Judge rules some NIH grant cuts illegal, saying he's never seen such discrimination in 40 years

A federal judge determined on Monday that it was unlawful for the Trump administration to terminate several hundred research grants, noting that these cuts pose significant concerns regarding racial discrimination.

U.S. District Judge William Young in Massachusetts stated that the administration’s method was “arbitrary and capricious.” He highlighted that the process bypassed established governmental rules and standards when they suddenly cut grants aimed at exploring gender identity or diversity, equity, and inclusion.

During a hearing on two cases seeking the reinstatement of these grants, the judge challenged government attorneys to define DEI formally. He questioned the legitimacy of canceling grants for that reason, particularly when some of them were meant to examine health disparities, as directed by Congress.

Young, an appointee of Republican President Ronald Reagan, went on to address what he called “a darker aspect” to the cases, calling it “palpably clear” that what was behind the government actions was “racial discrimination and discrimination against America’s LGBTQ community.”

After 40 years on the bench, “I’ve never seen government racial discrimination like this,” Young added. He ended Monday’s hearing saying, “Have we no shame.”

During his remarks ending the hearing, the judge said he would issue his written order soon.

Young’s decision addresses only a fraction of the hundreds of NIH research projects the Trump administration has cut – those specifically addressed in two lawsuits filed separately this spring by 16 attorneys general, public health advocacy groups and some affected scientists. A full count wasn’t immediately available.

While Young said the funding must be restored, Monday’s action was an interim step as the ruling could be appealed.

The Trump administration is “exploring all legal options” including asking the judge to stay the ruling or appealing, said Andrew Nixon, a spokesman for NIH’s parent agency, the Department of Health and Human Services.

“HHS stands by its decision to end funding for research that prioritized ideological agendas over scientific rigor and meaningful outcomes for the American people,” he said in an email.

While the original lawsuits didn’t specifically claim racial discrimination, they said the new NIH policies prohibited “research into certain politically disfavored subjects.” In a filing this month after the lawsuits were consolidated, lawyers said the NIH did not highlight genuine concerns with the hundreds of canceled research projects studies, but instead sent “boilerplate termination letters” to universities.

The topics of research ranged widely, including cardiovascular health, sexually transmitted infections, depression, Alzheimer’s and alcohol abuse in minors, among other things. Attorneys cited projects such as one tracking how medicines may work differently in people of ancestrally diverse backgrounds, and said the cuts affected more than scientists – such as potential harm to patients in a closed study of suicide treatment.

Lawyers for the federal government said in a court filing earlier this month that NIH grant terminations for DEI studies were “sufficiently reasoned,” adding later that “plaintiffs may disagree with NIH’s basis, but that does not make the basis arbitrary and capricious.” The NIH, lawyers argued, has “broad discretion” to decide on and provide grants “in alignment with its priorities” – which includes ending grants.

Monday, Justice Department lawyer Thomas Ports Jr. pointed to 13 examples of grants related to minority health that NIH either hadn’t cut or had renewed in the same time period – and said some of the cancellations were justified by the agency’s judgement that the research wasn’t scientifically valuable.

The NIH has long been the world’s largest public funder of biomedical research.

The Associated Press Health and Science Department receives support from the Howard Hughes Medical Institute’s Science and Educational Media Group and the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. The AP is solely responsible for all content.

Copyright © 2025 by The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.

You May Also Like

Millions of Americans face flash flood threats as rain set to pound parts of Atlantic coast

Millions Face Flash Flood Threat as Heavy Rain Targets Atlantic Coast

JACKSONVILLE, Fla. — Millions of residents along Florida’s Atlantic Coast are facing…
MICHAEL RUIZ: New York's gutted police unit was more than a protest squad

Michael Ruiz: New York’s Gutted Police Unit Was More Than a Protest Squad

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani is moving to dissolve the NYPD’s…
Missing DoorDash driver’s wife slams rumors that she's 'in on' her husband's disappearance

Wife of Missing DoorDash Driver Denounces Claims She Was Involved in His Disappearance

The wife of missing DoorDash driver Zachariah “Zack” Schuck has reportedly pushed…
US intel picks up ‘very specific’ Iranian dirty bomb plot targeting Washington: report 

Report: US Intel Detects ‘Specific’ Iran Dirty Bomb Plot Targeting DC

US intelligence officials have reportedly uncovered an alleged Iranian plan to detonate…
South Carolina mother reveals troubling past of ex accused of burying their baby alive

South Carolina Mother Details Ex’s Troubling Past After He Is Accused of Burying Their Baby Alive

A South Carolina mother is breaking her silence after her 11-month-old son…
LA Metro plan for $25B train yard in wealthy enclave sparks backlash

LA Metro’s $25B Train Yard Plan Sparks Wealthy Enclave Backlash

Angry residents confronted Los Angeles transit officials during a heated meeting about…
California sheriff's deputy, special officer put on leave after 5-second conversation with ICE agents

California Deputy, Special Officer Put on Leave Over ICE Talk

Two employees of the Orange County Sheriff’s Department have been placed on…
Ivy League student slashed in neck, suspect accused was arrested just weeks before

Ivy League student slashed in neck; suspect was arrested weeks earlier

A man is facing charges after police say a college student was…
The Post's 225 icons: How Lorne Michaels turned 'SNL' into an institution

How Lorne Michaels Turned Saturday Night Live Into a Cultural Institution

To mark our 225th birthday, The New York Post is celebrating Gotham’s…
State Department presses Egypt to respect religious freedom as Christian convert faces possible execution

US Presses Egypt as Christian Convert Faces Execution Over Faith

The U.S. State Department is stepping up pressure on Egypt to uphold…
Chase Bank outages today: Chicago-area JPMorgan Chase customers impacted by online banking issues, 'software bug'

Chase Outage Hits Chicago as Software Bug Disrupts Online Banking

CHICAGO () — JPMorgan Chase said banking transactions have returned to normal…
Man legally named Captain America charged with murder after allegedly giving victim’s girlfriend chilling note

Man Legally Named Captain America Charged With Murder After Note

Captain C. America, right, faces a first-degree murder charge in the death…