Jonathan Roldan killed ex-girlfriend's boyfriend, US Army veteran Andrew Garay, in Humboldt Park, Chicago shooting: prosecutors
Share this @internewscast.com

A man is facing charges after allegedly shooting and killing his ex-girlfriend’s boyfriend on Chicago’s Northwest Side in January, according to prosecutors.

The family of the victim, 30-year-old Andrew Garay, expressed relief outside the courtroom on Sunday, grateful that a suspect has been apprehended for the murder.

ABC7 Chicago is now streaming 24/7. Click here to watch

“One of our biggest fears was that no one would be held accountable. We’re relieved that justice is being pursued,” said Karjan Dambaugh, Garay’s cousin.

The suspect, identified as 35-year-old Jonathan Roldan, was taken into custody late last week in connection with the shooting that occurred on January 23.

Garay, a U.S. Army veteran, had been in a relationship with Roldan’s former partner for several years. Roldan had a long-standing relationship of 17 years with her and shares two children with her.

Prosecutors revealed that witnesses quickly identified Roldan as a suspect during the investigation. Surveillance footage also reportedly captured him at the crime scene on the night of the shooting.

Garay had just dropped his girlfriend off at her home in the Humboldt Park neighborhood and was waiting for her to go inside, prosecutors said. Roldan allegedly walked up from the gangway and fired one shot through the driver’s side window, hitting Garay in the forehead and killing him.

“He was assassinated. This wasn’t spur-of-the-moment. This was planned. It was clear from the beginning,” Dambaugh said.

Garay had a 7-year-old daughter. His family says his loss has been very difficult to deal with.

“I still struggled Daly with believing he’s gone. There are times I grabbed my phone with the instinct of calling him or sending him a quick text, and then, it hits us all over again,” Dambaugh said.

Roldan is charged with first-degree murder. The judge ordered him held in jail pending trial. His next court appearance is scheduled for next week.

The video in the player above is from a previous report.

INTERACTIVE SAFETY TRACKER Track crime and safety in your neighborhood

Copyright © 2026 WLS-TV. All Rights Reserved.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
The Post tries Gwyneth’s delivery menu

The Post Explores Gwyneth Paltrow’s Latest Delivery Menu

New Yorkers have weathered their share of culinary quirks, from the ubiquitous…
Feds arrest illegal immigrant repeat offender they say dodged deportation for decades amid sanctuary policies

Decades of Evasion: How Sanctuary Policies Shielded a Repeat Offender from Deportation

Illegal migrant arrested for murder of Loyola student sparks sanctuary city debate…
Why the DHS shutdown will likely drag on until May or June

DHS Shutdown: What to Expect in the Coming Months

WASHINGTON — The Department of Homeland Security remains on hold for a…
2 dead and 11 injured after enormous blaze tears through, partially collapses NYC apartment building

Devastating NYC Apartment Inferno: 2 Dead, 11 Injured in Partial Building Collapse

A devastating blaze claimed the lives of two individuals and left nearly…
Disneynature's 'Orangutan' producer Roy Conli on finding the story and working with Josh Gad

Inside Disneynature’s ‘Orangutan’: Roy Conli Reveals Storytelling Secrets and Collaborating with Josh Gad

LOS ANGELES — In the lush canopies of Southeast Asia, a young…
Israeli soldiers caught smashing Jesus statue sentenced to 30 days in prison

Israeli Soldiers Sentenced to 30 Days for Vandalizing Jesus Statue: A Controversial Incident Unfolds

In response to international condemnation, two Israeli soldiers have been disciplined after…
Hiker identified, popular trail closed after deadly fall at Utah's Zion National Park

Tragic Fall at Zion National Park: Hiker Identified, Trail Closure Announced

A Texas resident has been identified as the victim of a fatal…
Priceless ancient golden Romanian helmet returned to country following Dutch museum raid

Priceless Ancient Romanian Gold Helmet Repatriated After Recovery in Dutch Museum Heist

A golden helmet, dating back 2,500 years and considered invaluable, was returned…
Girl dies in Brazil after hair gets caught in pool suction system

Tragic Pool Accident in Brazil: Young Girl Loses Life to Pool Suction Incident

A tragic incident occurred in Mirassol, Sao Paulo, Brazil, where a 12-year-old…
Student charged, weapon recovered after 3 teens targeted in incident linked to high school tradition: police

High School Tradition Takes a Dark Turn: Student Arrested and Weapon Seized After Targeting 3 Teens

A high school in Massachusetts became the scene of a troubling incident…
Nearly 8,000 people died or disappeared on migration routes in 2025: 'Collective failure'

Tragic Toll: 8,000 Lives Lost or Missing on Migration Paths in 2025, Highlighting Global Shortcomings

GENEVA, April 21 (Reuters) – A staggering 8,000 individuals lost their lives…
A preschool classroom is shaken by loss after a mass killing in Louisiana

Tragedy Strikes: Louisiana Preschool Community Mourns After Devastating Mass Killing

Every morning, Angela Hall, a dedicated preschool teacher in Shreveport, Louisiana, gathers…