Andrew Garay, US Army veteran and dad killed in Humboldt Park, Chicago shooting, remembered as selfless, hardworking
Share this @internewscast.com

A man has been charged in connection with the murder of a young father and U.S. Army veteran on Chicago’s Northwest Side earlier this year, according to Chicago police. The announcement came on Saturday, shedding light on the January incident that left the community in mourning.

Jonathan Roldan, a 35-year-old resident of Chicago, was taken into custody on Thursday. He faces a first-degree murder charge stemming from the fatal shooting that occurred on January 23.

ABC7 Chicago is now streaming 24/7. Click here to watch

Authorities allege that Roldan shot 30-year-old Andrew Garay while Garay was seated in his vehicle on the 3500 block of West Wabansia Avenue in the Humboldt Park neighborhood. The incident took place around 9 p.m., marking a tragic end to that evening.

Back in January, ABC7 interviewed Garay’s family, who shared their grief and memories of him.

“He kissed me on my forehead three hours before and said, ‘Mom, I’ll be back in a little bit,'” recalled Debbie Knutt, Garay’s mother, as she recounted those final moments with her son.

According to Garay’s family, he had just dropped off his girlfriend and her daughter at their home before the sound of gunfire broke the night’s silence.

“They just got out of the car,” said Samantha Knutt, the victim’s sister. “They were up right at the apartment door when it happened.”

Why anyone would want to harm Garay has been a mystery to his loved ones.

“It’s just been complete shock, honestly. I don’t think any of us really genuinely know how to feel or even accept that he’s gone,” Samantha said.

They remember him as selfless, hardworking, and someone who got along with everyone.

“Andrew just exuded this presence that made you feel safe, and he made you feel happy like I’ve never seen anybody, not like Andrew,” said Karjan Dambaugh, the victim’s cousin. “If he loved you, he loved with everything… He was the person that would show up randomly and just make everything right.”

Garay’s family said he lived on the Northwest Side, and after leaving the Army, worked as a package delivery driver. He leaves behind a 7-year-old daughter.

“He would do anything under the sun for that girl. If she needed anything, okay, daddy’s got it. You want to play games? Daddy’s got it,” Samantha said.

Relatives say Garay aspired to be a Chicago police officer and was working toward applying.

Roldan is due in court on Sunday.

The video in the player above is from a previous report.

INTERACTIVE SAFETY TRACKER Track crime and safety in your neighborhood

Copyright © 2026 WLS-TV. All Rights Reserved.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Englewood, Chicago crime: Jacob Bogdan arrested, accused of being ax-wielding man, targets Chicago Fire Department cars

Englewood Incident: Jacob Bogdan Apprehended for Allegedly Vandalizing Chicago Fire Department Vehicles with an Axe

A Chicago man faces charges after allegedly defacing vehicles owned by firefighters…
EXCLUSIVE INTERVIEW: Lee Brice’s Stirring 'When the Kingdom Comes': a Poignant Musical Exploration of Compassion, Hope, and Faith

Exclusive: Lee Brice Unveils Heartfelt Journey in ‘When the Kingdom Comes’ – A Musical Tapestry of Compassion and Faith

(NASHVILLE, TN) Picture this: a child yearning for food on a grimy…
Second arrest made in 'drive-by style' shooting in Lake City

Second Suspect Apprehended in Lake City Drive-By Shooting Incident

The Lake City Police Department has confirmed the arrest of a second…
Murder suspect on ICE hold accused of luring teen into death trap where victim’s final plea went unheard

Community Outcry Intensifies Over Alleged Teen Execution by Illegal Immigrant Amid ‘Invasion’ Claims

The tragic death of a 15-year-old boy in Missouri, who pleaded for…
Pura Vida Miami makes menu changes after uproar over popular tuna sandwich

Pura Vida Miami Revamps Menu Following Public Outcry Over Beloved Tuna Sandwich

The tuna sandwich has hit a snag. Pura Vida Miami, the celebrated…
9-year-old was found locked in a van since 2024, malnourished and unable to walk in Hagenbach, France

Shocking Discovery: 9-Year-Old Rescued Malnourished and Immobilized After Year-Long Van Confinement in Hagenbach, France

In a shocking turn of events, a young boy, aged 9, has…
Staffers for Rep. Swalwell 'Horrified' Over Sexual Assault Allegations

Shocking Allegations: Rep. Swalwell’s Team Reacts to Disturbing Sexual Assault Claims

Staff members of Representative Eric Swalwell’s office and his gubernatorial campaign have…
US, Iran fail to reach peace agreement after marathon talks in Pakistan

US-Iran Peace Talks in Pakistan End Without Agreement

ISLAMABAD, Pakistan — Despite intensive peace negotiations held in Pakistan, Vice President…
Florida gubernatorial candidate arrested after reported 'weapons disturbance'

Florida Gubernatorial Hopeful Arrested Amidst ‘Weapons Disturbance’ Allegations

In a surprising turn of events, a man campaigning for the governorship…
Pet charity quits Los Angeles after City hits them with huge bill

Animal Welfare Organization Exits Los Angeles Following Substantial City-Imposed Fees

A volunteer-driven animal rescue organization, dedicated to reducing the alarming number of…
Trump cheered at UFC 327 as he attends fight alongside daughter Tiffany, Secretary of State Marco Rubio

Donald Trump Receives Warm Welcome at UFC 327 with Daughter Tiffany and Marco Rubio in Attendance

On Saturday night, President Trump made a notable appearance at UFC 327,…
LA's top federal prosecutor makes staggering claim about scale of California fraud

California Fraud Scandal Unveiled: LA’s Chief Prosecutor Reveals Massive Scope of Deception

California has been rocked by revelations of a significant Medi-Cal fraud scheme,…