Retrial ordered over father's home invasion murder
Share this @internewscast.com

A man jailed for at least 15 years for a violent home invasion murder will get a second go at acquittal after prosecutors admitted a significant jury error.

During an armed robbery targeting thousands of dollars in cash, 49-year-old father-of-two Warwick Hunter was stabbed to death in his western Sydney home.

Samir Chamma, 32, and John Hicks, 35, were found guilty of murder in 2023 after a jury found they were both knew there was a “non-fanciful probability” Hunter would be killed.

Warwick Hunter, 49, stabbed to death in Sydney’s north in 2020. (NSW Police Force)

Chamma successfully had his conviction quashed and a retrial ordered by the NSW Court of Criminal Appeal today.

Crown prosecutors admitted they had not told jurors that a key witness, who cannot be legally identified, had received a discounted sentence for other offences in exchange for co-operating in the trial.

“[The] breach of the duty of disclosure could realistically have affected the reasoning of the jury as to the verdict of guilty that was returned and thus gives rise to a miscarriage of justice,” prosecutors told the court.

Chamma and Hicks had been accused of committing the opportunistic robbery with a third man after being told Hunter had a large sum of cash at his Toongabbie home.

Hicks stabbed Hunter, but Chamma knew of the knife and helped create a handmade sheath beforehand, Justice Sarah McNaughton found when sentencing the pair in September 2023.

At the time, Hicks was sentenced to 23 years’ imprisonment with a non-parole period of 16 years, while Chamma received 21 years with a non-parole period of 15 years and nine months.

Chamma’s successful appeal will see him head into a retrial.

He will be re-arraigned in the NSW Supreme Court on July 4.

The appeal court rejected Chamma’s further claims that the verdict of murder was unreasonable.

He argued he should be acquitted on this charge and sent back to a retrial for the lesser offence of manslaughter.

However, two of the three appeal judges found it was open to jurors to find him guilty of murder.

It was open for them to find he went ahead with the robbery despite knowing there was a probability that death or really serious injury could result, Justices Mark Leeming and Robertson Wright said.

In dissent, Justice Belinda Rigg said she would have acquitted Chamma of murder.

She said she could not be satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that he knew Hicks would use the knife intending to kill or cause grievous bodily harm.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Woman Accused of Bribing Officers After Fatal Cyclist Accident: Police

News footage captures a memorial for Radahámez Rodriguez Pérez at the site…

Ex-Beauty and the Geek Contestant Charged with Partner’s Murder

Detectives are calling for the public’s help to track the movements of…

Kenneth Chesebro, Trump’s Attorney, Disbarred by Appeals Court

Inset: FILE – Kenneth Chesebro speaks to Fulton County Superior Court Judge…

No Leniency Shown by Judge in Hate-Driven Murder Case Conviction

Background: Footage from the courtroom shows Judge Donald Zuidmulder at the sentencing…

Shocking Report: 5th Grade Girls Allegedly Plan Classmate’s Murder, Intend to Disguise It as Suicide

Authorities in Arizona have detained four fifth-grade girls who allegedly planned to…

Trenton resident apprehended after a nearly 3-mile motorcycle chase through Gainesville

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Yesterday morning, 19-year-old Michael Thomas Williamson from…

Travis Decker: Authorities Doubt Fugitive Father Suspected of Killing His 3 Kids Remains in Washington or is Alive

After a thorough three-week investigation in the mountainous regions of Washington state,…

Police Report: Man Allegedly Laughed in Jail Following Rival’s Shooting

Background: Pat”s Bar in Dayton, Ohio (Google Maps). Inset: Jacob Brady (Montgomery…

Authorities Report Woman Murders Victim and Conceals Body in Futon

Background: 4400 block of Frankford Avenue, Philadelphia (Google Maps) Inset: Gerelys Sanchez-Reyes…

Three Arrested in Connection with $3.4 Million Sea Cocaine Retrieval Plot

Three men have been charged over an alleged plot to import 1.5…

Judge Rejects Requests to Postpone Bryan Kohberger Trial and Present ‘Alternative Suspects’

The judge presiding over the case of the criminology student charged with…

Man’s Sentence Revealed for Assisting in Moving 5-Year-Old’s Body

Left to right: Benjamin Rivera and Samuel Olson (Houston Police Dept.). A…