Jonathan Roldan killed ex-girlfriend's boyfriend, US Army veteran Andrew Garay, in Humboldt Park, Chicago shooting: prosecutors
Share this @internewscast.com

A man is facing charges after allegedly shooting and killing his ex-girlfriend’s boyfriend on Chicago’s Northwest Side in January, according to prosecutors.

The family of the victim, 30-year-old Andrew Garay, expressed relief outside the courtroom on Sunday, grateful that a suspect has been apprehended for the murder.

ABC7 Chicago is now streaming 24/7. Click here to watch

“One of our biggest fears was that no one would be held accountable. We’re relieved that justice is being pursued,” said Karjan Dambaugh, Garay’s cousin.

The suspect, identified as 35-year-old Jonathan Roldan, was taken into custody late last week in connection with the shooting that occurred on January 23.

Garay, a U.S. Army veteran, had been in a relationship with Roldan’s former partner for several years. Roldan had a long-standing relationship of 17 years with her and shares two children with her.

Prosecutors revealed that witnesses quickly identified Roldan as a suspect during the investigation. Surveillance footage also reportedly captured him at the crime scene on the night of the shooting.

Garay had just dropped his girlfriend off at her home in the Humboldt Park neighborhood and was waiting for her to go inside, prosecutors said. Roldan allegedly walked up from the gangway and fired one shot through the driver’s side window, hitting Garay in the forehead and killing him.

“He was assassinated. This wasn’t spur-of-the-moment. This was planned. It was clear from the beginning,” Dambaugh said.

Garay had a 7-year-old daughter. His family says his loss has been very difficult to deal with.

“I still struggled Daly with believing he’s gone. There are times I grabbed my phone with the instinct of calling him or sending him a quick text, and then, it hits us all over again,” Dambaugh said.

Roldan is charged with first-degree murder. The judge ordered him held in jail pending trial. His next court appearance is scheduled for next week.

The video in the player above is from a previous report.

INTERACTIVE SAFETY TRACKER Track crime and safety in your neighborhood

Copyright © 2026 WLS-TV. All Rights Reserved.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
‘Baby Jessica’ arrested in Texas following alleged domestic disturbance

Former ‘Baby Jessica’ Involved in Texas Domestic Incident, Authorities Report

Jessica McClure Morales, famously known as “Baby Jessica” after her dramatic 1987…
'Future on the front line'

Exploring the Cutting-Edge Roles Shaping Tomorrow’s World

In a groundbreaking military achievement, the Ukrainian army has successfully seized a…
Tax Day: Millions of filers take advantage of new Trump tax exemptions ahead of deadline, Treasury says

Maximize Your Tax Savings: How Millions are Benefiting from New Trump Tax Exemptions Before Deadline

WASHINGTON — As Wednesday marks Tax Day, the final date for the…
Donald Trump has a wild theory about Diet Coke and cancer: Dr. Oz

Donald Trump’s Controversial Diet Coke and Cancer Theory Sparks Debate with Dr. Oz

WASHINGTON — It’s best to keep him away from Roundup. In a…
Tax 2026 deadline | Getting a refund or owe taxes? Expert reveals some things to know and do before you file

Tax Season 2026: Essential Strategies to Maximize Refunds and Minimize Payments

The clock is ticking for those who still need to file their…
LA Special Victims Bureau will handle Swalwell case of woman who claimed he sexually assaulted her

LA Special Victims Bureau Takes Charge of Investigation into Allegations Against Swalwell

The Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department has launched an investigation into a…
Husband of missing American woman will remain in Bahamas after jail release, attorney says

Attorney Confirms Husband of Missing American Woman to Stay in Bahamas Post-Jail Release

Brian Hooker prepares to leave jail Brian Hooker is set to be…
Teen takeover Chicago news: Parents organize own gathering in response to planned Hyde Park teen trend

In Response to Planned Hyde Park Teen Event, Parents Organize Alternative Gathering in Chicago

CHICAGO (WLS) — Residents and businesses in Hyde Park have been on…
Disgruntled worker invokes Luigi Mangione in $500M warehouse inferno he filmed in anti-capitalist rage: feds

Warehouse Inferno: Discontented Employee Cites Anti-Capitalist Sentiment and Luigi Mangione in $500M Blaze, Say Federal Authorities

A disgruntled employee from the Inland Empire, who allegedly caused $500 million…
Islanders fans rally behind jailed ‘cooler cop’ Erik Duran after launch of defense legal fund

Islanders Fans Unite to Support Jailed ‘Cooler Cop’ Erik Duran with New Defense Fund

In a powerful show of support, fans of the New York Islanders…
President Trump tells The Post US-Iran talks 'could be happening over next two days'

Trump Hints at Possible US-Iran Negotiations in Coming Days

ISLAMABAD — President Trump revealed to The Post on Tuesday that further…
Hochul proposes taxes on second homes in NYC worth $5M-plus

Hochul Suggests New Tax for NYC’s Luxury Second Homes Valued Over $5 Million

Governor Kathy Hochul is advocating for an additional tax on owners of…