‘Please don’t shoot me. I’m sorry’: Person of Interest Arrested, Search Continues for Missing Wisconsin Woman

Authorities have apprehended a person of interest linked to the disappearance of Gabriella Cartagena, a Wisconsin woman who has been missing for nearly a week.

The Marinette Police Department reports that Cartagena, 24, was last spotted on February 4 at Red Arrow Park in Marinette around 5 p.m. Her case is being treated as an “involuntary” disappearance.

Robert Chilcote, 29, was detained after a high-speed chase in Monticello. Chilcote had been sought for questioning in connection with an “aggravated assault and possible homicide,” according to FOX 11.

Chilcote faces charges for fleeing a law enforcement officer in a vehicle and for being a fugitive from a different state.

During the arrest, authorities allegedly discovered an “AR-15 rifle with an inserted magazine” inside Chilcote’s vehicle, as reported by WBAY.

Family and friends recall that Cartagena was last seen with Chilcote when they left for a grocery store, and at the time, there was no indication of anything amiss.

However, during a phone call, family members reportedly heard Cartagena say,”Please don’t shoot me. I’m sorry.”

Police are currently searching for a red Toyota Prius, with Wisconsin license plates, in connection with Cartagena’s disappearance.

Heart-Wrenching Plea: Arrest Made as Search Intensifies for Missing Wisconsin Woman
Marinette Police Department

Menominee and township residents are urged to check security footage between 9:25 p.m. and 9:45 p.m. on February 4.

“We did do an expanded search yesterday. We are continuing to follow up on all leads and are attempting to obtain any camera footage which may assist us in our investigation,” Police Chief Jon LaCombe told FOX 11 on Monday.

“At this point I have no other information to provide and we are still attempting to locate whereabouts of the female,”

Heart-Wrenching Plea: Arrest Made as Search Intensifies for Missing Wisconsin Woman
Robert Chilcote/Menominee Police Department via FOX 11

Cartagena is described as a Hispanic female who stands 5 feet, 6 inches tall, and weighs around 130 pounds. She has brown hair and eyes.

She was last seen in black joggers with a logo on the hip, a black robe, and tan slipper-like shoes.

Anyone with information is urged to contact the Marinette Police Department’s detective division at zneumann@marinette.wi.us or at 715-732-5200. Tipsters with vehicle images should contact Menominee County 911 at 906-863-6614.

Anonymous tipsters should use the Crime Stoppers P3 app, or go to www.mmcrimestoppers.com.

Chilcote remains behind bars on a $100,000 bond.

Check back for updates.

[Feature Photo: Gabriella Cartagena/Marinette Police Department]

You May Also Like

Federal Judge Tosses Trump Administration Lawsuit Seeking to Force Michigan Officials to Cooperate With ICE

FILE – President Donald Trump speaks in the East Room of the…

Father Killed Daughter, 14, Her Brother and Shot Girlfriend at Home: Police

Inset left: Zion Savion Terry (Obituary). Inset middle: Levy Nelson (Richmond Police…

Ex-Overstock CEO Defies Judge on LindellTV, Lawyers Notice

Patrick Byrne appears on Emerald Robinson’s LindellTV show in July 2026 (court…

Authorities Say Couple Left 3 Kids in Filthy Black Mold-Filled Home, Admitted It Was Bad and Refused Police Entry

Inset, left to right: Timothy MacDonald and Lana MacDonald (Pike County Detention…

Driver Hits Child After Ignoring School Bus Stop Arm, Police Say

Inset: Ashley Parsons (Scott County Detention Center). Background: The black SUV authorities…

Woman Shot Ex 17 Times Over His Spiritual Demons, Police Say

Inset: Rebecca Jane Mryglod (Cleburne County Sheriff’s Office). Background: Cleburne County Sheriff’s…