Elk Grove Village murder: Arturo Taylor charged in stabbing death of Colleen Bagley, found outside of hotel at Landmeier, Higgins

ELK GROVE VILLAGE, Ill. — Police have charged a man from the north suburbs with the stabbing death of a woman he was staying with in a hotel room, authorities reported.

The woman’s body was discovered earlier this week near a dumpster outside the hotel in Elk Grove Village.

Authorities confirmed on Friday that the case is being treated as a homicide. An autopsy revealed that the victim succumbed to multiple “sharp-force” injuries.

ABC7 Chicago is now streaming 24/7. Click here to watch

The deceased has been identified by Elk Grove Village police as 50-year-old Colleen Bagley of Fox Lake.

During the investigation, 54-year-old Arturo F. Taylor, also of Fox Lake, was apprehended. He is now facing charges of first-degree murder in connection with the incident.

A suspect in her death, 54-year-old Arturo F. Taylor of Fox Lake, was arrested during the investigation, police said. He has been charged with first-degree murder.

Investigators said the two were sharing a hotel room. Taylor allegedly stabbed Bagley multiple times after a dispute in their hotel room.

Her body was found just after 4:15 a.m. Wednesday, near a refuse dumpster outside the extended-stay hotel off Landmeier and Higgins Road in Elk Grove Village, police said.

Investigators spent most of the day processing the scene. Elk Grove Village police called the death suspicious at the time, but assured the public it was an isolated incident.

“I just freaked and I couldn’t believe it,” Eva Wypych told ABC7 on Wednesday. “I saw body covered with the blanket.”

Wypych was staying at the hotel off Landmeier and Higgins Road and says she saw the body and investigators on the scene as soon as she stepped out for her early morning walk.

The Major Case Assistance Team responded alongside police. Investigators were seen going through dumpsters near the hotel, collecting multiple bags of evidence.

Wypych said hotel guests have heard reports of what may have played out, but so far investigators have not released details on the woman’s death.

“This, it just breaks my heart. People should love one another, care for one another,” Wypych said. “Nobody deserved that. We all created by God, and only God could take you.”

Police believe this was an isolated incident, and there is no threat to the community.

Taylor appeared in court Saturday for a detention hearing.

No further information was available.

Copyright © 2026 WLS-TV. All Rights Reserved.

You May Also Like
Missing tortoise reunited with family after Missouri search

Lost tortoise reunited with family after search in Missouri

A 50-pound sulcata tortoise from Missouri is back where she belongs after…
Suspected California double murder fugitive arrested in Laos, returned to US

California Double-Murder Suspect Captured in Laos, Brought Back to the U.S.

A California murder suspect accused in two separate killings has been returned…
Teenager shot during Knicks madness takeover in Times Square

Teenager Shot Amid Knicks Celebration Crowds in Times Square

A 17-year-old was shot in the foot during chaotic celebrations in Times…
Knicks hosting NYC watch parties as team looks to clinch NBA championship

Knicks Plan NYC Watch Parties as Team Eyes Chance to Clinch NBA Title

The celebration is back on for Knicks fans. As the team tries…
NYC pilot, passenger rescued after wave slams seaplane near Throggs Neck Bridge

Wave Slams Seaplane Near NYC’s Throggs Neck Bridge, Pilot and Passenger Rescued

A seaplane pilot and his passenger were pulled from the East River…
Clear CEO found her American dream on Wall Street

Clear CEO found the American dream on Wall Street

Through July 4, The Post, in partnership with the Milken Center for…
Merrillville, Indiana tornado damage: EF-2 tornado wind speed destroys homes; Illinois tornadoes also cause storm damage

Merrillville, Indiana EF-2 Tornado Destroys Homes as Severe Storms Spark Damage Across Illinois

Recovery efforts were still underway Saturday in several communities hit by this…
Knicks fans ignite school bus on fire

Knicks Fans Set School Bus Ablaze During Postgame Unrest

Celebrations over Knicks mania spiraled into chaos in Times Square, where fans…
Residents wake up screaming as cops race to rescue them from late-night apartment blaze: video

Late-Night Apartment Fire Sparks Dramatic Police Rescue as Residents Flee in Panic on Video

Residents of a Utah apartment complex were jolted awake in the early…
New York Knicks win first NBA title since 1973 with 94-90 victory over San Antonio Spurs in Game 5

Knicks End 51-Year Drought, Beat Spurs 94-90 in Game 5 to Win First NBA Championship Since 1973

SAN ANTONIO — Jalen Brunson and the never-say-die Knicks delivered one more…
‘Hell on wheels’ killer Mackenzie Shirilla lands prison job while serving life sentence for fatal 2022 crash

Mackenzie Shirilla Gets Prison Job While Serving Life Sentence in 2022 Fatal Crash Case

Convicted killer Mackenzie Shirilla has been assigned a prison job as she…
Woman airlifted to hospital with serious injuries after shark attack at popular Sydney beach

Shark Attack at Popular Sydney Beach Leaves Woman Seriously Injured, Airlifted to Hospital

A 30-year-old woman was taken to a hospital on Saturday after suffering…