades ago, said he is hopeful that Tremblay and her family will see justice.

“It always bothered me,” Murphy told the television station. “A young child. Somebody’s young child,” he said.

Sherry Carignan, Tremblay’s childhood friend, attended Friday’s court hearing. She said she has mixed feelings about McClendon’s capture.

“News like finding out they made an arrest is something to be celebrated, but it does break your heart open,” Carignan told WCVB-TV. “Let’s hope justice is served here, but I think the real justice will come when he sits before God.”

For the latest true crime and justice news, subscribe to the ‘Crime Stories with Nancy Grace’ podcast. Here is our latest episode. 

[Featured image: Marvin C. McClendon, Jr., Melissa Tremblay/Police Handout]



You May Also Like

Archer Woman Arrested After Two-Hour Domestic Battery Standoff

Staff report ARCHER, Fla. – Cynthia Lee Correll, 74, was arrested Thursday…

Prosecutors: Teen Shot Classmate Dead Six Seconds After Leaving County Bus Following Heated Argument

Inset: Camron Bowen (Facebook). Background: Surveillance footage showing Robbiel Stokes aboard a…

Police: Parents Crammed 15 Kids Into Deplorable 2-Bedroom Apartment

Insets, from left: Ashley Jackson, Derrick Jackson and Briana Reynolds (Cobb County…

Mom Accused of Attacking 2 Young Children; 6-Year-Old May Lose Arm

Inset: Taylor M. Gosnell (Spartanburg County Sheriff’s Office). Background: The South Carolina…

GPD Detective Arrested by FBI

Photo from GPD’s Facebook page Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – FBI agents…

Plumber Says He Hit a ‘Bump’ After Killing 13-Year-Old

Background: Cody Churchwell appears during a court hearing (KPTV). Inset: Quinn Broyles,…

Man Shot Girlfriend in Head, Faked Break-In During 911 Call, Jury Finds

Left inset: Lisa West (Manchester Funeral Home). Right inset: Kevin Wells (Colorado…

Lawsuit: 4-Year-Old Drowned After Boy Opened Apartment Pool Gate

Left inset: Sy’mir Draco Vinson (Taylor Funeral Home of Chattanooga). Right inset:…