S.C. woman who wondered how family's killer could 'live with yourself' is arrested in 2015 quadruple homicide

A South Carolina woman, who’d given emotional interviews about stumbling into the gruesome murder scene of four loved ones, was arrested and ordered held without bail this weekend in connection with that 2015 quadruple slaying, officials said.

Amy Vilardi and her husband, Rosmore “Ross” Vilardi, are both accused of killing Cathy Scott, 60; Mike Scott, 59; Barbara Scott, 80; and Violet Taylor, 82, on Halloween night of 2015 in the victims’ Refuge Road home in Pendleton, authorities said. Each victim had at least one gunshot wound, officials said at the time.

Cathy Scott was Amy Vilardi’s mother, and Violet Taylor was her grandmother. Mike Scott was the husband of Cathy Scott and son of Barbara Scott. Amy Vilardi called 911 on Nov. 2 after discovering the gruesome crime scene, authorities said.

Just days after the murders, she told NBC affiliate WYFF of Greenville, South Carolina, that she had difficulty shaking the memory of finding the bodies.

“When I went to knock on the back door, the door just pushed open so I walked in and it was dark and I just flipped the light on and there they were. They were just, they were there,” Vilardi said.

She added: “I don’t understand why any of it has happened and I just keep thinking it’s a dream I’m going to wake up from. Whoever did this, I don’t see how you can live with yourself.”

Now, Vilardi and her husband are both charged with four counts of murder. They were arrested Friday at their Columbia home, and a judge ordered them held without bail on Saturday.

“This is a case that rocked our county extremely hard,” Anderson County Sheriff Chad McBride told reporters on Friday. “We’ve tried to keep it at the forefront of the media and the public’s awareness and knowledge.”

The suspects were not represented by attorneys during Saturday’s court appearance, and it wasn’t clear if they had hired or been assigned defense lawyers by Monday, a sheriff’s department spokesperson said.

McBride thanked the victims’ loves ones for their patience over the years as his detectives worked the cold case.

“God bless this family. They have been through so much and they have waited a long time and we are just so pleased they don’t have to wait anymore,” he said. “I can’t wait to see justice served.”

The sheriff declined to reveal any details of how detectives linked Amy and Ross Vilardi to the slayings.

“Some things have to be preserved for our day in court,” he said. “Anything I say, as far as details, the other side can use against us.”

The couple had been on the detectives’ radar for years.

In 2018, the now-suspects had gone to court asking that cars, electronic devices, firearms and cash that had been seized from them be returned.

“We have some issues there with whether or not some evidence may have been moved before the sheriff’s office even got involved,” Anderson County Attorney Leon Harmon told a court in 2018. “That’s why we feel like we need to control the evidence until we get to the end of our investigation.”

The couple has long denied having any role in the slayings.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Gas prices are surging just before Labor Day, as diesel hits an all-time high

Trump Eyes U.S. Diesel Export Ban, Experts Warn of Higher Gas Prices

A temporary U.S. ban on diesel exports could bring immediate relief at…
WATCH: ‘American Idol’ alum Caleb Flynn tells cops flag-carrying stranger came to door before wife’s shooting

WATCH: American Idol Alum Caleb Flynn Says Flag-Carrying Stranger Visited Before Wife Was Shot

Former “American Idol” contestant Caleb Flynn returned to center stage Monday as…
Cornell frat member ratted out bros in alleged gang rape, attorney reveals as he claims key evidence lost forever

Cornell Frat Member Told on Brothers in Alleged Gang Rape, Lawyer Says

A Cornell University student who was repulsed by the allegations against his…
Adventurer who blew life savings on California ghost town reveals how his gamble has gone

Adventurer Reveals Outcome of His Life Savings Gamble on a California Ghost Town

After spending more than $1 million to buy an abandoned California mining…
Trump to announce largest steel plant in American history to be built in Iowa

Trump to Announce Record-Breaking Steel Plant Planned for Iowa

WASHINGTON — President Trump is set to announce Monday afternoon that Minnesota-based…
WATCH: NYPD bodycam captures tense standoff after Bank of America exec fatally stabbed in Times Square

NYPD Bodycam Shows Standoff After Fatal Bank of America Exec Stabbing

Newly released NYPD body camera video captures officers urging Pamela Cisneros to…
Parents-in-law arrested after New York Times Games engineering director found fatally shot

Parents-in-Law Arrested After New York Times Games Engineering Director Found Shot Dead

Jonathan McKinsey, a New York Times Games engineering executive, was fatally shot…
Mamdani’s 'influencer army' plot secret attacks on NYC CEOs

Zohran Mamdani’s ‘Influencer Army’ Plans Secret Attacks on NYC CEOs

Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s senior advisers are reportedly developing a coordinated campaign targeting…
Bessent: Iran’s Economy Will Have ‘Nothing Left to Trade’ in Two Weeks

Treasury Secretary Bessent Says Iran Has Two Weeks of Trade Left

Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said Sunday that Iran could have “nothing left…
Alito recuses from major climate change case to be decided by the Supreme Court

Justice Alito Recuses From Supreme Court Climate Change Case

Washington — Justice Samuel Alito has stepped aside from a major climate…
UK airbase terror suspects being released on bail as Iran denies connection

UK Airbase Terror Suspects Released on Bail as Iran Denies Link

British police are expected to release five terrorism suspects on bail Monday,…
BASE jumper dies after falling from 700-foot Utah cliff

BASE Jumper Dies After Falling From 700-Foot Cliff in Utah

A 27-year-old BASE jumper died Sunday morning in Utah after plunging approximately…