Trump vs. Harvard and the 'academic brain drain' myth
Share this @internewscast.com

Has President Donald Trump declared war on Albert Einstein?

“America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain,” The Economist warns.

Following the Department of Homeland Security’s decision to bar Harvard University from enrolling foreign students, Ian Bremmer, a political scientist with strong connections in Washington, described the action as “fantastic news for China.”

The government’s strategy involves using its influence over the immigration status of foreign students to pressure Harvard into implementing tougher policies against antisemitism and eliminating racially charged “diversity, equity, and inclusion” initiatives.

However, this isn’t solely an issue in America’s culture war: Experts in foreign policy, including Bremmer, argue that the administration’s actions endanger national security and could undermine America’s technological advantage over its global competitors.

The Manhattan Project was a success thanks to émigré geniuses who contributed a great deal more to America’s World War II effort, and subsequent struggle with the Soviet Union, than just the atomic bomb.

And isn’t it true that something like 40% of Fortune 500 companies were started by immigrants?

Liberals might support high immigration levels, and large numbers of foreign students in particular, simply because they like the new and unfamiliar — though it’s hard not to notice that foreign students typically pay more tuition and pad the bottom line of our colleges and universities, just as immigration on the whole gives liberals opportunities to court newcomers with social services and identity politics.

Yet supposedly hard-headed realists say it’s not liberal ideology but America’s need for more scientists and entrepreneurs that’s the real reason we have to open our campuses (and borders) to the world’s talents.

After all, if we don’t do that, where else are we going to get the brains we need to compete with China?

The trouble with this tale, which is an article of faith for The Economist and the likes of Bremmer, is that it’s patently false — and largely intended to deceive.

In fact, very few companies on the Fortune 500 were started solely by immigrants; almost all were founded by Americans, occasionally in partnership with émigrés.

The source for the factoid, the American Immigration Council, has to fudge the numbers by lumping “children of immigrants” into the same category as “immigrants,” even when those children are born American citizens.

As for competing with China, how can it be that China itself is so competitive when it accepts relatively few foreign students or immigrants?

China, with a native population of more than 1.4 billion people, had only about 258,000 foreign students enrolled in degree-granting programs before COVID-19.

And while China sometimes claims to have nearly 500,000 foreign students overall, nearly half that number appear to be in non-degree programs: They’re not even full-time students, let alone Einsteins.

China’s economic and military competitiveness is home-grown, not a result of harvesting engineers from India.

America has a great many foreign-born Nobel Prize winners, to be sure.

But when America, and America’s campuses, have had more restrictive attitudes toward migration in the past, they have nonetheless competed, and won, at the highest levels — while developing countries, even when their most talented individuals have not been able to migrate, have not risen to America’s levels.

That’s not because individual talent doesn’t matter; it does, and the most truly exceptional minds, such as Einstein’s or other Nobel laureates’, should not only be welcomed by America but actively courted by us.

But where most people are concerned, even most people of above-average talent, the national environment counts more.

This is why the outlook of The Economist is so dangerous to America: It encourages lowered expectations of Americans themselves, with more disciplined if not more talented immigrants picking up the slack.

That’s the real brain drain: It’s draining the world’s intellectual capital to make up for self-imposed habits of failure in America.

The talented foreign student turns into an excuse for having Americans waste their own talents — not least by studying the kinds of highly ideological subjects that give rise to wokeness, antisemitism and “diversity, equity, and inclusion” in the first place.

The Trump administration faces another fierce fight in the courts over its attempt to revoke Harvard’s ability to host international students.

It’s a heavy-handed remedy, though perhaps nothing short of such pressure will be enough.

The most elite institutions of higher education in this country have long been a force unto themselves, even as they receive hundreds of millions of dollars from taxpayers and enjoy privileges for importing workers and customers — foreign talent and students — most businesses could only dream of.

A reckoning is overdue.

But Trump’s brawl with Harvard isn’t just about an institution — it’s also about the ideas that have led Americans to think they can’t succeed anymore, they can only import someone else to succeed in their place.

Daniel McCarthy is the editor of Modern Age: A Conservative Review.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
'El Chapo' son and Sinaloa cartel kingpin Joaquin Guzman Lopez confesses to drug trafficking, kidnapping in court in Chicago

El Chapo’s Son, Joaquin Guzman Lopez, Admits to Drug Trafficking and Kidnapping in Chicago Court

CHICAGO — Intense scenes played out in a federal courtroom in Chicago…
School bus driver knits beanies for students to spread warmth and love

Heartfelt Stitches: School Bus Driver Warms Students’ Heads and Hearts with Handmade Beanies

Tina Hutcherson, a dedicated school bus driver, is knitting beanies to ensure…
Chicago weather forecast: More snow for PM commute Monday | O'Hare, Midway airports recover from weekend flight cancellations

Snowy Monday Commute Expected in Chicago as Airports Recover from Weekend Cancellations

CHICAGO — As the Chicago area continues to recover from a significant…
Mamdani-appointed NYC professor who wrote book on ending policing now tasked with shaping community safety

NYC’s New Community Safety Visionary: Meet the Professor Behind the Movement to End Policing

A sociology professor from Brooklyn College, who recently joined New York Mayor-elect…
Trump's Ultimatum to Maduro: Flee Now or Face American Forces

Trump’s Bold Stand: Maduro’s Last Chance to Escape or Confront U.S. Military Power

South America may soon witness heightened tensions as President Trump issues a…
EU official warns 'impunity' for Russia would mark 'historic mistake of huge proportions'

EU Leader Cautions: Letting Russia Off the Hook Could Be a Monumental Misstep

In an ongoing effort to mediate peace between Russia and Ukraine, President…
Trump: Wounded National Guardsman Andrew Wolfe 'Fighting for His Life'

Trump Speaks Out on National Guardsman Andrew Wolfe’s Critical Condition

President Donald Trump announced that a National Guardsman injured in a Washington,…
Foreign terror labels curb ISIS, but US radicals face fewer limits online, study finds

Study Reveals Disparity: US Online Radicals Face Fewer Restrictions Compared to Foreign ISIS Terrorists

In the United States, extremist factions are seizing the chaotic landscape of…
Accused CEO assassin Luigi Mangione asks judge to toss evidence from his arrest

Luigi Mangione, Accused CEO’s Alleged Assassin, Seeks Dismissal of Arrest Evidence in Court Appeal

On Monday, Luigi Mangione, charged with the assassination of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian…
Father-to-be Navy officer vanishes with pilot instructor after plane drops off radar

Navy Officer and Pilot Instructor Disappear After Aircraft Loses Radar Contact

A tragic incident has left a flight instructor and her student, a…
Judge says former Trump lawyer Alina Habba has been unlawfully serving as US attorney in New Jersey

Court Confirms Alina Habba’s Removal from New Jersey Attorney Role

In a significant legal decision this week, a federal appeals court ruled…
ICE arrests two illegal immigrants convicted of 'heinous' crimes against children in New Jersey and Texas

ICE Captures Convicted Child Offenders in NJ and TX: A Critical Move in U.S. Immigration Enforcement

In a decisive move emphasizing the U.S. government’s commitment to expelling violent…