Washington — A federal judge has prevented the Kennedy Center from shutting its doors for planned renovations and determined that the board acted improperly when it renamed the building to include President Trump’s name.
In a comprehensive 94-page ruling issued Friday, U.S. District Judge Christopher Cooper sided with Democratic Representative Joyce Beatty from Ohio. Beatty, a trustee of the Kennedy Center, had challenged the name change and the two-year closure plan intended for extensive renovations starting this summer.
The judge concluded that the board had exceeded its authority by renaming the Center in honor of Mr. Trump. He ordered the removal of Trump’s name from the “building’s façade, any signage—physical or digital—and official documents or materials.”
“The Kennedy Center’s founding legislation unambiguously states it is to be named for President Kennedy, and the board cannot alter this designation without congressional approval,” Cooper stated. Appointed by President Barack Obama, Cooper emphasized that only Congress has the power to change the Center’s name.
Regarding the proposed closure, the judge criticized the board’s actions, remarking that “by endorsing President Trump’s closure plan, the board neglected its full responsibilities to the Center.”
Cooper highlighted that the board relied on inadequate and biased information, failing to fully consider its legal duties and the negative impact a closure could have on the Center’s programming and commemorative activities.
Al Drago / Getty Images
Referring to the impending closure, the judge said that “in ratifying President Trump’s closure announcement, the Board was derelict in discharging the full range of its responsibilities to the Center.”
“More specifically, the Board based its decision on an insufficient, one-sided presentation of information and neglected to consider the full range of its statutory obligations and potential adverse consequences of closure on programming and memorial functions,” Cooper wrote.
He called the decision to cease operations during the renovation “ill-informed and seemingly preordained.”
The judge also ruled that the board had “overstepped” its power by stripping Beatty, an ex officio member through her role in Congress, of her right to vote at a March meeting where the board approved the plan to close the center after this summer’s July 4 celebrations.
Earlier this year, Cooper ruled that Beatty was entitled to participate in the meeting, but did not require that the board allow her to vote.
In his Friday ruling, however, Cooper said that planned repair work can continue, saying the evidence put forward in the case indicates it is “sorely needed.” He also said his preliminary injunction does not “categorically” bar the board from closing the Kennedy Center “should it come to this decision anew after independently balancing its multiple obligations to the Center in a prudent fashion.”
“By way of this opinion, the Court does not purport to dictate how the Center should be run, nor does it prescribe any particular plan for the institution — construction, closure, or otherwise — moving forward,” he wrote. “It simply holds the Kennedy Center Board to certain minimum requirements imposed by law. Beyond that, the Court will let the parties play on.”
In a separate decision on Friday, Cooper denied a similar legal challenge brought by the D.C. Preservation League.
Beatty cheered the decision.
“Today’s ruling rightly affirms that this administration’s efforts to rename and close the Center have no basis in law,” she said in a statement. “The Kennedy Center is an institution that belongs to the American people, not to Donald Trump. He has desecrated this sacred memorial for his own vanity.”
Roma Daravi, spokeswoman for the Kennedy Center, said the institution is “confident that on appeal the court will uphold the Board’s will to recognize President Trump’s historic contributions to our nation’s cultural center.”
She reiterated that the Kennedy Center requires repair work.
“With $257 million secured by President Trump and approved by Congress, the resources are in place and we remain committed to pursuing every lawful avenue to ensure the Trump Kennedy Center is restored as a national cultural landmark for all Americans to enjoy,” Daravi said.
A Justice Department spokesperson said: “The Department is pleased that the court rejected challenges to the Trump-Kennedy Center renovations, and we will continue to defend President Trump’s ability to restore the Center to its former glory as the finest performing arts center in the country – if not the world.”
Mr. Trump moved to put his mark on the Kennedy Center in the opening weeks of his second term. The president replaced several members of the center’s Board of Trustees with senior members of his administration and close allies, who then elected Mr. Trump chair.
The board also moved to oust its longtime president, and installed Ric Grenell, who served as U.S. ambassador to Germany in the first Trump administration, as its new leader. Grenell left his post helming the Kennedy Center earlier this year and was replaced by Matt Floca, the institution’s former vice president of operations.
In December, the Kennedy Center’s board voted to change the performing arts institution’s name to The Donald J. Trump and The John F. Kennedy Memorial Center for the Performing Arts.
The changes were instituted swiftly. Hours after the board’s vote, the Kennedy Center’s website was updated to read “The Trump Kennedy Center” and crews went to work adding Mr. Trump’s name to the building’s facade. But lawmakers and legal scholars said such a change required action by Congress.
But the president’s moves to reshape the Kennedy Center were met with backlash from the performing arts community. Several artists who were set to perform at the institution canceled performances and the executive director of the National Symphony Orchestra, which performs at the Kennedy Center, left for a new job.
