Labour has been accused of being “determined” to open a major migrant centre near an Oxfordshire village, despite warnings that converting and running the site could cost taxpayers £1billion over 10 years.
Calum Miller, the MP for Bicester and Woodstock, said ministers appeared to be ignoring concerns about public safety and community cohesion surrounding the proposed asylum accommodation near Piddington.
Housing Secretary Angela Rayner approved plans last week to house 1,256 single male asylum seekers at MoD Bicester, even after villagers symbolically voted to leave the UK in protest.
Mr Miller criticised the Government for approving the military site despite a planning application receiving 3,177 objections and just one expression of support.
“The overwhelming impression is that the Government is determined to open another large asylum centre and simply does not care about the real and specific problems associated with this site,” he said.
During an urgent question in the House of Commons, the Liberal Democrat MP warned that converting the site into asylum accommodation would be extremely costly.
“It is a semi-derelict storage depot containing asbestos-ridden buildings,” he said. “Water, electricity and sewage infrastructure would have to be built from scratch, alongside new accommodation and transport arrangements for an isolated site.
“That is an extraordinary amount of work just to make this location usable. I believe building and operating the centre will cost more than £1billion over 10 years.”
An aerial view of MoD Bicester, where the proposed asylum accommodation centre is due to be established
Calum Miller, MP for Bicester and Woodstock, said ministers appeared to be ignoring concerns about public safety and community cohesion
Home Office minister Anna Turley said she could not comment on Mr Miller’s estimate, but suggested the centre would nevertheless be cheaper than placing asylum seekers in hotels.
“The final per-person cost for MoD Bicester will depend on the outcome of the planning and procurement process, so I cannot comment at this stage,” she told MPs.
“For comparison, the cost of the two existing large sites, Wethersfield and Crowborough, is £135 and £138 per person per night respectively, as the honourable gentleman knows. That is significantly less than the £199-a-night cost of hotels.
“As I have already said, overall asylum costs have fallen by more than £1billion since this Government came to office.”
The Government has acknowledged that housing a large number of single male migrants near Piddington could create risks for women and girls, while police chiefs have warned that the site could also lead to higher crime levels.
The planning approval document said officials had “considered the effects on neighbouring communities, including concerns about the safety of women and girls, perceptions of safety, community cohesion, policing demand and protest activity”.
It said the centre would be “closely managed”, but conceded that security arrangements “cannot eliminate all risk” to local residents.
The document also disclosed that Matthew Barber, the Police and Crime Commissioner for Thames Valley, had objected to the plans.
“Insufficient consideration has been given to the implications of accommodating a large population in a relatively self-contained and isolated location with limited access to services and amenities,” his submission stated.
“Such circumstances may increase the risk of social isolation and crime, increase demand for policing, place pressure on local infrastructure and contribute to tensions within both the resident and surrounding communities.”
ALSO READ: Courageous Mother Wins 23-Year Sentence for Her Abuser in Pursuit of Justice
Joy Morrissey, the shadow minister for women and equalities, accused Labour of putting local women at risk.
“Why is the Government approving this site when it knows it cannot guarantee the safety of women and girls?” she asked Ms Turley.
“This is a decision the Government will come to regret.”
In response, the Labour minister noted that the Conservatives had opened two asylum camps at former military bases in Wethersfield, Essex, and Crowborough, East Sussex.
Ms Turley said former military bases offered a “much safer and more secure” alternative to accommodating asylum seekers in hotels.
Housing Minister Angela Rayner approved the controversial site despite Piddington residents symbolically voting to leave the UK in protest
The approval of the Piddington site came after Prime Minister Andy Burnham said people in more affluent parts of the UK must “play their part” in accommodating asylum seekers.
The Government has pledged to end the use of hotels for asylum accommodation and instead make use of former military sites.
Wethersfield and Crowborough are already operating. Alongside MoD Bicester, sites at Barnham in Norfolk and Linton-on-Ouse in North Yorkshire have also been identified.
Decisions on those locations are understood not to have been made.
Residents of Piddington said they “always knew” the centre would be approved, accusing the Government of effectively submitting and approving its own planning application.
Joe Marshall, a Piddington parish councillor, told BBC Newsnight: “The quality of the application is shocking, with discrepancies throughout.
“They have not followed the proper planning procedure. But regardless of that, we always knew it would be approved.
“There are 28 conditions that must be discharged, all of them effectively relating to the viability of the site. So this fight is not over yet.”
He also questioned whether residents could consider themselves to be living in a democracy given the scale of opposition to the proposed migrant centre.
“I think this is the kind of development that nobody would want imposed on their local area,” Mr Marshall continued.
“And it is not simply a NIMBY issue. It is a much wider concern: the population would quadruple, residents would be exposed to emissions from generators and the proposal could lead to more road collisions.”
A Home Office spokesman said: “Planning permission allows us to continue progressing the use of MoD Bicester. However, a final decision on whether to proceed has not yet been taken.
“The Government is working towards a fairer distribution of asylum accommodation across the country, with more than £1billion saved in costs since the election. This includes closing all asylum hotels.”