Supreme Court sides against FBI in wrong-house raid case
Share this @internewscast.com

Background: The Martin-Cliatt family residence in Atlanta, Georgia (Institute for Justice). Inset, top left to right: Hilliard Toi Cliatt, Curtrina Martin, and Martin’s son Gabe (Institute for Justice); Inset, bottom: Justice Neil Gorsuch (left) and Justice Sonia Sotomayor (right) (Erin Schaff-Pool/Getty Images).

The U.S. Supreme Court unanimously decided to reinstate a lawsuit filed by an Atlanta family which stemmed from a “predawn” raid conducted at the wrong house by an FBI SWAT team in Georgia, who were searching for suspected gang members.

Love true crime? Sign up for our newsletter, The Law&Crime Docket, to get the latest real-life crime stories delivered right to your inbox.

On the early morning of October 18, 2017, a SWAT team forcefully entered the home of Curtrina Martin, Hilliard Toi Cliatt, and Martin’s 7-year-old son Gabe. As previously reported by Law&Crime, the team used a flash-bang grenade while announcing their arrival. Mistaking the raid for a burglary, Martin and Cliatt hid in a bedroom closet. An officer later dragged Cliatt out onto the bedroom floor at gunpoint, while another team member pointed a gun at Martin, instructing her to keep her hands raised. Meanwhile, Gabe was left alone, separated from the two adults during the execution of the warrant.

The family’s lawsuit had been dismissed by the district court in Georgia on qualified immunity grounds, and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit agreed, taking the unusual position that the lawsuit was barred by the Constitution’s supremacy clause, which generally presumes that federal law takes precedence over conflicting state law. The family appealed to the Supreme Court, and in a unanimous decision, the high court held that the family can get another hearing at the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit on their intentional-tort claims.

Although the federal government is usually immune from lawsuits, the Federal Tort Claims Act (FTCA) waives that immunity in certain circumstances, including when a plaintiff has a state-law claim stemming from a government official’s performance of a discretionary duty that advances federal policy. With the family’s appeal, the Supreme Court justices were asked to consider whether the mistaken warrant execution was a “discretionary duty” on the part of the officers; under the FTCA, the “discretionary function exception” protects federal agents from liability for routine judgment calls.

Justice Neil Gorsuch penned the opinion of the court and vacated the dismissal of the case.

The justice spelled out what the 11th Circuit must do once the case is remanded, including an evaluation of whether the discretionary function exception of the FTCA “bars either the plaintiffs’ negligent-or intentional-tort claim” and grants immunity to the government.

Gorsuch also made clear that the government shouldn’t have been able to dodge the FTCA suit at the 11th Circuit on the strength of the supremacy clause.

“The FTCA is the ‘supreme’ federal law addressing the United States’ liability for torts committed by its agents,” he added.

In a concurrence joined by Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, Justice Sonia Sotomayor wanted to “underscore that there is reason to think the discretionary function exception may not apply to these claims,” meaning the government would not be able to shield itself from liability.

Institute for Justice senior attorney Patrick Jaicomo, who represents the plaintiffs, said in a statement after the ruling that SCOTUS was “right to let the Martin family’s case move forward for the FBI’s botched raid of their home.”

“The Court’s decision today acknowledged how far the circuit courts have strayed from the purpose of the Federal Tort Claims Act, which is to ensure remedies to the victims of federal harms—intentional and negligent alike,” he said. “We look forward to continuing this fight with the Martins in the Eleventh Circuit and making it easier for everyday people to hold the government accountable for its mistaken and intentional violations of individual rights.”

In April, both Gorsuch and Sotomayor appeared reluctant to give immunity to the FBI agents involved in the wrong-house raid.

“You might look at the address of the house before you knock down the door,” Gorsuch remarked during oral arguments.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Mother Mad About Dirty Diaper Gives Son Scalding Bath, Resulting in Tragic Death: Police Report

Left inset: Jatoria Cleamons (Hooks Police Department). Right inset: Courtlyn Cleamons (Bates…

Lawyer Admits Guilt in Case of Missing Jennifer Dulos

Inset: Jennifer Farber Dulos (New Canaan Police Department). Background: Kent Mawhinney, center,…

Urgent search for suspects involved in shooting Australians in Bali

Police eager to catch the killers before they flee the country have…

Texas Man Accused of Slipping Abortion Pill into Pregnant Girlfriend’s Drink Faces Capital Murder Charge

A man from Texas is facing capital murder charges for allegedly giving…

Man Charged with Mistreating Girlfriend’s Toddlers and Family Dog

Inset: Mason Williams. Background: High Ridge, Missouri, neighborhood where Williams allegedly abused…

Habitual Criminal Taken into Custody for Intensifying Stalking Behavior

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – A 45-year-old man named Joseph Taylor, Jr.…

Indiana Mother Sentenced Following Tragic Discovery of Oaklee Snow in Dresser

The sentencing in the death of 1-year-old Oaklee Snow has been handed…

Search Escalates for Vance Boelter, Suspected of Murdering Minnesota Legislators

Authorities are searching for a man suspected in the shootings of two…

Angry Mother Pursues Teasing Teens at Park in Her Truck

Inset: Brandie Gotch (Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office). Screenshot: Tire tracks left in…

State Senator’s Wife Heroically Protected Daughter by Acting as Human Shield

In the left inset: there is an image of Minnesota Senator John…

Gainesville Resident Accused of Improper Contact with Teen

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Shawn Wesley Williams, aged 38, was taken…

Pregnant Woman and Her Two Children Perish in Intentionally Set Fire

Insets: Ashley Thompson with her two children (GoFundMe). Background: Firefighters responding to…