Body of Shinnecock Bay kayaker recovered, 2nd still missing

Late Sunday, authorities discovered the body of one of two kayakers who went missing over the weekend in Shinnecock Bay, Long Island. The search for the second kayaker resumed Monday morning.

The search began after 27-year-old Shane Garcia and 25-year-old Aaron Marano failed to return from their kayaking trip. Garcia’s girlfriend alerted authorities at 8:44 p.m. on Saturday when the pair did not come back as anticipated. Before vanishing, they had sent her a photo taken near the Ponquogue Bridge.

New York State Police divers recovered Garcia’s body from the bay on Sunday night, according to reports from ABC News and other media outlets. The search for Marano was paused Sunday night due to darkness but resumed at first light on Monday.

Shane Garcia, left, and Aaron Marano.
Shane Garcia, left, and Aaron Marano.

The search effort has been extensive, involving drones, ATVs, and a Suffolk police helicopter, as confirmed by Town of Southampton police spokeswoman Detective Sergeant Gina Laferrera to Newsday. Additionally, the U.S. Coast Guard joined the operation at 6 a.m. on Sunday, according to Southampton police Sergeant Michael Walsh.

The investigation commenced after Garcia’s work van was located Saturday parked at the end of Shinnecock Avenue in Hampton Bays. By midday Sunday, state and Southampton Town marine patrol units discovered two kayaks and paddles washed up near Shinnecock East County Park. This led investigators to focus on a specific area where they eventually found Garcia’s body.

You May Also Like
New Mexico seeks massive penalty from Meta after jury found tech giant liable for endangering children

New Mexico Demands Massive Meta Penalty After Jury Finds Facebook Parent Liable for Endangering Children

New Mexico’s Department of Justice is pushing to make Meta pay far…
South Carolina personal trainer goes missing, last spotted walking toward wooded area

SLED Joins Investigation After Body Found Matches Description of Missing South Carolina Personal Trainer

South Carolina’s lead investigative agency, the State Law Enforcement Division (SLED), joined…
Hollywood Is Having An Inflection Moment As Established Properties Are Getting Hammered by the Upstarts

Hollywood Inflection Point: New Upstarts Overtake Established Franchises at the Box Office

Through this point in 2026, the domestic box office has posted an…
Coast Guard opens fire on boat smuggling 25 Chinese nationals near Florida after it refused to stop

US Coast Guard Fires on Smuggling Boat Carrying 25 Chinese Migrants Off Florida After Pursuit

The U.S. Coast Guard fired on a boat off the Florida coast…
Karmelo Anthony claims he's penniless as business records tied to parents draw scrutiny

Karmelo Anthony Says He Is Broke as Parents’ Business Records Face Scrutiny

MCKINNEY, Texas – As convicted killer Karmelo Anthony asks for a taxpayer-funded…
Lansing news: Former employee Devon Johnson charged in deadly shooting of Andrew Coleman at Nippon Paint Automotive Americas

Lansing: Former Nippon Paint Automotive Americas Employee Devon Johnson Charged in Fatal Shooting of Andrew Coleman

LANSING, Ill. (WLS) — A former employee has been charged with murder…
'Happy Face' killer warns fellow serial killer Rex Heuermann could be 'tossed to the wolves' in prison

‘Happy Face’ killer says accused serial killer Rex Heuermann could face danger in prison

Keith Jesperson — the “Happy Face” serial killer who has been corresponding…
Chicago crime: Suspect Merlin Lu, 21, charged with hate crime, arson for burning cross in Grant Park, police say

Chicago Police Charge 21-Year-Old Merlin Lu With Hate Crime, Arson After Cross Burning in Grant Park

CHICAGO (WLS) — A 21-year-old Chicago man is facing a series of…
Giants Broadcaster Criticizes Players Wearing Bible Verses for Pride Night

Giants Broadcaster Slams Players’ Bible Verse Display on Pride Night, Sparking Controversy

San Francisco Giants broadcaster Mike Krukow has spoken out against the players…
G7 leaders back Trump's plan to end Iran war that faces skepticism at home

G7 Leaders Endorse Trump’s Iran War Exit Plan Amid Skepticism at Home

EVIAN-LES-BAINS, France — Leaders at the Group of Seven summit on Wednesday…
Jonathan Wilson charged in Uptown, Chicago police shooting on Argyle after condo board president shot, killed: CPD

Jonathan Wilson charged after fatal shooting of condo board president in Uptown, Chicago police say

CHICAGO (WLS) — A 38-year-old Chicago man is facing multiple felony charges,…
Senior US officials dictate memorandum with Iran to journalists+

US Officials Quietly Shape Iran Memorandum Through Journalist Briefings

Senior U.S. officials on Wednesday briefed reporters on the memorandum of understanding…