A federal judge has permanently blocked enforcement of two California laws that would have required federal immigration agents, including ICE officers, to remove their masks and display identifying information. The ruling ends a yearlong legal battle between the federal government and California Democrats.
U.S. District Judge Christina A. Snyder ruled Tuesday that state Attorney General Rob Bonta may not enforce the mask ban or identification requirement against federal agencies such as Immigration and Customs Enforcement. Bonta’s office has appeared to accept the decision.
“The Constitution does not permit states to interfere with federal operations or place federal officers and their families at risk. This injunction ensures that federal law enforcement officers can continue carrying out their important missions without unlawful state interference,” Associate Attorney General Stanley E. Woodward Jr. said in a statement Thursday.
The injunction follows last month’s decision by the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, which sided with the Trump administration and found that California’s law violated the Constitution’s Supremacy Clause by interfering with the duties of federal officers.
“As before, we conclude … the No Vigilantes Act attempts to directly regulate the United States in its performance of governmental functions,” Judge Mark J. Bennett wrote. “No set of circumstances exist under which the Act would be valid.”
The Justice Department filed suit last fall to block the identification requirement, along with a separate state law that sought to prohibit federal agents and local police from wearing masks.
Democrats in California and across the country considered measures targeting federal immigration enforcement after the killing of anti-ICE protester Renee Good in Minneapolis. Good was shot four times during a tense confrontation with officers while she was inside her SUV.
A spokesperson for California Gov. Gavin Newsom previously responded to the laws’ setbacks in court by saying that “these laws shouldn’t even be necessary.” The spokesperson criticized President Donald Trump and his chief of staff, Stephen Miller, over what was described as their aggressive deportation campaign.
RELATED: Wife Arrested After Allegedly Faking a Decade-Long Cancer Battle
Federal attorneys argued that California’s measures not only unlawfully attempted to regulate federal agencies but also disrupted critical enforcement operations.
The Justice Department said the restrictions endangered ICE officers, who have faced an unprecedented wave of harassment, doxing and even violence from anti-ICE activists. The department also warned that the privacy risks could compromise sensitive law enforcement operations.
“This permanent injunction protects… the safety of federal law enforcement officers,” Acting Assistant Attorney General Jonathan D. Guynn said. “The Federal Government, not the states, gets to decide what equipment federal officers may use and what measures they may take to protect themselves while performing their official duties.”
Attorneys representing the state acknowledged in a court filing that the injunction would end the case. Although they said the “State Defendants continue to dispute the United States’ claims,” they agreed to resolve the matter rather than pursue additional appeals.
Despite the court challenges, California Democrats have continued their campaign against ICE agents.
This year, the state passed additional laws banning “wearable electroshock devices,” barring ICE agents accused of serious misconduct from state employment and allowing residents to sue federal immigration officials.
State legislative analysts have already warned that this year’s court rulings could undermine those new laws.