Mushroom cook is 'not on trial for lying', defence says
Share this @internewscast.com

Mushroom cook Erin Patterson is not on trial for lying and jurors should not find her guilty of triple murder based on her falsehoods, her barrister has argued.

Colin Mandy SC today advised the Victorian Supreme Court jury to consider the evidence logically and rationally as he entered the second day of his closing address.

He pointed to the lie Patterson told her lunch guests about having a cancerous lump on her elbow, saying jurors should not jump from that deception to finding her guilty of murder.

Erin Patterson's defence barrister Colin Mandy SC.
Erin Patterson’s defence barrister Colin Mandy SC. (Justin McManus)

“She’s not on trial for lying,” Mandy said.

“This is not a court of moral judgment.”

Prosecutors allege Patterson, 50, intentionally poisoned her former in-laws Don and Gail Patterson, Gail’s sister Heather, and Heather’s husband Ian Wilkinson.

Don, Gail and Heather all died after consuming the July 29, 2023 beef Wellington lunch served by Patterson at her home in regional Victoria, while Ian survived.

She has pleaded not guilty to three charges of murder and one count of attempted murder.

Prosecutors alleged Patterson made up the cancer claim so there would be a reason to have her guests over for lunch.

But Mandy argued that proposition was “illogical and irrational” as the guests were only told the lie after the beef Wellingtons were eaten.

“If this was a ruse, there was no need to have the conversation because the deed – on the crown case, the consumption of the food – had already happened,” he said.

“There was absolutely no need for Erin to say anything about cancer if that was a ruse.”

A courtroom sketch of Erin Patterson.
A courtroom sketch of Erin Patterson. (Paul Tyquin)

The defence barrister conceded it was a “stupid” lie, but it was made because Patterson was embarrassed about her plans to undergo weight-loss procedures.

Although she never had any surgery, Mandy told the jury Patterson did have an appointment scheduled with a clinic that performed liposuction.

He also raised the issue of an argument Patterson had in December 2022 with her ex-husband Simon over child support and the comments she made to Facebook friends about her in-laws.

In those messages, Patterson stated “this family, I swear to f—ing God” and “I’m sick of this shit, I want nothing to do with them”.

Mandy said she regretted using the words, but the tension was an aberration from her usual interactions with her in-laws.

The resounding evidence was that Patterson had a close and supportive relationship with Don and Gail, the court heard.

“In three short days, Erin made a handful of comments in the context of being hurt and frustrated … and that’s it,” he said.

Mandy encouraged the jury not to consider the evidence through hindsight, saying that could lead to irrelevant speculation.

“It doesn’t matter what you may have done in a similar situation,” he said.

LISTEN NOW: The Mushroom TrialSay Grace is the latest podcast from Nine and The Age. Join journalists Penelope Liersch and Erin Pearson as they take listeners inside the case that’s grabbed global headlines. You can listen on Apple here and Spotify here.
Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Man Accused in Fatal Gangland Shooting Incident in Sydney’s West

A man has been charged for his alleged role in the fatal…

Mother Accused of Shooting and Stabbing Son to “End His Suffering”: Police

Inset: Krista Roy (St. Charles County Jail). Background: The Missouri home where…

Police Discover Missing Woman Hidden in Attic in Gruesome Crime Scene

Insets, top to bottom: Douglas Shaw and Renia Lewis (Vallejo Police Department).…

Mother-in-Law Allegedly Hired Hit on Law Professor Son-in-Law; Jury Misconduct May Lead to Her Release

After nearly three weeks of testimony, a jury swiftly reached a verdict…

Woman Causes Disturbance at Little Caesars Over $1 Sauces: Police Report

Share copy link Inset: Breanna Haynes (Louisville Metro Police Department). Background: The…

Tragic Incident: Child’s Death in Car Window Leads to Mother’s Charges, Say Police

Inset: Kandice Grace (Fulton County Jail). Background: The street in Atlanta where…

QuikTrip Dispute Over Right-of-Way Escalates to Tragedy, Police Report

Inset from left to right: Alfred Jackson Jr. and Olivia Guster (Denton…

Police Report: Teen Involved in Fatal Stabbing Incident

Background: News footage showing the residence in Carrolltown, Pennsylvania, where two individuals…

Wealthy Financier’s Personal Assistant Accused of Aiding in Scheme to Lure Models to Secretive Location: FBI

The personal assistant of retired financier Howard Rubin reportedly helped him lure…

Former mayor and ex-state trooper receives verdict for accident

Inset left: A.J. Scott (City of Buchanan). Inset right: Isabella Chinchilla and…

Driver Who Intentionally Hit and Killed Two Kangaroos Avoids Jail Time

A man who deliberately swerved to kill two kangaroos with his ute…

Family Secures Significant Compensation from Agency Following Son’s Tragic Passing

Noah Cuatro smiles in a photograph (GoFundMe). Los Angeles County will compensate…