Appeals court won't give DOGE access to social security data
Share this @internewscast.com

Elon Musk makes a surprise appearance on stage as the Republican presidential candidate, former President Donald Trump, addresses the audience at a campaign event at the Butler Farm Show on Saturday, October 5, 2024, in Butler, Pennsylvania. (AP Photo/Evan Vucci)

The complete bench of judges on a federal appeals court in Virginia turned down the Trump administration’s plea to provide the so-called Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) with “immediate and unfettered” entry to the Social Security Administration’s (SSA) records systems, marking another legal setback for the president shortly after surpassing the 100-day milestone in office.

In a decision voted nine to six, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 4th Circuit on Wednesday upheld a preliminary injunction issued by U.S. District Judge Ellen Hollander of Maryland. This injunction prevented the Elon Musk-led agency from accessing the highly sensitive personal data of “essentially everyone in the country.” The majority argued that the “fundamental” principle of the SSA maintaining confidentiality of personal data “has been disregarded by the abrupt grant to DOGE of unrestricted access to the SSA system of records.”

In the majority’s 12-page order, Circuit Judge Robert Bruce King, an appointee of Bill Clinton, heaped praise on Hollander, an appointee of Barack Obama, referring to her as a “very able district judge” who had “carefully and thoughtfully examined the evidence and the legal issues” in the case. He also noted that her initial TRO order was accompanied by a 137-page opinion, while her preliminary injunction order included a 148-page opinion.

King lauded Hollander’s dual opinions as “addressing extensive evidence proffered by the parties” and “refining the pertinent legal analysis” of the lawsuit. The complaint accused the administration of violating the Privacy Act and the Administrative Procedure Act by granting DOGE SSA system access, and claimed it was acting in an “arbitrary and capricious” manner by “flouting SSA protocols for hiring, onboarding, training, and granting systems access to the DOGE affiliates.”

Love true crime? Sign up for our newsletter, The Law&Crime Docket, to get the latest real-life crime stories delivered right to your inbox.

In her latest opinion in the case, Hollander noted that since the SSA’s inception in 1935, it has “collected, stored, respected, and protected” personal and private data of U.S. citizens. She then emphasized that ensuring the confidentiality of that information was a “bedrock principle of the agency” — a principle the Trump administration sought to change by giving DOGE “unfettered access to SSA systems.”

“The objective to address fraud, waste, mismanagement, and bloat is laudable, and one that the American public presumably applauds and supports,” Hollander wrote. “Indeed, the taxpayers have every right to expect their government to make sure that their hard earned money is not squandered.”

Rather, she said, the issue was how DOGE wants to perform its work, and how the SSA was willing to abandon its long-standing mission.

“However, the issue here is not the work that DOGE or the [Social Security Administration] want to do,” she continued. “The issue is about how they want to do the work. For some 90 years, SSA has been guided by the foundational principle of an expectation of privacy with respect to its records,” adding, “This case exposes a wide fissure in the foundation.”

Hollander ultimately found the plaintiffs were likely to prevail on the merits, as did the majority of the appellate court judges.

“[Hollander’s preliminary injunction] analysis of those claims and the preliminary injunction factors is lengthy, thorough, and compelling,” the appellate court’s opinion says. “Rather than repeating that carefully crafted analysis herein, I adopt and attach hereto the [preliminary injunction] Opinion in its entirety.”

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Homeless Individual Charged with Assaulting Another, Resulting in a Hand Injury Requiring 10 Stitches

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Authorities arrested Anthony Pernell Collins, Jr., 25,…

Teen Driver Involved in Road Rage Incident Collides with Motorcyclist: Police

Background: News footage of the fatal crash in Litchfield, N.H. on Wednesday…

Prosecutors: Brothers Left Deceased Woman on Couch for Months

Background: A video captured news coverage of the Montreal courthouse where the…

Trump Requests Supreme Court Permission for DOGE to Access Social Security Information

President-elect Donald Trump listens intently to Elon Musk as he watches SpaceX’s…

Father Charged with Killing Deputy Following Son’s Police Encounter

A Cincinnati sheriff’s deputy was fatally struck by a car driven by…

“Alito Criticizes Oklahoma’s ‘Discriminatory History’ Amid Catholic Charter School Debate”

Main: Supporters of charter schools rally outside of the Supreme Court on…

Judge appointed by Reagan criticizes unfounded accusations against the judiciary

Main: President Donald Trump addresses the Michigan National Guard at Selfridge Air…

Tragic Incident: Man Allegedly Commits Matricide, Searches for Another Victim

The image shows Aaron Schlossin (Dakota County Jail). The 4500 block of…

New FDLE Memo Sheds Light on July 2024 Raid at Boukari Law and Alachua County Today Offices

Photo credit: Alachua Chronicle BY JENNIFER CABRERA This article quotes an FDLE…

Man Contacts Coroner After Fatal Shotgun Incident with Roommate

Left: Cody Vernon Kolstad (Rice County Attorney’s Office). right: Brian Daniel Stoeckel…

FBI Arrests Man Accused of Plotting to Kill Trump

President Donald Trump makes a gesture while speaking during an Iftar dinner…

Adoptive mother sentenced for fatal abuse of 7-year-old child

Gina Emmanuel appearing in court during her April 2025 murder trial in…