Jay Sullivan, an AIPAC lobbyist from Arkansas, posted on X, “Jewish lives matter more than anyone’s,” igniting widespread condemnation.
A viral photo allegedly showing Sullivan responding to a video of a burning Palestinian child with “This is how Israel deals with antisemites. Americans against Israel should learn from this” intensified the outrage.
Sullivan chose to privatize and subsequently delete his X profile following the intense criticism. Noel Fritsch, the publisher of National File, issued a letter to AIPAC seeking clarification on the group’s viewpoint, accusing them of promoting Jewish supremacy.
Jay Sullivan, identified as an AIPAC representative in Arkansas, made the inflammatory X post at approximately on June 20, 2025.
The remarks sparked considerable discussion, with reactions such as, “No more trying to do it covertly, all OVERT!” Some accused Sullivan of being an “AIPAC puppet,” suggesting he prioritized Jewish lives over others and threatened Americans.
The viral photo of Sullivan’s alleged response to the Palestinian child video further escalated accusations of extremism.
Shortly after posting, Sullivan made his X account private and then deleted it, leading to speculation about AIPAC’s potential role. On X, critics speculated that AIPAC might have instructed Sullivan to restrict or remove the post to minimize fallout. As of June 21, 2025, AIPAC has neither confirmed nor denied these assertions.
National File publisher Noel Fritsch sent a letter to press@aipac.org, questioning AIPAC’s response to Sullivan’s actions.
Fritsch’s letter questioned if AIPAC directed Sullivan to protect his account, if the tweet was deleted, and if AIPAC supports Sullivan’s claim.
Fritsch also raised concerns about “credible claims of Jewish Supremacy” linked to Zionism and inquired about AIPAC’s plans to atone, including whether Sullivan would be fired and his salary redirected to support displaced Christians in the Levant.
An AIPAC lobbyist in Arkansas posted recently on X that “Jewish lives matter more than anyone’s.”
He subsequently protected his account.
Did AIPAC direct Sullivan to protect the account? Has Sullivan deleted the tweet?
Does AIPAC agree with Sullivan’s assertion that Jewish lives matter more than the lives of all other ethnicities?
Credible claims of Jewish Supremacy have been made recently, as awareness of the true roots of Zionism have proliferated.
What is AIPAC doing to atone for its Jewish Supremacy?
Will AIPAC fire Sullivan and donate his salary to supporting Christians displaced in war-torn settlements in the Levant?
Thanks for your time and attention to this matter.
Noel Fritsch
Publisher
National File
Fritsch’s letter reflects a broader sentiment questioning whether AIPAC endorses or tolerates supremacist rhetoric.
The backlash against Sullivan’s post has amplified calls for accountability. Jewish American groups, such as Jewish Voice for Peace, have previously criticized AIPAC for misrepresenting Jewish values and stifling dissent on Israel’s policies.
A 2024 statement by prominent Jewish Americans condemned AIPAC’s electoral interventions, arguing they ensure unwavering U.S. support for Israel despite human rights concerns. Sullivan’s remarks risk further alienating these critics, who see them as emblematic of deeper ideological issues.
