Elsa E. Segura lured Monique Baugh into a fatal ambush that took place Dec. 31, 2019, prosecutors said. (Mug shot: Minnesota Department of Corrections)

Elsa E. Segura lured Monique Baugh into a fatal ambush that took place Dec. 31, 2019, prosecutors said. (Mug shot: Minnesota Department of Corrections)

The former probation officer who admitted on the stand that she set up a sham house-showing appointment with a realtor who ended up getting murdered will receive a new trial because the trial court flubbed jury instructions on her case.

The Minnesota Supreme Court on Wednesday determined that while there’s enough evidence to show that Elsa E. Segura, 31, participated in the kidnapping and felony murder of Monique Baugh, 28, the majority of justices ruled that botched jury instructions possibly contributed to her conviction.

From the ruling, quoting the trial court’s jury instructions (emphasis belonging to the state Supreme Court):

The elements of kidnapping to commit great bodily harm/terrorize are first, the defendant or another (or others) confined or removed Monique Baugh from one place to another without her consent …

Second, the defendant or other persons acted for the purpose of committing great bodily harm on the person of Monique Baugh or terrorizing Monique Baugh … It is not necessary that the defendant or that other person(s) actually caused great bodily harm to Monique Baugh or have terrorized Monique Baugh so long as the defendant or that other person(s) intended to do so.

Third, some part of the defendant’s act took place on or about December 29th through 31st, 2019, in Hennepin County.

…

If you find that each of these elements has been proved beyond a reasonable doubt, the defendant is guilty of this charge; if you find that any element has not been proved beyond a reasonable doubt, the defendant is not guilty of this charge, unless you find the State has proven beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant is liable for this crime committed by another person according to the instruction below.

The Supreme Court opined, “When viewed together, these instructions materially misstate the law because they — by their plain language — allow the jury to convict Segura of kidnapping for the actions of others without reaching the issue of her liability under an aiding-and-abetting theory. The jury could find that the State proved beyond a reasonable doubt that (1) another person confined or removed Monique Baugh from one place to another without her consent, (2) the other person acted for the purpose of committing great bodily harm on the person of Monique Baugh or terrorizing Monique Baugh, and (3) that Segura took some action on December 29–31 in Hennepin County. Under the plain language of the instructions, the jury could convict Segura of kidnapping based on these findings alone. Thus, we conclude that the district court abused its discretion by providing hybrid instructions that materially misstated the law.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Man Arrested After Alleged Robbery at Homeless Encampment

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Michael Allan Davis Sr., 30, was arrested…

Police: Mother Beat Newborn Son to Death at Home Within an Hour

Jantelle Sharon Jordan (Smith County Sheriff’s Office). A Mississippi mother is in…

911 Call Captures Mother’s Last Plea as Boyfriend Kills Daughter

Inset: David Keith Thornton (Broward County Jail). Background: The 1500 block of…

Gainesville Man Arrested After Allegedly Touching Juvenile Neighbor

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Bennie Williams III, 52, is facing charges…

Dad Allegedly Fractured Baby’s Skull, Told Cops Blood on Shirt Was Tomato Sauce

Inset: Muhire Augustin (Boone County Jail). Background: The Fourth Avenue home in…

Man Accused of Strangling Woman for 10 Minutes After She Laughed at Him, Police Say

Inset: Victor Dorantes-Velazquez (Broward County Sheriff’s Office). Background: The Hallandale Beach apartment…

Police: 300-Person Teen Party Had Underage Drinking, Fireworks

Inset, from left: Lisa Vaughn and Aubrey Vaughn (Fairfax County Police Department).…

Prosecutors: Father Who Killed 7-Week-Old Son Hurt Infant Before

Inset: Jacob Thompson (Ottawa County Prosecutor’s Office). Background: Magruder Hospital in Port…