Share this @internewscast.com

The Ohio father accused of executing his three young sons in front of his wife and daughter appeared in court this week and asked a judge to throw out his statements claiming detectives violated his rights.

Prosecutors have said Chad Doerman, 32, made statements last June such as “I did it. Take me to jail” and “I shouldn’t have done that” after he was taken into custody for the shooting deaths of Clayton, 7, Hunter, 4, and Chase, 3. Prosecutors said Doerman told detectives he had been thinking about murdering his sons eight months before the shooting. He faces the possibility of the death penalty if convicted of the aggravated murders.

Clermont County sheriff’s deputies found Doerman sitting on his front porch with a .22 caliber rifle sitting next to him. His sons were dead in his yard. While walking Doerman to a police cruiser in handcuffs, Deputy Jeffrey Rudd said, “You have the right to remain silent. F—— use it,” when Doerman asked, “can you get the wallet out of my pocket?”

Doerman’s lawyers claim the deputies mishandled their communications with him from the start. Rudd didn’t back down when questioned about what he said to Doerman during the hearing.

Detective Michael Ross questioned Doerman once he arrived at the sheriff’s office. Ross said he tried to build a rapport with Doerman by giving him a bottle of water and readjusting his handcuffs.

Ross said he believed Doerman wanted to speak with him but conceded on cross-examination that he didn’t read the entire card outlining Doerman’s Miranda rights, including a portion that discussed the right to have a lawyer present during questioning.

“I’m not a robot. I probably should have read the entire card, but I’m not a robot,” Ross said.

Doerman’s attorney, W. Stephen Haynes, questioned Ross further about whether he omitted parts of the card because he feared Doerman might not want to speak with him. Ross denied it and said he felt Doerman wanted to speak with him because he said, “that’s fine,” when he first started to read his rights to him.

Ross also explained that Doerman brought up “a lawyer” a couple of times during the interview and mentioned his father, Keith Doerman, and a woman named Ruby Franklin. Doerman, he claimed, said Franklin was with the CIA, but neither she nor Keith Doerman were lawyers.

Former Ohio Deputy Attorney General Mark Weaver told Crime Fix a defendant must clearly request a lawyer for questioning by law enforcement to stop.

“Defense counsel here doesn’t have much to work with,” Weaver said. “All of us have rights under the Constitution. But we also have obligations to make known whether or not we’re waiving those rights or whether we’re standing on those rights. Officers do not have to be mind readers.”

Weaver said some of Doerman’s statements about lawyers could be construed as vague. But, ultimately, the judge will make that decision. 

Ross said he felt Doerman “muddied the waters” and was “playing games” when he mentioned having “family lawyers” and said at one point he would get “nice, good answers” to questions after talking to a lawyer.

Ross said Doerman denied killing his sons throughout the interview. But, when left alone in the room, he muttered things under his breath that indicated he had murdered his sons, Ross said.

Doerman’s lawyers dropped some hints at what the defense might include at trial through some of its questioning. Haynes asked Detective Ross whether he had dealt with mentally ill defendants in the past and whether he knew about “psychosis.”

“Now you’re getting outside of my knowledge of mentally ill people,” Detective Ross responded.

Judge Richard Ferenc said he would decide on Doerman’s motion to suppress after reading briefs from the state and the defense following the hearing. The ruling could come in the next month.

Doerman’s trial is scheduled to begin in July. He remains held without bail in the Clermont County Jail.

 

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Tragic Road Rage Incident Claims Life of Delivery Driver, Police Report

Left inset: Laken Logan (Jackson County Sheriff’s Office). Right inset: Cleveland Wright…

Daycare Worker Accused of Injuring Infant in Disturbing Incident

Inset: Ashley Marie Karschnick (Fond du Lac County Jail). Background: Lily Pad…

Perth’s Infamous Killer Revealed: Shocking Miscarriage of Justice Uncovered as Innocent Men Exonerated

Serial killer Eric Edgar Cooke became the last person to be executed…

Suspect in Melbourne Carjacking Crashes Taxi in City Center

A man has been arrested after allegedly carjacking and crashing a taxi…

Tragic Hit-and-Run in Los Angeles Claims Life of Elderly Woman; Authorities Offer $50K Reward for Leads

Authorities are intensifying their efforts to locate the driver of a black…

Gainesville Resident Apprehended for Alleged Tip Jar Theft and Filing a False Police Report

GAINESVILLE, Fla. – In a twist of events early this morning, 21-year-old…

Sydney Crackdown: Massive Wave of Charges Issued in Two-Day Anti-Crime Operation

More than 200 charges were laid and 95 people arrested during a…

Pre-Trial Release Breach: Man Arrested for Assault with Camp Saw

Staff Report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – A 40-year-old man, Brandon Levelle Lindsey, faces…

Couple Sentenced for St. Patrick’s Day Murder of Man’s Former Partner

From left: Margarita Jimenez and Jorge Garfias (Ventura County District Attorney) and…

Breaking News: Tragic Incident at Pennsylvania University Homecoming Leaves One Dead, Six Injured

A night meant for celebration turned tragic at a Pennsylvania university when…

Urgent Search Underway: 71-Year-Old Man Disappears from Umatilla Indian Reservation in Oregon

The Umatilla Tribal Police Department is actively seeking the public’s help to…

Woman Faces Attempted Murder Charges for Allegedly Shooting at Police Officers

A woman from Tasmania faces charges of attempted murder following an incident…