Trump lawyers shred attempt to dismiss his '60 Minutes' suit
Share this @internewscast.com

Left: President-elect Donald Trump featured on “Meet the Press” Sunday, Dec. 8, 2024 (NBC News/YouTube). Right: Vice President Kamala Harris appears on “60 Minutes” in a video uploaded Oct. 7, 2024 (60 Minutes/YouTube).

Attorneys representing President Donald Trump have responded against Paramount Global and CBS after they sought to dismiss the $20 billion lawsuit he initiated last year concerning a “60 Minutes” segment with Kamala Harris. Trump’s team criticized the move as a superficial effort to misuse the First Amendment as a “weapon.”

The lawsuit, backed by Texas Representative Ronny Jackson— a Republican from Amarillo and former White House physician under Trump— met opposition from Trump’s legal representatives on Wednesday. This followed Paramount and CBS’s March motion to dismiss, citing issues such as lack of personal jurisdiction, incorrect venue, failure to state a claim, and lack of subject matter jurisdiction.

The companies filed two separate motions to dismiss on March 6; one for personal jurisdiction and improper venue, another for failure to state a claim and lack of subject matter jurisdiction. They had previously filed dismissal motions in December, but were required to refile after Trump amended his complaint in February to add Jackson and double the damages sought from $10 billion to $20 billion.

In trying to get the cases kicked out of the Lone Star State, Paramount and CBS argued that they did not aim the broadcast at Texas residents.

The media defendants also say that Trump’s lawsuit is an attempt to punish defendants for editorial judgment, which they claim is barred by the First Amendment.

Trump’s lawyers disagree.

“The fact that such commercial speech was issued by a news organization does not insulate Defendants from liability under the First Amendment,” wrote Trump’s legal team on Wednesday. “The First Amendment is no shield to news distortion.”

Trump’s allegations stem from two clips of Harris answering a question about the ongoing Israel-Hamas war in the Middle East. His lawsuit claims the network edited the vice president’s response to make her more appealing to voters and to avoid “one of Harris’ most embarrassing weaknesses,” which it claims was “her habit of uttering ‘word salads’ — i.e., jumbles of exceptionally incoherent speech that drew disapproval even from dyed-in-the-wool Democratic commentators.” The suit says CBS was “looking to profit from manufactured enthusiasm for Harris” by using allegedly “doctored” footage, which they claim was an “unethical and unlawful” attempt to “sabotage a Republican presidential candidate.”

In their filings opposing the dismissal motions, Trump’s lawyers said that “to support their shallow argument” to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction and improper venue, Paramount and CBS “unconvincingly attempt” to show that Trump engaged in “naked forum-shopping.” His lawyers maintained that Trump and Jackson have “sufficient minimum contacts” in Texas and that their claims “arise out of those contacts.”

For the failure to state a claim and lack of subject matter jurisdiction motion to dismiss, Trump’s team said Paramount and CBS “seek to wield the First Amendment as a sword, arguing that they cannot be held responsible for illegal conduct, intended to mislead the masses and undertaken in the pursuit of profit, because such conduct was the result of ‘editorial judgment.””

“No matter how many times they claim the conduct at issue was editorial speech, that ipse dixit does not make it so,” they said.

Trump alleges that CBS’s editing of the “60 Minutes” interview with Harris caused “widespread confusion and mental anguish of consumers, including plaintiffs, regarding a household name of the legacy media apparently deceptively distorting its broadcasts, and then resisting attempts to clear the public record.” His lawyers describe him as a “prolific content creator who directly communicates with his tens of millions of followers on social media, a media brand in his own right which competes with defendants.”

Trump has reportedly been negotiating a settlement with Paramount, which offered $15 million to end things — an offer Trump declined, according to a report by The Wall Street Journal, citing people familiar with the matter. The parties have reportedly discussed a tentative mediation session scheduled for Thursday.

Trump’s amended complaint, which was filed on Feb. 7, condemns the Harris interview as “an act of unfair competition” and “unfair advantage” against his Truth Social network under the federal Lanham Act, in addition to unlawful “election and voter interference.” Trump is also claiming that CBS falsely advertised with a preview for it during an episode of “Face the Nation.”

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Judge Slams Trump Administration for Non-Compliance in Humanities Grant-Funding Lawsuit

President Donald Trump speaks during a lunch with African leaders in the…

Myrtle Beach Pastor John Paul Miller Indicted by Feds Following Wife Mica’s Tragic Swamp Death and Cyber Stalking Allegations

In a troubling turn of events, John Paul Miller, a pastor from…

Joran Van der Sloot Discovered in Critical Condition with Neck Injury, Authorities Report

Last week, Joran Van der Sloot, convicted for murder, reportedly attempted suicide…

Tragic Case: Mother in ‘Funeral Dress’ Sentenced After Attempting to Drown Daughters, Heroic Intervention Saves Lives

Share A South Carolina mother has been sentenced to a lengthy prison…

Unveiling Secrets: Concerns Rise Over Possible Over-Redaction in Trump-Era Epstein Files

A significant number of redactions are anticipated, according to one source, with…

Amazon Driver Allegedly Assaults Dental Office Receptionist; Subdued by Patients and Staff, According to Police

Background: News footage of the Emerald Dental office in Lakewood, Colo. (KDVR).…

Heartwarming Holiday Miracle: Rescue Operation Reunites 43 Children with Families in 12 Days

In a significant breakthrough, federal authorities revealed on Thursday the successful rescue…

Wisconsin Judge Convicted of Felony Obstruction, Cleared of Aiding Mexican Immigrant in ICE Evasion

Inset: Surveillance video shows Milwaukee County Judge Hannah Dugan speaking with ICE…

Revolutionizing Healthcare: Ionic Alliance Foundation Champions Healing Over Profit

Every year, the healthcare system is burdened by a staggering $250 billion…

Trump-Appointed Judge Criticizes ICE, Threatens Contempt in ‘Chillingly Brutal’ Case

Donald Trump, left, shakes hands with Kristi Noem at a campaign rally…

Probationer Detained Following Home Invasion and Attempted Escape

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Taurus Cordarryl Duncan, aged 36, found himself…

Additional Teens Face Charges Following Violent Altercation at Sydney Shopping Centre

Two more teenagers have been charged over an alleged brawl at a…