Supreme Court rules unanimously in favor of Marlean Ames
Share this @internewscast.com

Main: Marlean Ames (CBS News). Inset: The Justices of the Supreme Court pose for a new group photograph in Washington, Friday, Oct. 7, 2022. Bottom row, from left, Associate Justice Sonia Sotomayor, Associate Justice Clarence Thomas, Chief Justice of the United States John Roberts, Associate Justice Samuel Alito, and Associate Justice Elena Kagan. Top row, from left, Associate Justice Amy Coney Barrett, Associate Justice Neil Gorsuch, Associate Justice Brett Kavanaugh, and Associate Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson (AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite).

The U.S. Supreme Court has unanimously decided in favor of a heterosexual woman from Ohio who argued she was subjected to what has been termed “reverse discrimination” by the Ohio Department of Youth Services (ODYS).

In the ruling, all nine justices held that there are no extra requirements for discrimination plaintiffs who belong to a majority group.

Marlean Ames had been employed at ODYS for 18 years. When she started reporting to a new supervisor who is gay, she applied for a promotion but was not selected. Shortly after being overlooked for the promotion, Ames was removed from her current position and was only provided with the choice of returning to a previous role that offered a significantly lower salary.

Love true crime? Sign up for our newsletter, The Law&Crime Docket, to get the latest real-life crime stories delivered right to your inbox.

The department then hired a gay woman for the position that Ames had sought and a gay man to fill the position from which Ames was removed. Ames claims that both individuals were less qualified for the positions and that she was discriminated against because of her sexuality. ODYS disputes Ames’ claims and says the staffing changes were the result of agency-wide restructuring and that Ames had difficulties getting along with co-workers.

Ames sued for violation of her rights under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, and lost at both the district and circuit court levels. Both courts ruled that Ames, as a heterosexual person, needed and failed to present evidence of “background circumstances” that suggested ODYS was discriminating against members of a majority group.

At issue before the Supreme Court was whether the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit’s “background circumstances” rule really is applicable and requires different evidence from members of a minority versus a majority group.

In a nine-page opinion, Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson wrote for the Court and rejected the “‘background circumstances” rule entirely.

Jackson wrote that Title VII bars employers from intentionally discriminating against their employees on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, or national origin — and that its requirements are no different for majority group members. Jackson explained that the 6th Circuit’s rule simply cannot be squared with Supreme Court precedent and noted that Ohio presented no justification for imposing a heightened evidentiary standard on majority-group plaintiffs.

“By establishing the same protections for every ‘individual’ — without regard to that individual’s membership in a minority or majority group — Congress left no room for courts to impose special requirements on majority-group plaintiffs alone,” Jackson wrote.

Justice Clarence Thomas penned a 13-page concurring opinion which was joined by Justice Neil Gorsuch. In it, Thomas warned that the framework established in 1973 to evaluate employment discrimination claims may not be “workable and useful.”

“Judge-made doctrines have a tendency to distort the underlying statutory text, impose unnecessary burdens on litigants, and cause confusion for courts,” Thomas wrote. “The ‘background circumstances’ rule — correctly rejected by the Court today — is one example of this phenomenon.”

The Court’s ruling Thursday does not mean that Ames wins her case against ODYS, only that her claim may proceed on its merits.

You can read the Court’s full ruling here.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Driver Convicted for Fatal Crash That Claimed Two Lives at Restaurant

Left: Steven Bailey. Right: A video showing Bailey crashing into a crowded…

Mercedes Tragedy: Wealthy Socialite Fatally Hits Brothers and Makes Shocking Request from Jail.

Convicted socialite Rebecca Grossman is demanding a venue change in the wrongful…

Burglar Who Murdered Expectant Amish Woman Receives Prison Sentence

Inset: Shawn Christopher Cranston (Crawford County Correctional Facility). Background: Fish Flats Road,…

Man Accused of Shooting at Father with Two Children Nearby

Share copy link Shakir Moss (Shelby County Sheriff’s Office). A man from…

Vandals Target Major Australian Logistics Company in Anti-Israel Incident

Anti-Israel activists have recorded themselves vandalising the head office of one of…

Federal Officers Arrest Delta Co-Pilot in Cockpit on Child Sex Abuse Allegations After Landing

Federal agents arrested a Delta Air Lines co-pilot immediately upon landing at…

Gainesville Resident Receives 90-Month Federal Prison Sentence for Drug and Firearm Crimes

Press release from the U.S. Attorney’s Office, Northern District of Florida GAINESVILLE,…

Gainesville Resident Arrested for Brandishing Firearm at Downtown Billiards Venue

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Melvin Eugene Miller, Jr., 38, was apprehended…

Michigan Resident Faces Terrorism Charges in Walmart Stabbing Incident

A 42-year-old man from Michigan has been charged with terrorism and eleven…

Boyfriend Unable to Physically Confront Husband, Resorts to Shooting: Police Report

Inset: Micah Hill (Edmond Police Department). Background: The Biomat USA Plasma Center…

Trump urges quick testimony session for Rupert Murdoch

Left: President Donald Trump addresses the press during a gathering with Britain’s…

Ghislaine Maxwell: Claims She’s Not Suicidal; Will She Survive to Testify?

Could Ghislaine Maxwell share the same destiny as her former lover, Jeffrey…