Another judge swats down Jan. 6 rioter's restitution refund
Share this @internewscast.com

Left inset: Donald Trump speaks at the annual Road to Majority conference in Washington, DC, June 22, 2024. (Allison Bailey/NurPhoto via AP). Center inset: Derek Kinnison (Justice Department). Right inset: Senior U.S. District Judge Royce Lamberth (U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia). Background: Violent insurrectionists loyal to President Donald Trump breach the U.S. Capitol in Washington, Jan. 6, 2021 (AP Photo/John Minchillo).

A federal judge has dismissed a request from another Jan. 6 defendant seeking a refund of restitution after being pardoned by President Donald Trump. This marks the fifth instance where a refund request has been declined by Washington, D.C. judges.

The recent denial came from Senior U.S. District Judge Royce Lamberth, who had previously issued a similar rejection. The defendant, Derek Kinnison, 42, from Lake Elsinore, faced a 33-month prison sentence for participating in the 2021 Capitol incident with members of the Three Percenter militia, as detailed by the Justice Department.

In his decision, Lamberth referenced the U.S. Supreme Court’s 1877 ruling in Knote v. United States, which described a pardon as “an act of grace” that doesn’t return “rights or property once vested in others due to the conviction and judgment.” This reasoning was outlined in a five-page order.

Kinnison was also critiqued by Lamberth for trying to align his case with another Supreme Court case, Nelson v. Colorado, where pardoned defendants successfully reclaimed payments deposited into state accounts after their overturned convictions — due to trial errors or post-conviction issues, as per Lamberth.

“The defendant seeks to equate the reversal of the petitioners’ convictions in Nelson with the vacatur of his conviction by the D.C. Circuit,” stated Lamberth, appointed by Ronald Reagan. “However, the defendant’s conviction was not reversed; it was only vacated due to the presidential pardon. Moreover, the court’s authority to issue a refund does not depend on the vacatur of the conviction but rather on entitlement to the funds. The defendant had paid the full $2,350, which was deposited.”

Lamberth noted how the government attempted to “save the defendant’s argument” by referring to the deposit of funds in the Treasury as “erroneous.” The funds at issue here were not “erroneously received,” he concluded, noting the nation’s highest court “made clear” in Knote that while “a pardon is an act of grace,” it ultimately “does not make amends for the past.”

“The defendant’s conviction was fully ‘in force’ at the time he paid the $2,350 in assessments and restitution,” Lamberth concluded, citing Knote. “Therefore, the funds were not ‘erroneously received’ by the Treasury, and the court will not — indeed, it may not — order a refund here.”

U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan was the last person on the bench in Washington to deny a restitution and fine refund. Stacy Hager, 61, was charged and convicted in 2023 of four misdemeanors related to the Capitol breach. He requested a $570 refund in February. Federal prosecutors signed off on Hager’s request, as they did with Kinnison and other Jan. 6 defendants, saying there was “no longer any basis justifying the government’s retaining funds.” Chutkan was not convinced and cited previous rejections.

“At least three other judges in this district have denied similar motions where defendants sought reimbursement for fines and fees associated with their now pardoned criminal convictions,” the Barack Obama appointee wrote in her three-page order on July 3. “The government concurs, acknowledging that pardons generally do not ‘make amends for the past’ nor do they afford any ‘relief for what has been suffered by the offender,'” Chutkan said. “But it takes the curious position that in this ‘unusual situation,’ reimbursement is appropriate.”

Chief U.S. District Judge James Boasberg and U.S. District Judge Randolph Moss are the other District of Columbia judges who have turned down requests from Jan. 6 defendants in recent months.

Boasberg, a Barack Obama appointee, rebuffed a request from a Maryland couple on June 30 who asked for roughly $1,000 in restitution to be returned. Moss, another Obama appointee, said no to a former U.S. Marine from New Jersey; Lamberth previously denied Utah defendant John Sullivan.

Trump’s mass pardon of Jan. 6 rioters earlier this year granted clemency to more than 1,500 defendants.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

US Conspiracy Theorist in Wieambilla Shooting Case Strikes Plea Deal on Lesser Charge

Donald Day Jr, hailing from Arizona, recently appeared in a U.S. court…

Police Report: Mother Accused of Strangling Her 6-Year-Old Child in Sudden Outburst

Inset: Justine Mroz (Pasco County Sheriff’s Office). Background: The house where Mroz…

Mother Charged After Child Tragically Dies in 107-Degree Parked Car

Inset left to right: Ariel Osbey and Imani Osbey (Alcovy Judicial Circuit…

Police Discover Man on Top of Girlfriend After Fatal Stabbing

Share A Connecticut man faces murder charges after authorities discovered him atop…

Texas Man Faces Charges in Fatal Assault of Schoolteacher Wife

A Texas man is facing charges for the murder of his wife,…

Man Sentenced After Shocking Crime and Disturbing FaceTime Call

Inset left: Taton Dorfman (Pima County Sheriff”s Department). Inset right: Hannah Rogers…

Justice Served: Mother Sentenced for Tragic Neglect Leading to Son’s Starvation

Sherrilynn Hawkins appearing in court in October 2025 (WPVI). Inset: Tylim Hatchett…

Husband Allegedly Struck and Killed by Wife After Leaving Home

Inset: Alina Gonzalez-Morelos (Pasadena Police Department). Background: The sidewalk near where Gonzalez-Morelos…

Georgia Couple Faces Charges of Child Cruelty After Three Young Children Discovered Unattended at Campsite

In a troubling incident in Carroll County, Georgia, authorities have charged a…

Authorities Conduct Thorough Search of Rural Toowoomba Property in Connection to Alleged Dismemberment Case

A man has been charged with murder as police search for the…

Teen Expresses Remorse to Family After Tragic Incident Involving Friend

Background: News footage of Rolan Delacruz during his sentencing on Oct. 20…

Fugitive Nicholas Rossi Sentenced for Rape After Elaborate Fake Death and International Escape

A man from Rhode Island who staged his own death before escaping…