As Nvidia shares slide, British investors have been moving in, snapping up stock at prices not seen since July last year.
Nvidia was the most purchased stock by net buys on investment platform AJ Bell during the four days to November 9. Saxo recorded 12 times more trades in Nvidia than in the next most-traded stock this week, with buyers accounting for 88 per cent of transactions.
The surge in demand follows a week in which around half a trillion dollars was erased from Nvidia’s market value after chief executive Jensen Huang was ousted. Huang, 63, founded the semiconductor company in 1993, and Nvidia has since grown into the world’s second-largest business.
The company’s future was thrown into question after reports surfaced about Huang’s extramarital relationships, including an alleged relationship with a Chinese spy.
Nvidia shares fell 13 per cent after the reports emerged, as unsettled investors sold their holdings. The stock is down 28 per cent over the past six months, with the latest developments adding to fears that the artificial intelligence (AI) spending boom could be approaching a breaking point. Weekend reports suggested that Huang may already be considering a return to the company.
That leaves investors facing a difficult choice: is this the moment to buy Nvidia shares while they trade well below recent highs, or should they hold off — or even sell — as uncertainty around the company’s outlook grows?
Demand for Nvidia shares has surged after about half a trillion dollars was wiped from the company’s value last week following the ousting of chief executive Jensen Huang
Ben Yearsley, director at Fairview Investing, says: ‘The AI trade has delivered exceptional returns over the past few years, but it has also been extremely volatile. This is simply the latest example.
‘At times like this, investors should return to the original reason they bought an asset and ask whether that rationale still holds.’
Technology shares have soared in recent years, driven by excitement over AI. However, questions are mounting over how much some companies are spending on the technology — and on the data centres needed to operate it. Investors are increasingly asking whether those huge outlays will ultimately generate sufficient profits.
Those concerns have been intensified by higher interest rates, which raise borrowing costs for companies financing their expansion, as well as political uncertainty. The surprise Republican wipeout in this month’s US midterm elections has added to the unease.
Proposals from the US Democratic Party to impose tighter rules on AI and data-centre construction are also viewed as a possible threat to the industry’s growth.
Against that backdrop, shares in companies including Alphabet, Meta and Tesla have fallen. Whether Nvidia and other technology stocks represent a buying opportunity depends largely on what investors expect to happen next.
Investors who see the current market as a repeat of the dot-com bubble, with a major correction still to come, may decide to sell. Those who believe the decline is temporary and that markets will recover could regard it as an opportunity to buy.
Amish Patel, head of equity research at Raymond James, says: ‘Investors should not mistake the recent technology sell-off, or the headlines surrounding Nvidia, for evidence that the fundamental AI investment story has changed.
‘There has undoubtedly been fear in the market, but so far there is little evidence that the sector’s long-term fundamentals have shifted.’
The rise and rise of Nvidia
Nvidia focuses on a specialist type of computer chip known as a Graphics Processing Unit (GPU). These chips power applications ranging from artificial intelligence and video games to cloud computing and autonomous vehicles. Its technical expertise and market-leading products have helped it establish a dominant position, supported by major customers such as Microsoft, Alphabet and Meta.
Yet Nvidia’s success has also been closely linked to the person leading it.
‘Much of Nvidia’s advantage appears to stem from Huang’s ability to identify an idea and put it into action almost immediately,’ says Ben Kumar of investment firm 7IM.
Could Huang’s departure therefore threaten the company’s future? Key-person risk can be significant, particularly at founder-led businesses. If a company’s prospects become too dependent on one individual, their sudden absence can have serious consequences.
Chris Beauchamp of trading platform IG says: ‘A company worth several trillion dollars is bigger than one person, but investors have seen this week just how much of Nvidia’s value was linked to a single man.’
Nvidia makes Graphics Processing Units (GPUs), the chips that support everything from artificial intelligence and video games to cloud computing and autonomous vehicles
Brian Colello, senior equity analyst at Morningstar, believes Nvidia is likely to have a succession plan in place.
Although no new chief executive has yet been appointed, several credible candidates are reportedly in contention. They include Colette Kress, the company’s chief financial officer and interim CEO; Ian Buck, who runs Nvidia’s high-performance computing business; and Rene Haas, chief executive of chipmaker ARM. Reports have also raised the possibility that Huang could return.
For now, Nvidia’s product expertise and loyal customer base should allow it to continue expanding regardless of who occupies the chief executive’s office. Colello says the company’s ‘wide moat’ — its strong competitive advantage over rivals — leaves it well positioned to benefit from ‘insatiable AI computing growth’.
He adds: ‘[But] we’ll continue watching for signs that this turmoil could result in cancelled customer orders or changes to financial agreements that might affect our revenue forecasts.’
Morningstar values Nvidia shares at $310, substantially above the $162 price at the time of writing.
The ripple effect
Nvidia is the largest holding in several highly rated technology funds and investment trusts, including Polar Capital Technology, L&G Global Technology Index Trust, T. Rowe Price Technology and Allianz Technology Trust. Their performance could suffer in the short term as a result.
Nvidia is also the second-largest constituent of the MSCI World index, accounting for 5.25 per cent of it. That means anyone invested in a global tracker fund will also feel the impact of a decline in the stock.
The AI boom, of course, does not depend on Nvidia alone. The sector is set for another major development next week, when Anthropic, the company behind Claude, is expected to list. The business is due to float on the Nasdaq on November 18 at a potential valuation of $1.5trillion, which would place it among the world’s ten largest companies from the outset.
Beauchamp says: ‘The next phase of the technology rally may depend on whether investors pay more attention to Jensen’s downfall — he has been dubbed the Godfather of AI — or to Anthropic’s stock market debut.
‘For investors willing to tolerate substantial short-term volatility, the distinction may not matter as much if Anthropic’s listing performs well. Markets need positive stories to keep advancing, and a successful flotation could help investors move on from Nvidia’s troubles.’
Nvidia is also due to publish its latest results on Tuesday. The figures could give the company a chance to draw a line under the events of the past week.
Will McIntosh Whyte of Rathbones Asset Management expects ‘decent numbers’, alongside evidence that Nvidia intends to continue investing in data centres despite the prospect of additional regulation. ‘They may slow the rollout slightly, but this is a long-term structural trend,’ he says. ‘AI adoption is happening quickly. Companies are currently spending very little relative to what they could spend, so there is a long way still to go.’
‘The future of the rally in technology shares may depend on whether investors focus more on Jensen’s downfall or Anthropic’s stock market listing,’ says Chris Beauchamp of IG
This time it’s different?
The AI boom is the latest in a long line of episodes in which stock markets have become overheated. Russ Mould, investment director at AJ Bell, points to earlier manias including the South Sea Bubble of 1720, the US railroad boom of the 1870s, Japanese property in the 1980s and the global technology frenzy of the 1990s.
Periods of transformational technological change often trigger fresh market speculation, Mould says. He outlines a familiar bubble cycle: rising prices create fear of missing out, which fuels speculation and easy money. Eventually, weaknesses emerge, confidence evaporates and investors rush for the exit, leaving many with substantial losses.
He adds: ‘Investors can decide for themselves where they believe we are in that cycle. There do appear to be several features of the current market that fit the well-established pattern, at least so far.’
So what should investors do? McIntosh Whyte says they should consider what might trigger another rise in share prices. He admits ‘it is difficult to identify one right now’, but adds: ‘The story is still developing and we will wait to see what action the US takes [against Huang]. However, if the shares continue to de-rate, they could begin to look very attractive, and we may use that as an opportunity to increase our position.’
Patel says the scale of Nvidia’s gains makes it reasonable for investors to consider taking profits. ‘Our focus is more on whether further weakness creates opportunities to gain exposure to high-quality businesses at more attractive valuations. We are not rushing in, and the underperformance may have further to run.’
Yearsley says investors should maintain a long-term perspective: ‘Huang is clearly important to the business, but previous examples of technology leaders leaving — including at Apple and Microsoft — show that companies can continue to prosper. That does not mean investors should rush out and buy the dip today.’
For many investors, a buy-and-hold strategy may be the most sensible approach. Selling after a fall crystallises the loss, while buying during a decline carries the risk that prices could continue to drop, leaving investors immediately out of pocket.
Trying to time the market by predicting the ideal moment to invest is extremely difficult, says James Norton of investment giant Vanguard. ‘Market peaks and troughs are almost impossible to identify in real time, and delaying investment or selling holdings can often mean missing out on future opportunities.’
Instead, investors can use a market downturn to review their portfolios. Check that holdings remain aligned with financial goals, consider taking profits from strong performers and redirecting them towards laggards, and continue with regular investment plans. This can support pound-cost averaging, whereby investors buy more shares when prices are lower and fewer when they are higher, potentially improving their average purchase price over time.
Norton adds: ‘Maintaining discipline, holding a broadly diversified portfolio over the long term and riding out periods of volatility can produce strong results, even in challenging market conditions.’