A student-run coffeehouse at a California college removed all of its flags rather than display American and Israeli flags with the same “size” and “prominence” as a Palestinian flag.
The Motley Coffeehouse at Scripps College in Claremont announced the decision in an Instagram post on Nov. 13.
According to the post, the coffeehouse removed its Palestinian and Ukrainian flags after the college issued an ultimatum by email.
The message, the coffeehouse said, gave them two options: keep the Palestinian flag displayed and additionally display the American and Israeli flags at the same “size” and “prominence,” or remove all flag displays. The post didn’t mention who exactly from the college sent the email.
The Motley explained why they chose to take down all the flags: “neither option aligns with our mission statement or community consensus. However, jobs are at risk if we do not comply with the decorations policy.”
A dispute over the display of a Palestinian flag at Scripps College has reignited tensions between school administrators and students who operate The Motley.
The Palestinian and Ukrainian flags were put up earlier this semester, with student leaders maintaining that both displays complied with the coffeehouse’s existing decoration rules and mission statement.
The Motley is owned by Scripps College but managed by students, who have accused administrators of selectively intervening when Palestinian-related expression is involved.
“Thus far, the college has only used its decision making authority over The Motley Coffeehouse when issues regarding Palestinian speech arise,” The Motley’s student co-heads wrote in a statement to TSL.

“The Palestinian exception is not new to The Motley, unique to Scripps College, nor abnormal in domestic and international conversations.”
The disagreement comes despite a decoration policy developed jointly by students and college officials and approved by Scripps President Amy Marcus-Newhall in February 2026.
Under those guidelines, the coffeehouse’s walls, excluding its blackboard, are designated as spaces for artwork and displays reflecting its emphasis on intersectional feminism, community involvement and creative expression.
The rules also establish a process for resolving disagreements over decorations. If administrators determine that a display violates school regulations or creates potential legal liability, they must inform student staff of the specific issue, explain the alleged violation and identify the changes being requested.
Rather than allowing decorations to be removed without discussion, the policy calls for proposed changes to be considered collectively.
Any removal or modification must receive approval from more than half of The Motley’s baristas and management team, with the coffeehouse’s values taken into account.
The latest controversy is part of a long-running disagreement between students and the administration over who has the final say on what can be displayed inside the coffeehouse.
Those tensions date back more than two years and have repeatedly centered on the Palestinian flag.
The California Post reached out to Scripps College for comment.