Throughout medieval Europe, the nobility often sparked fashion crazes and controversies with their choice of poulaines—extravagant footwear characterized by their dramatically extended pointed toes, which could far exceed the natural length of the foot.

“A seasoned wearer of dress shoes understands that initially they might feel a bit snug, leading to some blisters, but eventually, they’ll soften, expand, and become extremely comfortable,” FitzPatrick remarked.

Florsheim offers a sizing tip on its website, advising, “If you’re in between sizes, opt for the larger one. Remember that athletic shoes generally run a half size bigger than dress or casual shoes. So, if you’re a size 10 in athletic shoes, you’re likely a 9.5 in dress or casual shoes.”

However, FitzPatrick pointed out that Florsheim shoes aren’t what they once were.

The company has transitioned its production overseas, with manufacturing now taking place in countries like Cambodia, China, India, Mexico, and the Dominican Republic.

Nevertheless, according to Peskowitz, Florsheim shoes generally fit true to size. While the style Trump has been promoting is “typically more narrow,” that alone doesn’t explain the significant size discrepancy in the shoes.

“There is a certain juvenile reasoning that might make men want to wear bigger shoes that I won’t repeat here,” he said.

“But generally no. I don’t see people wearing the wrong shoe size as any kind of fashion statement.”

Where did Vance and Rubio go astray?

Did they misremember their sizes? Did they try to get them pre-loosened rather than letting them stretch? Do they prefer the ideal of the feet they wish they had to the reality rattling around inside their new shoes? Or have they simply fallen victim to the oscillation issues plaguing American footwear?

“I wouldn’t put this on Florsheim,” said Jake Woolf, a menswear content creator.

“It seems just like a skill issue and/or user error.”

NEVER MISS A STORY: Get your breaking news and exclusive stories first by following us across all platforms.