Experts weigh in on key moments that could decide Karen Read's fate in murder trial

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles!

Karen Read’s retrial in the death of Boston cop John O’Keefe is near an end after more than a month’s worth of pivotal testimony.

Experts say key moments decided the case in their minds. Now her fate is in the hands of jurors.

For David Gelman, a defense attorney from the Philadelphia area and a former prosecutor, the pivotal moment occurred when special prosecutor Hank Brennan presented police dashcam footage from the crime scene. The video captured Read’s panicked reaction upon discovering her boyfriend unresponsive in the snow.

The defense asserted that a sloppy investigation and a disgraced lead detective left too many questions unanswered and prematurely accused Read of a crash that never happened.

Lawyer Hank Brennan in court during the Karen Read trial.

Prosecutor Hank Brennan, left, points to defendant Karen Read during closing arguments in Read’s murder trial in Norfolk Superior Court, Friday, June 13, 2025, in Dedham, Mass. (Mark Stockwell/The Sun Chronicle via AP, Pool)

“There was no collision,” Jackson told jurors three times to kick off his final argument. Furthermore, police didn’t investigate other potential sources of O’Keefe’s injuries, interview key witnesses or even follow protocols at the crime scene.

But Brennan countered that the defense theories are far-fetched and contradicted by clear evidence – the data from O’Keefe’s phone and Read’s car, as well as the taillight fragments embedded in his clothes.

“She was drunk. She hit him. And she left him to die,” Brennan said. “It’s that simple.”

O’Keefe, described by friends as a selfless 46-year-old who took in his orphaned niece and nephew, may even have survived if someone had called for help after he fell, Brennan suggested.

Gelman, who has won and lost in trials as both a prosecutor and a criminal defense attorney, said both sides put on powerful cases from start to finish.

“Both closed strong,” he said. “But if it’s even, that’s reasonable doubt.”

You May Also Like

Putin's war machine tied to troubling recruitment of young women as new deals emerge

Putin’s War Machine Linked to Alarming Recruitment of Young Women

Ghana and the Democratic Republic of the Congo have signed new agreements…
Deputy working security at South Carolina gun show fatally shoots customer who shot at him

South Carolina Deputy Working Gun Show Security Fatally Shoots Customer After Being Fired Upon

A South Carolina sheriff’s deputy working security at a gun and knife…
TikToker arrested after big cat mauls teen to death during video shoot at private farm

TikToker Arrested as Big Cat Kills Teen in Private Farm Video Shoot

A TikToker and a private farm owner have been arrested after a…
Trump border crackdown drives encounters to record October low as zero-release streak hits 18 months, DHS says

Trump Border Crackdown Drives Record-Low October Encounters, DHS Says

Rep. Pat Fallon urges Republicans to stay firm on border security Rep.…
Iran vows ‘we will find you’ to 2 US Navy officers the day warship returns from Middle East

Iran Threatens 2 US Navy Officers After Middle East Deployment

Iran’s embassy in South Africa issued a direct online threat against two…
Florida man sends letter filled with peanut butter to allergic ex-wife's friend: cops

Florida Man Accused of Peanut Butter Letter to Ex’s Allergic Friend

He’s nuts! A Florida man allegedly filled a card with peanut butter…
Mamdani guts elite NYPD tactical unit, backs 'civilian-led approach' to responding to protests

NYC Mayor Mamdani Cuts Elite NYPD Unit, Backs Civilian Protest Plan

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced Monday that the NYPD’s Strategic…
Ground stop shows

Ground Stop Halts Flights, Triggering Widespread Delays

Washington — Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said Sunday that the Federal Aviation…
Spain's Canary Islands flooded by thousands of migrants as country declares emergency

Canary Islands Declare Emergency as Thousands of Migrants Arrive

Thousands of migrants arrived in Spain’s Canary Islands over the weekend as…
San Diego Zoo elephant 'Nipho' dies from ‘unusually fast’ disease

San Diego Zoo Elephant Nipho Dies From Unusually Fast Disease

A 15-year-old elephant at the San Diego Zoo has died from a…
Massive El Niño-powered wave in Morro Bay wipes out group on shore

Massive El Niño Wave Sweeps Group Off Shore at Morro Bay

Massive waves reaching up to 30 feet battered California’s Central Coast over…
Murder suspect in 'Purge' mask identified -- after student killed on Halloween

Purge-Mask Murder Suspect Identified After Student Killed on Halloween

Colorado authorities have identified everyone shown in security footage released after a…