Missing woman’s sister says Nancy Guthrie case now a ‘hope roller coaster’ for family as search continues

The search for Nancy Guthrie has surpassed the 50-day mark without any breakthroughs, a situation that strikes fear into the hearts of families with missing loved ones. Julie Murray, who has spent over 20 years looking for her own sister, understands this anguish all too well. Her sister, Maura Murray, disappeared in New Hampshire back in 2004.

“What the Guthrie family is going through is something I recognize instantly,” Murray remarked. “It’s an experience that stays with you. You can see it etched in their expressions and hear it in their desperate pleas.”

Murray pointed out that missing person cases often start with a flurry of attention, involving extensive resources, media focus, and public interest. However, this initial momentum can wane over time, leaving families to shoulder the burden alone.

Maura Murray was known for her talent in long-distance running, as her sister Julie fondly recalls.

Maura Murray running long distance in her West Point uniform.

“Most families have to battle just to have their voices heard and to garner the level of attention they deserve,” Julie Murray explained. “Unfortunately, some families never receive any attention at all.”

“Most families… have to fight to be heard and beg for that level of attention,” she said. “And some families don’t get any at all.”

That attention, she emphasized, can be lifesaving.

“Media pressure saves lives.”

Nancy Guthrie posing for a photo.

An undated photo of Nancy Guthrie provided by NBC in response to the disappearance of the 84-year-old mother of Today Show host Savannah Guthrie. (Courtesy of NBC)

Nancy Guthrie, 84, was last seen Feb. 1 after being dropped off at her Tucson, Arizona home. Authorities believe she was taken against her will in the early morning hours.

Surveillance video captured a masked man, described as average height and build, approaching her home carrying a black backpack and what appeared to be a handgun. Investigators say Guthrie’s phone and watch were later recovered inside the home, while her pacemaker last synced with her Apple devices around 2:30 a.m., helping establish a possible timeline.

Despite weeks of investigation, authorities have not announced a suspect. Pima County Sheriff Chris Nanos has said Guthrie was likely targeted.

Pima County Sheriff Chris Nanos speaks about Nancy Guthrie disappearance

Pima County Sheriff Chris Nanos gives an update on the investigation after the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie on Feb. 5, 2026.  (Rebecca Noble/Reuters)

The case has drawn national attention, driven in part by emotional public appeals from Guthrie’s daughter, NBC “Today” anchor Savannah Guthrie.

“Someone needs to do the right thing. We are in agony,” Guthrie said in a preview of her first formal interview since her mother’s disappearance.

In the same interview, she described the toll the uncertainty has taken.

“I wake up every night in the middle of the night… and in the darkness, I imagine her terror,” she said. “She needs to come home now.”

Authorities are urging anyone with information to contact the FBI tip line.

Murray said the level of attention surrounding the Guthrie case can generate a surge of tips, but not all are actionable.

Deputies outside Nancy Guthrie's home

Deputies examine a flyer taped to Nancy Guthrie’s mailbox on Sunday, Feb. 22, 2026. They were called to the scene after volunteer searchers and several streamers walked onto Guthrie’s property with a shovel. (Michael Ruiz/Fox News Digital)

“You’re begging the public for information, but at the same time you’re getting speculation and hearsay,” she said. “Some of those tips you just can’t chase down.”

Her family, she said, still receives tips more than 20 years after her sister vanished, none of which have led to answers.

Each one, however, carries emotional weight.

“I call it the hope roller coaster,” Murray said. “You want it to be the one that breaks the case open… and then it doesn’t.”

Retired LAPD Detective Moses Castillo said that emotional toll is already visible in the Guthrie family’s public appeals.

“You can feel every ounce of her pain, her strength, and her desperation,” Castillo said. “That kind of resolve matters. It moves people. It forces attention.”

Two images of the Nancy Guthrie suspect on her porch.

A source familiar tells Fox News Digital that two photos of the suspect in the Nancy Guthrie doorbell video were taken on different days. (FBI )

He described Savannah Guthrie’s interview as “a call to action” that could help generate new leads.

Murray warned that one of the most difficult turning points in a case comes when investigators exhaust immediate leads.

For Murray’s family, that moment came just weeks after Maura disappeared.

“The worst day wasn’t the day she went missing,” she said. “It was the day we were told they had done all they could.”

From that point forward, she said, the responsibility shifted to the family to keep pushing for answers—through media coverage, public pressure and independent efforts.

“You can’t let up on the pressure,” she said.

Doorbell camera footage of the suspect in Nancy Guthrie's disappearance

The FBI released new surveillance footage of the suspect in the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie on February 1, 2026. (X/ @FBI DirectorPatel)

Investigators have said the Guthrie case remains active, but have also warned the public not to assume there is no ongoing threat.

Families also face growing challenges as cases gain visibility, including online speculation and bad actors.

“Trust becomes a casualty,” Murray said, warning that some individuals attempt to exploit high-profile cases or spread misinformation.

More than two decades later, Murray said her family has come to terms with the likelihood that her sister is no longer alive—but they are still searching for answers.

“There’s no such thing as closure,” she said. “It’s resolution.”

For families like the Guthries, that means continuing to push for answers, while hoping the right tip finally comes in.

Authorities are asking anyone with information about Nancy Guthrie’s disappearance to contact the FBI tip line at 1-800-CALL-FBI. A combined reward of more than $1 million is being offered for information leading to her return.

Stepheny Price covers crime, including missing persons, homicides and migrant crime. Send story tips to stepheny.price@fox.com.

You May Also Like

Mother charged with murder for refusing to give toddler son cancer care

Mother Charged With Murder After Refusing Cancer Treatment for Toddler Son

The mother of a 3-year-old boy who died weighing just 24 pounds…
Zelenskyy says Russia strikes hometown, criticizes Putin-Trump meeting

Zelenskyy Says Russia Struck His Hometown, Criticizes Putin-Trump Meeting

Democratic leaders condemn Trump after Putin-Xi summit in China Steve Yates defended…
The Post’s 225 icons: George Washington’s surprise attack was America’s greatest Christmas gift

George Washington’s Surprise Attack: Why the Post Calls It America’s Greatest Christmas Gift

As The New York Post marks its 225th birthday, we’re celebrating the…
Texas execution took over an hour as staff struggled to find vein:

Texas Execution Lasted Over an Hour as Staff Sought a Vein

Texas carried out the execution of Reinaldo Dennes on Thursday after prison…
135 homeless squatters refuse to leave radioactive California Superfund site

135 Homeless Squatters Defy Eviction at California Superfund Site

Dozens of unhoused people have made their homes at a radioactive waste…
DSA fails to open Staten Island outpost

Democratic Socialists of America Fails to Open Staten Island Chapter Office

An effort by Staten Island activists to establish an independent Democratic Socialists…
Jewish legal group urges US to strip visa from Calvin Robinson

Jewish Legal Group Seeks US Visa Revocation for UK Cleric Calvin Robinson

The American Association of Jewish Lawyers and Jurists has asked Yehuda Kaploun,…
Harvard scientist pushes back on NASA chief over mystery space object: 'It's not an asteroid'

Harvard Scientist’s Mission to Prove Mysterious Space Object’s Origin Is Scrapped

A Harvard astrophysicist who believes a puzzling object racing through the solar…
$3.3M Encino home targeted by burglars in home invasion

Burglars Target $3.3M Encino Home in Brazen Home Invasion

Two burglars broke into a $3.3 million home in Encino on Friday…
Masked ICE agents drag passengers off Seattle jet bridge, delaying LA flight

ICE Agents Drag Passengers Off Seattle Jet Bridge, Delay LA Flight

A Thanksgiving trip descended into an airport confrontation after masked ICE agents…
AOC spent $12K on glam German digs while pushing for 'working class' rights

AOC’s $12K Luxury German Stay Amid Workers’ Rights Push

Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez spent roughly $9,000 on hotel rooms alone during a…
Illegal immigrant avoids charges after Florida grandmother killed outside grocery store, enraging family

Illegal Immigrant Avoids Charges After Florida Grandmother Is Killed

Prosecutors have dismissed the criminal case against an undocumented immigrant accused of…