Trump blasted by legal experts over suspending habeas corpus
Share this @internewscast.com

Inset: Stephen Miller responds to immigration inquiries (C-SPAN). Background: President Donald Trump participates in the Building America’s Future, Southeastern Pennsylvania Roundtable at the Drexelbrook Event Center on October 29, 2024, in Drexel Hill, Pennsylvania (Matt Bishop/imageSPACE/Sipa USA via AP Images).

The Trump administration‘s floated discussion of suspending the writ of habeas corpus immediately drew strong condemnation in the legal community.

Late Friday, C-SPAN aired a statement from top White House adviser Stephen Miller, indicating the government is “actively considering” halting the writ. He mentioned it hinges on whether the courts take the right steps. CNN later corroborated the gravity of these remarks, revealing that “two individuals with knowledge of the discussions” confirmed President Donald Trump was personally engaged in these talks.

Miller’s statement clarified the previously hinted frustrations of the 45th and 47th president during a press conference in late April. The Trump administration is increasingly agitated by court rulings preventing the immediate deportation of undocumented immigrants under the Alien Enemies Act.

“[T]he short version is that the Founders were hell-bent on limiting, to the most egregious emergencies, the circumstances in which courts could be cut out of the loop,” Georgetown University Law Prof. Steve Vladeck wrote on his blog. “To casually suggest that habeas might be suspended because courts have ruled against the executive branch in a handful of immigration cases is to turn the Suspension Clause entirely on its head.”

Love true crime? Sign up for our newsletter, The Law&Crime Docket, to get the latest real-life crime stories delivered right to your inbox.

The law professor went on to say Miller was “wrong” about the conditions necessary to revoke habeas under the U.S. Constitution.

“Well, the Constitution is clear,” Miller said. “And that, of course, is the supreme law of the land, that the privilege of the writ of habeas corpus can be suspended in a time of invasion.”

Vladeck’s response to that claim goes on, at length [emphasis in original]:

The Suspension Clause does not say habeas can be suspended during any invasion; it says “The Privilege of the Writ of Habeas Corpus shall not be suspended, unless when in Cases of Rebellion or Invasion the public Safety may require it.” This last part, with my emphasis, is not just window-dressing; again, the whole point is that the default is for judicial review except when there is a specific national security emergency in which judicial review could itself exacerbate the emergency. The emergency itself isn’t enough.

The writ of habeas corpus is a 900-year-old legal protection afforded to persons against authoritarian impulses of law enforcement and government executives which allows an advocate to argue someone is being illegally confined, detained or imprisoned. It is generally considered the bedrock of the American and British legal systems.

The writ also attempts to force the government to answer questions in court and account for its actions by forcing an administrative process on, for example, the detention and deportation of immigrants.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Roommate Found Dead, Body Hidden in Carpet and Necktie

Left inset: Marvin Jean-Pierre (Broward County Sheriff’s Office). Right inset: Jose Mondelus…

Breaking News: Body Found in Wheel Well of American Airlines Aircraft

A body was found Sunday in the wheel well of an American…

Motorist fatally shoots man during road rage confrontation: Police

Left: Jaden Harris (Sanford police). Right: Joseph Hall (Allen-Beyer Funeral Home). A…

Father Fatally Assaults Infant Against Crib, Police Report

Background: Buildings on the 5800 block of Northwest Drive in Mesquite, Texas…

Man Accused of Shooting Gun at Bar During Cowboys Game

Inset: David Callum (North Richland Hills Police Department). Background: The sports bar…

Wisconsin Teacher Breaks Down in Court Over Charges of Inappropriately Approaching 11-Year-Old Boy

A former elementary school teacher from Wisconsin reportedly became emotional in court…

Ohio Men Officially Charged in Case of Pregnant Woman Found Encased in Plastic Tote

Two men from Ohio have been accused in relation to the death…

Police: Man Found Holding Child and Elderly Woman in Deplorable Living Conditions

A June 2024 photo depicts the Muncie, Indiana house where Daniel Good…

Tragic Incident: Woman Fatally Shot by Man in Front of Her Daughters

Background: News footage shows Charles Lee Dawson (far right) with his attorney…

Mother Accidentally Spills Medication on Play Mat, Leading to Baby’s Hospitalization: Police Report

Inset: Cheyenne Pope (Duval County Jail). Background: UF Health Hospital in Jacksonville,…

John Eastman Requests Court to Overrule Disbarment Suggestion

FILE – Attorney John Eastman, known for crafting a legal plan intended…

Mother Instructed Son into Lake and Observed Him Submerge: Police Report

Left inset: Ruth Miller (Tuscarawas County Sheriff’s Office). Right inset: The boat…