police tape
Share this @internewscast.com


A New York prosecutor said Sunday during a bond hearing that 9-year-old Shalom Guifarro cried out for her mother, Shemene Cato, 48, to help her before the child’s brutal death.

Brooklyn Assistant District Attorney David Ingle provided disturbing case details during a Sunday bond, according to the Brooklyn District Attorney’s Office.

As CrimeOnline previously reported, the incident happened in an apartment above a restaurant off of Lincoln Place in Crown Heights. Patrons at the restaurant below reportedly complained of a foul smell emanating from upstairs, “almost like sewage dripping into the restaurant from the apartment.”

Police arrived at the scene and found Shalom unresponsive after a 911 about the victim bering in distress. Shalom had had bites marks on her body and trauma to her head, police said. Patch reports that police found the little girl was unresponsive after a bed apparently been dropped on her while she was trying to hide from Cato.

“[Cato] lifted the bed and attempted to pull [Shalom] out from under the bed,” the criminal complaint read. “But [Cato] dropped the bed causing the leg to fall off the bed and the bed to fall on the head of Shalom Guifarro.”

Previous Video Coverage 

A medical examiner said the child died from a blunt-force impact that caused internal bleeding.

Shalom lived in the apartment with her mother and a 13-year-old sister. The older sibling reportedly told investigators about the beating carried out by Cato on the day in question.

The sister said that the girl’s mother “spanked” Shalom and put her in a time-out following a temper tantrum. The complaint filed on Tuesday accused Cato of beating the girls over a missing computer tablet. Shalom fled and hid under the bed, which Cato lifted and dropped on her head.

Neighbors told The New York Times that Cato was an “overprotective mother who seemed troubled.” She was said to have been abusive to her children, as well as her two dogs.

“She was crazy,” neighbor Rey Santiago said, adding that he saw the suspect once shove and yell at her daughter at a laundromat.

Cato was arraigned and charged with murder, manslaughter, assault, reckless endangerment of a child, and a weapons charge. She remains behind bars without bail.

For the latest true crime and justice news, subscribe to the ‘Crime Stories with Nancy Grace’ podcast.

Join Nancy Grace for her new online video series designed to help you protect what you love most — your children.

[Featured image: Shutterstock]



Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Trump Administration Requests Supreme Court Approval to Remove AEA Migrants

In the Oval Office at the White House in Washington, U.S. President…

Dispute Over Peacocks Harassment Escalates to Shooting Incident

A dispute over peacock harassment led to a shooting in Portland, Oregon…

Attorneys for Abrego Garcia: Trump Wrongly Asserts Privilege

Inset: Kilmar Abrego Garcia in updated photo (CASA). Background: President Donald Trump…

Husband Allegedly Shoots Wife, Later Claims Her Death Was a Suicide: Authorities Report

James Radford (Shawano County Sheriff’s Office). A man from Wisconsin reportedly asserted…

Witness Claims Fear for Life Prevented Him from Reporting Diddy’s Alleged Abuse Towards Cassie

A witness testified on Monday that he saw Sean “Diddy” Combs physically…

Lawsuit Regarding Gun Displayed in Zoom Meeting is Resolved

Background: Grand Traverse County Governmental Center (Grand Traverse County). Inset: FILE –…

Babysitter Convicted for Fatal Incident Involving Child in Bathtub

Left: Iesha Harris (Detroit Police Dept.). Right: Harmoni Henderson (GoFundMe). A 31-year-old…

Man Enters Ex’s Home Through Dog Door: Police Report

Caelan Ross (Escambia County Jail). A man from Florida was discovered lying…

Judge Appointed by Trump First to Support His Use of AEA for Removals

President Donald Trump boards Air Force One, Monday, May 12, 2025, at…

Wisconsin Man Accused in Wife’s Death Initially Claimed as Suicide

A Wisconsin man was arrested last month for the murder of his…

Law&Crime reveals AI-generated ‘video’ representation of Diddy trial

Law&Crime, a top legal and true crime media company, announces it will…

Dispute Over Dog Leads to Shooting at Wendy’s, Police Report

Background: The Wendy’s restaurant in Louisville, Ky., where a shooting incident occurred…