arrest warrant issued for dog owner
Share this @internewscast.com

They started it! 

The owner of a pit bull accused of attacking a tiny chihuahua is alleging that his dogs were the actual victims in the incident that took place on an Upper West Side sidewalk, which gained media attention last month.

The pit bull’s owner’s attorney, Ikiesha Al-Shabazz, made this assertion following a Friday court hearing convened because the owner had disregarded a judge’s order by not turning over the two large dogs to the authorities. She also presented a purportedly exonerating video of the violent incident.

Despite the key moment at the start of the fight still obscured in the clip, she said it showed the chihuahua provoking her client’s 100-pound dog.

“They decided that they were going to lie,” Al-Shabazz said in a Manhattan courtroom hallway on Friday.

A visibly frustrated civil court judge had earlier issued an arrest warrant for her client, Joseph Columbus, due to his absence that morning and his non-compliance with court directives to surrender the two dogs.

Al-Shabazz told reporters that “this case is not as it seems,” and claimed text messages reveal the tiny dog’s owner admitted to lying about who started the canine carnage.

“I was there for the original plan to say the bite was the Pit bull, not Penny,” the messages allegedly sent from Penny co-owner Lauren Claus read, “we dropped that plan like an hour after we left the precinct.”

Al-Shabazz claims that the messages are between Claus and an Upper West Side restaurant worker she was chatting with for surveillance video of the gruesome and bloody attack last month, and has filed them as an exhibit in the lawsuit.

“So you lied too?” the worker allegedly texted back.

Reps for the owner of the Chihuahua did not comment.

“Yes,” the response reads. “We didn’t feel good about it.”

“Penny was the initial aggressor,” said Al-Shabazz. “Does that mean a dog deserves to be attacked — absolutely not.”

Claus did not respond to a request for comment on the hearing or on the messages by the time of publication.

Al-Shabazz declined to share the name of the worker, but said she could call her to testify.

According to Department of Health records and earlier reports, Columbus’ pit bulls also mauled a pair of Shi-tzu’s in January, with one later succumbing to their injuries.

The Friday morning contempt hearing in Manhattan Supreme Court was supposed to focus on Columbus’ failure to hand over the two dogs, Rambo and Zooey, after two judicial orders to do so.

Judge Phaedra Perry-Bond immediately demanded to know why Columbus was not in court.

Harassment from the public and media had sent Columbus — a “morbidly obese man” —  to the emergency room with chest pains that morning, said Al-Shabazz.

The judge didn’t buy her claims that Columbus left his apartment for the E.R. at 6 a.m. that morning.

“The media was there,” Perry-Bond replied curtly, “it was all on T.V.”

Al-Shabazz asked if “the court could not express its disdain for Mr. Columbus.”

“It’s not disdain,” the judge interjected, “it’s frustration.”

Columbus had defied two orders to surrender the dogs issued this week, Perry-Bond said.

“I was very clear with those orders — and now you tell me he’s in the hospital the day of his hearing?” Perry-Bond said. 

“Those dogs should have been surrendered to the NYPD,” Perry-Bond said as she issued an arrest warrant for Columbus. “I told him the consequences.”

Al-Shabazz said that surrendering the dogs meant certain death for the pups. 

Perry-Bond rolled her eyes and said owners of Penny were only asking for the two big dogs to be “assessed, neutered, spayed, and have insurance, and a muzzle.”

“I understand you have your perception of this case,” Al-Shabazz said to the judge. “Your perception of the case is not fully formed.”

“Stop. Stop. Stop,” Perry-Bond shouted, just 10 minutes after the hearing began. “Stop talking. Stop. We’re done.”

“We’re looking for you Joe — don’t run Joe,” said supporters of the chihuahua as they walked by Al-Shabazz after the short hearing.

“You should be ashamed as a lawyer,” another added.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Ukrainians react to Trump's new stance on Russia-Ukraine war

Ukrainians Respond to Trump’s Latest Position on the Russia-Ukraine Conflict

Some Ukrainians hope his words translate into real support, while others remain…
Franklin Park ICE shooting: New bodycam video captures police response to fatal shooting of Silverio Villegas-Gonzalez

Police Release Bodycam Footage of Franklin Park ICE Incident Involving Silverio Villegas-Gonzalez’s Fatal Shooting

ABC7 has released body camera footage capturing Franklin Park police’s response to…
Man accused of trying to kill Trump in Florida to give closing argument Tuesday

Man Accused of Attempting to Assassinate Trump in Florida Scheduled to Deliver Closing Argument Tuesday

Ryan Routh and prosecutors will each have one hour and 45 minutes…
JSO: Man shot, killed after leaving party at Embassy Suites on Baymeadows Road

JSO: Man Fatally Shot After Departing Embassy Suites Party on Baymeadows Road

The Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office said two masked individuals approached and shot the…
Vystar Ballpark to host first playoff game in decades

Vystar Ballpark Set to Host Its First Playoff Game in Many Years

For the first time in over a decade, Vystar Ballpark will play…
All-boys choir members at Chicago's Leo High School, 'America's Got Talent' finalists, get ready to compete for $1M Tuesday night

Leo High School Choir from Chicago, ‘America’s Got Talent’ Finalists, Set to Vie for $1M Prize

CHICAGO (WLS) — The Leo High School all-boys choir is set to…
Rifle behind Charlie Kirk’s killing may be untraceable relic from WWI

Charlie Kirk Assassination Suspect Stays in Special Housing Unit After Mental Evaluation

On September 10, 2025, at Utah Valley University, Charlie Kirk engaged with…
Georgia couple charged over pet cremation fraud

Georgia Couple Accused of Fraudulent Pet Cremation Scam

The Georgia couple are accused of running a pet cremation scam in…
3 detainees shot, some fatally, at Dallas ICE facility: Sources

Three Detainees Shot, Resulting in Fatalities, at Dallas ICE Facility: Reports

On Wednesday morning, three individuals in custody were shot at the Dallas…
Remember Peter Strzok, the Smirking Anti-Trump FBI Agent? He Just Lost 1st Amendment Case Against the DOJ

Do You Recall Peter Strzok, the Smirking Anti-Trump FBI Agent? He Recently Lost His First Amendment Case Against the DOJ

Do you remember Peter Strzok, the FBI agent known for his anti-Trump…
The economy was a strength for Trump in his first term. Not anymore, according to recent polling

Polls Suggest Trump’s Economic Strength from First Term Has Diminished

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Donald Trump’s second-term strengths look different from his…
Woman accused of shooting car during 'road rage incident'

Woman Allegedly Opens Fire on Vehicle in Road Rage Encounter

Chelsea Roland has been taken into custody on charges including two counts…