Trump-appointed judge blocks AEA removal, but with a catch
Share this @internewscast.com

FILE — Republican presidential nominee, former President Donald Trump, observes a video screen during a campaign rally at the Salem Civic Center in Salem, Virginia, on Nov. 2, 2024. (AP Photo/Evan Vucci, File).

A California judge delivered another setback to the Trump administration’s immigration policies on Monday, preventing the deportation of a Venezuelan migrant under the Alien Enemies Act of 1798 (AEA), but with certain stipulations.

Darwin Antonio Arevalo Millan, a Venezuelan national detained at an Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) facility in Adelanto, California, is permitted to stay in the U.S. after a ruling from U.S. District Judge John Holcomb, who found that Millan’s due process rights were violated. Although Holcomb, a Trump appointee, acknowledged this, he also stated that the attempt to deport Millan under the AEA—a legal provision from the 18th century last invoked during World War II for the internment of Japanese Americans—was not “unlawful” as argued by Arevalo’s attorneys in court documents.

In fact, Holcomb went as far as to declare the president’s “authority” under the AEA as being nearly “unlimited” in his order, citing a 1948 Supreme Court ruling in Ludecke v. Watkins, a case where the deportation of a German “alien enemy” was found to be constitutional under the AEA due to the president’s wartime power, which appears to be “as unlimited as the legislature could make it,” per the ruling.

“In short, the AEA’s grant of authority to the President is close to ‘unlimited,”” Holcomb argued, citing Ludecke v. Watkins.

“And it includes the ability to decide whether an invasion or predatory incursion has occurred,” he said. “As such, this court cannot construe those terms without constraining the president’s authority under the AEA,” the judge added.

Love true crime? Sign up for our newsletter, The Law&Crime Docket, to get the latest real-life crime stories delivered right to your inbox.

Holcomb concluded that although Arevalo, who filed a motion for a temporary restraining order to block his deportation, is unlikely to succeed on the merits of his claim that the use of the AEA is unlawful, he is likely to succeed on the merits of his due process claims. This is because of the government’s own omission that it must provide detainees “notice and process” before removing them under the AEA, according to Holcomb.

“Indeed, the Government … does not appear to disagree that Arevalo will succeed on his due process claims,” the judge said. “Instead, the Government argues that Arevalo has necessarily already received adequate notice and process because he filed a habeas petition.”

According to Holcomb, these arguments are “unavailing” and the court is “hard-pressed to conclude” that the filing somehow means Arevalo has already received adequate process and notice.

“Similarly, although the Government indicates that it will provide detainees with more than 24 hours’ notice of their removals … the Government refused to tell the Court how much notice it actually intends to provide,” he said.

More from Law&Crime: ‘Turned the constitutional structure upside down’: Trump admin asks SCOTUS to halt ‘indefensible’ court order and permit mass termination of federal workers

Arevalo’s lawsuit states he was allegedly arrested after he reported for an ICE check-in that he had scheduled. According to the lawsuit, Arevalo was arrested due to an alleged affiliation with the notorious Venezuelan gang Tren de Aragua (TdA), with his tattoos being used against him as proof, his lawyers say.

“His arrest was premised upon his status as a Venezuelan with tattoos, which, although allegedly basketball-related, could indicate that Arevalo is affiliated with Tren de Aragua,” Holcomb said.

His ruling comes as the Trump administration continues to deal with lawsuits and judicial decisions related to the president’s use of the AEA, along with allegations of civil rights violations and court mandates being ignored.

One of the most noteworthy cases surrounds a Maryland man and father named Kilmar Abrego Garcia, who was deported to El Salvador despite his protected status. His attorneys have accused the government of defying a federal judge and the U.S. Supreme Court by refusing to provide any information regarding what has been done to “facilitate” his return to the U.S. after he was shipped off in March.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Miles Taylor Calls for Investigation into Trump’s Executive Order Targeting Him

From left to right: Miles Taylor is seen on CNN in August…

Sean ‘Diddy’ Combs Court Case: $30K Paid to Hotel Guard for Cassie Assault Footage, $1M NDA Signed

The security guard at the California hotel where Sean “Diddy” Combs was…

Appeal Over Tariffs to Be Reviewed by Three Trump-Appointed Judges in D.C. Circuit

President Donald Trump participates in the 157th National Memorial Day Observance at…

Inmate Charged for Threatening Trump to Deport Man: District Attorney

Left: Donald Trump speaks at the annual Road to Majority conference in…

Leading Jan. 6 Prosecutor Resigns from DOJ, Criticizes Pardon Decision

Background: Supporters loyal to President Donald Trump gather at the U.S. Capitol…

Police: Man Planned to Watch Ex-Girlfriend Sleep Through Her Window

Inset: Jalen Vallejos (Volusia County Sheriff’s Office). Background: Vallejos after deputies apprehended…

Teenagers revisited crime scene to record disturbing celebration

Insets, left to right: Freddy Patterson and Charles Adams (Maricopa County Sheriff’s…

Newark Mayor Files Lawsuit Against Alina Habba Following Arrest Incident at ICE Facility

Left: Alina Habba, who was formerly President Donald Trump’s attorney, is pictured…

Court Decides Against Trump in Case Involving Transgender Prisoners

President Donald Trump pauses as he speaks in the Oval Office of…

Caregiver Accused of Misusing Client’s Bank Account for Grocery Shopping and Food Orders

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – A 22-year-old named Marquisha S. Jackson was…

Lawsuit Claims Trump Administration Overlooked Immigrant DNA Collection FOIA Requests

President Donald Trump attends the signing of the Laken Riley Act in…

North Carolina Man Intentionally Crashes Head-on in Plot to End Wife’s Life

A North Carolina man faces multiple charges after police say he deliberately…