A Florida man who described himself as a sadist has been convicted of first-degree murder and kidnapping in the killing of a suicidal British piano tutor who had searched the dark web for someone willing to take her life.
Dwain Hall, 53, was found guilty on Friday of stabbing Sonia Exelby, 32, to death near Gainesville in October 2025, only days after she traveled from Britain seeking what prosecutors described as a “violent death.” The two had met through an online fetish chatroom.
Hall was placed in shackles and handcuffs almost immediately after the verdict and received two consecutive life sentences.
The 12-member jury—eight women and four men—reached its unanimous decision after about an hour of deliberations. Several jurors cried while viewing photographs of Exelby’s body in a shallow grave.
Hall, a roadside mechanic, stood impassively beside his attorneys as Judge Timothy McCourt read the verdict.
The sentence ends the tragic case involving Exelby, who was 32 when she flew from London to meet Hall in Florida in October 2025.
During the investigation, Hall told police that Exelby had promised to pay him $4,000 to kill her. Prosecutors said the pair had maintained a two-year relationship through online chatrooms, including Motherless.com, a now-defunct website where anonymous users posted images depicting women and children being tortured, raped and killed.
By convicting Hall of first-degree murder, jurors indicated that they found the killing was premeditated.
Sonia Exelby, 32, was found dead in a shallow Florida grave in October 2025, just days after the suicidal British woman traveled to meet 54-year-old Dwain Hall, whom she believed would help bring about a “violent death” (Source: Facebook)
Dwain Hall, 53, was convicted on Friday of stabbing Sonia Exelby, 32, to death near Gainesville in October 2025. He is pictured during his trial
Hall could have faced the death penalty, but prosecutors said they reached an agreement with British authorities not to pursue it in exchange for the United Kingdom’s full cooperation.
Eight of Exelby’s relatives, including two sisters and her older brother, traveled from Portsmouth in Britain and from Australia to attend the weeklong trial. They sobbed as the jury returned two guilty verdicts.
In an unusual move, Judge McCourt went to his chambers after the verdict and returned almost immediately with the sentence: two consecutive terms of life imprisonment.
Before the sentence was imposed, four of Exelby’s siblings delivered victim-impact statements.
“Dwain, you pretended to care for Sonia,” her brother Barry Wilton, 39, told Hall. “But you didn’t at all. You used her for your sick fantasy. You had the opportunity to save her. Instead, you took her from us. May your actions weigh heavily on your mind for the rest of your pitiful life.”
“I pray for the maximum possible sentence. I would be comforted knowing he’ll never be able to prey on someone else.”
Her other brother, Luke Wilton, 47, said: “This year has been terrifying for the family. We were terrified coming here. What we found, however, is decency and care. The people we met here were remarkable. We saw how the state of Florida fought for us and how everyone came together in harmony. Thank you to the jury for your patience and attentiveness, to the prosecutors who left nothing to chance, and to the staff who treated us with kindness, humanity and dedication.”
Asked whether he wanted to say anything before sentencing, Hall replied: “No!”
Hall, a tow-truck operator from Ocala, Florida, was accused of stabbing Exelby after the pair met on a fetish website. Early findings in the investigation indicated that Exelby may have paid Hall to kill her. He pleaded not guilty (Source: Facebook)
Exelby, who had documented mental health problems, flew to Florida on October 10, 2025, with a return flight booked for three days later. Her family and boyfriend Steve Hunt, pictured with her, reported her missing after she failed to board the flight home (Source: Facebook)
Prosecutors alleged that Hall, a father of two, sexually abused and tortured Exelby before killing her at a remote Airbnb where the pair were staying
The prosecution rested its case Thursday afternoon after a medical examiner testified that Exelby died from four deep stab wounds.
The wounds were clustered on the left side of her abdomen. Investigators said a large fixed-blade knife had been driven as deep as seven inches into her body, severing arteries and injuring her stomach, spleen, diaphragm, pancreas and left kidney.
Associate Medical Examiner Rachel Lange, who conducted the autopsy, told the court that the wounds were unlikely to have been self-inflicted or caused during a suicide attempt.
Exelby’s body was found on October 17, 2025, in a shallow grave in a wooded area near Interstate 75, south of Ocala. She was nude except for a bra and sandals.
“The paths of the wounds were not what is typically seen in self-inflicted wounds,” Lange told the jury. She said Exelby was in the early stages of decomposition and had bruising on her left buttock, breasts, abdomen and back.
YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE: American killer sentenced to life for British music tutor’s murder
Hall chose not to testify during the trial.
He had pleaded not guilty to first-degree murder and kidnapping after his arrest in October 2025. Prosecutors alleged that he groomed Exelby, who suffered from depression and other mental health problems, for two years through violent fetish websites before killing her.
Without Hall taking the stand, his defense attorney, Junior Barrett, called no witnesses and cross-examined only two prosecution witnesses.
“I can’t force him to testify,” Barrett said during a recess.
The disturbing details of the case appeared to affect many of the jurors, most of whom were women.
Jurors took extensive notes throughout the proceedings and submitted written questions for witnesses to Judge McCourt.
One juror openly wept when prosecutors showed images of Exelby’s body lying on its right side in a fetal position, less than a foot beneath the surface of the grave.
Exelby’s relatives repeatedly left the courtroom gallery when photographs of her body and video recorded shortly before her death were displayed on large television screens.
Hall also cried several times, although his emotional moments occurred when the evidence focused on him.
Although Exelby had planned to travel to Florida, prosecutors presented evidence that she began to reconsider the decision as her plane took off. Among the evidence was a letter she sent to herself from her cellphone aboard Flight VS 103
Police told the court they found disturbing images on Hall’s phone after his arrest in connection with Exelby’s death near Gainesville in October 2025. He pleaded not guilty (Source: Facebook)
During a four-hour-and-40-minute recording of Hall’s interview with Florida Department of Law Enforcement agents, he was seen repeatedly removing his glasses and wiping his eyes with his hands.
Hall became emotional when the recording captured him telling investigators that he had failed Exelby, who had paid him $4,000, because “she didn’t want to be found, she wanted to be gone, gone, gone.”
When asked about her death, Hall answered: “Compassion. This is all it was. Compassion.”
Hall never admitted killing Exelby during that interview or any other conversation with investigators. He also did not provide an explanation for what had happened to her.
Over three days, prosecutors called a series of witnesses who described evidence connecting Hall to Exelby’s disappearance and death.
Data from the Life360 app on Hall’s phone placed him at Gainesville airport when Exelby arrived, at the Airbnb she had rented, and at a Walmart where he bought rope and a shovel. The data also showed his phone at the burial site for more than an hour.
A forensic scientist testified that a black Cold Steel knife, which investigators said Hall sent to a friend in Ohio for safekeeping, had been cleaned and oiled. No blood was initially found on it. But after the handle was removed, Exelby’s blood was discovered on the screws.
After his arrest, Hall told police that he had met Exelby on a fetish website two years earlier and that she had explained how she wanted to die (Source: Marion County Sheriff’s Office)
Exelby’s body was discovered in a shallow grave in remote woodland near Ocala, Florida, on October 17, 2025, shortly after her boyfriend in England reported her missing (Source: Family Handout/PA Wire)
Neuropsychologist Jason Demery, who testified as an expert witness, described Exelby as a “highly vulnerable, mentally ill adult” who was conflicted about whether she wanted to die.
Demery said Exelby had received psychological treatment for most of her adult life after a difficult childhood. She stopped attending counseling sessions in July 2025, several months before traveling to Florida.
He told the jury that Exelby sought “masochistic relationships as a substitute for self-harm” and looked for men on Motherless.com, a site that depicted sexual violence against women and children and was shut down by authorities last year.
Assistant State Attorney Amy Beth Berndt said Exelby had contacted several men whom she paid to kill her. Each took her money but did not follow through until she met Hall.
Based on Demery’s testimony, Hall should have recognized that Exelby was mentally ill rather than meeting her for rough sex and allegedly making plans to kill her, prosecutors argued.
“She was conflicted and ambivalent about what she was doing,” Demery said. “She was scared and unsure whether she wanted to go through with it. There were clear indications that she was suffering from mental illness. Her behavior should have struck a chord with anyone. Her vulnerability was unmistakable.”