Share this @internewscast.com
Relief over a landmark court win has been short-lived for a transgender teenager’s mother after an Australian-first puberty blocker ban was reinstated.
The mother claimed victory after the Queensland government’s ban was overturned in the Supreme Court on Tuesday, saying it brought an end to a harrowing ordeal.
However, Queensland Health Minister Tim Nicholls confirmed hours later that he would issue a ministerial direction that would restore the puberty block pause in Queensland.
The mother’s devastated supporters on Tuesday night said they would discuss their legal options.

A mother, whose identity remains protected for legal reasons, recently spearheaded a groundbreaking legal challenge against the government’s decision to cease hormone treatment for transgender minors.

She did not hide her relief after Supreme Court Justice Peter Callaghan set aside the ban in a judgement delivered on Tuesday.
“This has been a harrowing and traumatising ordeal,” the mother said through her lawyer.
“I’m incredibly relieved it is over and that justice has been achieved by my child and the other young people affected by this ban.”

In a pivotal decision, Judge Callaghan overturned this ban, highlighting the rushed nature of the decision-making process. Queensland Health executives had been given a mere 22 minutes to consider a directive that would impose a ban on hormone therapy for the youth.

The case was based on whether Queensland’s health service made an independent decision with proper public consultation to halt puberty blockers.
“The only way that was argued that [the Queensland Health CEO] complied with this requirement is by reason of a video-conference which lasted for about 22 minutes,” said Callaghan who ordered Queensland’s health service pay the mother’s legal costs.

It’s important to note that the judgement did not delve into the validity or effectiveness of puberty blockers themselves.

In defense of the decision, Nicholls remarked, “I’m satisfied it is appropriate and in the public interest that I issue a written ministerial direction to all hospital and health services with immediate effect.” He emphasized the state’s responsibility, stating, “As parents, as communities, and as a state, we owe it to children to ensure care is grounded on solid evidence and we act with caution.”

Nicholls late on Tuesday confirmed the ban would be reinstated via a ministerial direction.
“The Supreme Court was concerned with the circumstances of the making of the directive, not whether a pause … was appropriate,” he told parliament.

However, this stance has faced criticism. Heather Corkhill, legal director at Equality Australia, expressed dismay over the government’s intentions, stating, “It’s deeply disappointing that the minister is threatening to double down on a policy that has already caused so much harm.”

The ministerial direction to ban puberty blockers would not affect people who were already on a treatment plan, he said.

“As parents, as communities and as a state, we owe it to children to ensure care is grounded on solid evidence and we act with caution,” Nicholls said.

Latest move could be challenged

The mother’s supporters said the state government may have opened itself up to a legal challenge with its latest decision.

“It’s deeply disappointing that the minister is threatening to double down on a policy that has already caused so much harm,” Equality Australia legal director Heather Corkhill said.

A group of transgender advocates celebrating outside court. Most have their hands raised in the air. A transgender flag is being held.

Supporters celebrating the decision to overturn the ban outside the Supreme Court of Queensland in Brisbane on Tuesday. Source: AAP / Darren England

“The government could also be back in hot water by opening itself up to a further legal challenge.”

Nicholls’ ministerial directions must be backed by evidence that they are in the public interest, she said.
“That means promoting public health and safety, improving service quality, and protecting vulnerable people,” she said.
“Denying young people access to evidence-based, safe and effective healthcare does none of those things
“It’s also incredibly offensive for the government to suggest that parents can’t be trusted to make the right medical decisions for their own children.”
Queensland was the first Australian state to ban hormone treatments for children diagnosed with gender dysphoria, following claims puberty blockers had been given to kids as young as 12 without authorised care.
Under the ban, hormone therapies are no longer accessible to new patients aged under 18 as the government awaits a review into the treatment.
The review into hormone treatment for children with gender dysphoria was due to provide a final report by the end of November.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
The lines waiting for the London Pub in Paddington on Anzac Day.

Aussies Gather in Droves for Thrilling Two-Up Games

It is the one day of the year when Australians can enjoy…

Controversial Methods Approved: US Sanctions Firing Squads, Electrocution, and Gas Chambers for Federal Executions

In Brief The Trump administration plans to firing squads, electrocution and gas…
Michelle Stalimeros (pictured) grew up in a 'chaotic' home where alcohol was woven into family life

Weekend Wine Habit Triggered Blackouts and Anxiety, Straining Marriage; Reflecting on Three Years of Sobriety

At first glance, Michelle Stalimeros appeared far from someone struggling with alcohol.…
Treasurer Jim Chalmers handed down the Budget on Tuesday night, boasting of a $9.3 billion surplus driven by a strong labour market and increased commodity prices

Budget 2024 Unveiled: $300 Cash Boost for Australians, Student Debt Forgiveness, Tax Cuts, and New Travel Policies by Albanese Government

In a strategic move to garner voter support ahead of elections, the…
Several beaches south of Sydney have been closed after a dead whale washed up onto the shore.

Whale Tragedy: Dead Whale Prompts Closure of Several Sydney Beaches

Several beaches located just south of Sydney have been shut down after…
Benjamin Netanyahu

Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu Discloses Secret Cancer Treatment Amidst Political Turmoil

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu quietly underwent treatment for prostate cancer, he…

20 Years Later: Beaconsfield Mine Tragedy Celebrates Australian Resilience and Humor

Two decades have passed since the Beaconsfield mine tragedy in Tasmania, yet…
One community member pays her respects at the Reservoir RSL sub-branch this morning.

Outrage Sparks as Anzac Day RSL Vandalism Leads to Charges Against Two Women

Two women, aged 20 and 22, are facing charges after allegedly being…

Fluctuating Fuel Costs, Employment Trends, and a New Tax Incentive: Key Insights You Need to Know

This week has been a whirlwind of events. Global markets experienced heightened…

Australian Women Confront Tough Decisions Amid National Crisis

in brief Experts are warning that the cost of living crisis is…
James Comer is planning on investigating the Biden administration.

Shocking Twist: Congress Considers Controversial Ghislaine Maxwell Pardon

There is a growing number of US members of Congress pushing for…
Anzac soldiers

Partial Remains of Australian Soldiers from WWI Finally Laid to Rest Over a Century Later

The partial remains of eight Australian soldiers have been laid to rest…