Bully who beat NYC subway rider while shouting homophobic slurs busted trying to beat fare: sources

A man accused of assaulting a subway passenger while shouting homophobic insults was apprehended after evading capture for three months. His arrest came during an attempt to evade paying a train fare, according to police and insider reports.

The suspect, Yeshayahu Carraway, 41, allegedly attacked a 24-year-old man after trailing him off a northbound L train at Williamsburg’s Lorimer Street station around 5:00 a.m. on January 18, authorities reported.

Brandishing a knife, Carraway reportedly hurled anti-gay slurs while violently hitting the victim on the head and body. After the assault, the assailant fled the scene, officers stated.


Still image of a man wanted in a hate crime assault.
41-year-old Yeshayahu Carraway was arrest for a homophobic attack committed three months ago after he was caught trying to duck the subway fare in the Bronx, cops said. NYPD

Despite sustaining minor injuries, the victim declined medical assistance at the location, as noted by officials.

Carraway’s unlawful actions eventually led to his capture. He was taken into custody on a Saturday evening around 7:40 p.m., when officers spotted him attempting to avoid the subway fare by slipping through the emergency gate at the Hunts Point Avenue station in the Bronx, sources revealed.


Man with dreadlocks wearing a black durag and black jacket.
Carraway screamed homophobic slurs at the man while brandishing a knife, and proceeded to thrash him – before running off in the hateful January attack, police said.  NYPD

The intolerant terror was arrested Saturday night at 7:40 p.m. after cops caught him trying to duck the subway fare by entering through the emergency gate at Hunts Point Avenue stop in the Bronx, sources said. 

It was while Carraway was in custody for fare evasion that cops also connected him to the hateful attack, sources said. 

The incident wasn’t Carraway’s first run-in with the law. 

The brute has been cuffed for putting his hands on people several times before, having been arrested for assault in 2011 and 2017, according to sources.

You May Also Like

Kacey Musgraves pays tribute to Dolly Parton at the 2026 MTV VMAs

Kacey Musgraves Honors Dolly Parton at the 2026 MTV VMAs

Kacey Musgraves honored the late country music legend during the 2026 MTV…
Moment aggressive sea lion knocks Santa Cruz paddle boarder into the ocean and tears at her hair

Sea Lion Knocks Santa Cruz Paddleboarder Into Ocean, Tears Hair

A woman paddle-boarding off the California coast in Santa Cruz was knocked…
Foiled terror plot at bomber base signals wider threat to US military installations: expert

Foiled Terror Plot at Bomber Base Signals Wider Threat to U.S. Bases

The five men arrested Sunday near RAF Fairford, a strategically important U.S.…
‘Santa Clarita Karen’ forced to apologize as her business implodes

Santa Clarita Woman Apologizes as Business Faces Backlash

A California business owner known online as “Santa Clarita Karen” is speaking…
WATCH: NYPD bodycam captures tense standoff after Bank of America exec fatally stabbed in Times Square

NYPD Bodycam Shows Standoff After Fatal Bank of America Exec Stabbing

Newly released NYPD body camera video captures officers urging Pamela Cisneros to…
NTSB releases preliminary report on northwest Fresno, California plane crash that killed 4 Eady family members

NTSB Releases Preliminary Report on Fresno Plane Crash That Killed 4 Eady Family Members

FRESNO, Calif. — The National Transportation Safety Board has issued a preliminary…
Texas delivery driver Donald Johnson's viral $700K fundraiser taken down after organizer revealed to be his daughter

Texas Driver Donald Johnson’s $700K Fundraiser Removed Over Daughter

A Texas woman presented herself as a caring neighbor while helping her…
Clancy holdout juror taps former Trump lawyer to fight back as he’s ‘dragged through the mud’: attorney

Lindsay Clancy’s Juror Inquiry May Pause as Both Sides Seek Delay

PLYMOUTH, Mass. — Lindsay Clancy’s defense team and Massachusetts prosecutors have agreed…
White House reporters share shocking choices on which Republicans could run for president after Trump

White House Reporters Reveal Surprise Republicans to Run After Trump

AUSTIN, Texas — Three high-profile White House journalists offered an early look…
Son makes chilling admission after fatally stabbing mom in gated Florida neighborhood

Son Admits Fatally Stabbing Mother in Gated Florida Community

A man who described himself as an “intuitive healer” allegedly fatally stabbed…
Monstrous NY shopping mall that aimed to spark troubled downtown devolves into bane of Dem-run city

Massive NY Mall Meant to Revive Downtown Becomes City Burden

New Roc City has become a symbol of a downtown revival that…
Round 2 of NYC's nor'easter leaves surreal scenes

NYC Nor’easter’s Second Round Leaves Surreal City Scenes

The nor’easter slammed New York City once again. A 1-year-old boy and…