'He should have got off me': 17-year-old shot and killed while trying to break up argument between adults, deputies say

Inset: Trenton Robinson (Palm Beach County Sheriff”s Office). Background: The house where Robinson allegedly shot a 17-year-old in Boynton Beach, Fla. (Google Maps).

A Florida man has been arrested after allegedly shooting and killing a teenager who intervened in a domestic dispute, authorities in the state have reported.

Trenton Robinson, aged 24, faces charges of second-degree murder with a firearm, as detailed in Palm Beach County court documents.

The tragic event took place on December 28 at a home on Northwest Ninth Avenue in Boynton Beach, a city within the greater Miami metropolitan area.

Local police responded to reports of a shooting late that morning, according to a probable cause affidavit obtained by Law&Crime.

Upon their arrival, officers found 17-year-old Josiah Jones with a gunshot wound to his abdomen. Emergency medical services transported him to Delray Medical Center, where he succumbed to his injuries.

Investigators revealed that Robinson was at the residence to pick up his young son from the child’s mother. During the visit, an argument erupted between the parents. As tensions rose, the teenager, Jones, attempted to intervene to calm the situation, according to the affidavit.

In the process, Robinson and the teen “grabbed a hold of one another,” according to the charging document. The pair “ended up on a bed still holding one another and that is when Josiah was shot.”

Police say Robinson was taken into custody there and “spontaneously uttered” an admission of sorts: “I f–d up. It was an accident.”

Detectives also interviewed the mother of the slain boy, who said she overheard her daughter and the defendant arguing and asked Josiah to go downstairs and separate them. The woman said she then went downstairs herself, heard a “pop,” and saw her son fall to the ground. Josiah’s mother next recalled her daughter saying: “You just shot my brother.”

Investigators also spoke with the sister of the victim. She said Robinson came to pick up his son when they began arguing. The sister said the argument “ended up getting loud but not physical.”

She said Josiah got in between her and Robinson and that her brother grabbed the defendant. As the two fell on the bed, Josiah allegedly held Robinson in a “bear hug,” according to the charging document.

The sister relayed the final moments as follows:

[Robinson] was trying to get up and saying, “get off me.” [Robinson] then removed a gun from his pocket and shot Josiah in the stomach. [The sister] stated that [Robinson] and Josiah were grabbing on to each other and not physically fighting or punching each other. After the shooting, [Robinson] stated, “he should have got off me.”

Police interviewed a second sister who offered much the same account of the day. She said she was the one who took the toddler out of the room during the argument and heard the shooting but did not see what happened, according to the affidavit.

The defendant, for his part, insisted the shooting was accidental in a custodial interview after being Mirandized.

“[Robinson] stated he was trying to remove the gun from his sweatshirt pocket because he did not want to shoot himself,” the affidavit reads. “While he removed the gun it went off accidentally. [Robinson] stated that the firearm was in his sweatshirt pocket and was not holstered.”

Police also noted that Robinson – in 911 call audio and at the scene of the crime – repeatedly said the shooting was an “accident.”

In a follow-up interview, the toddler’s mother reiterated that Josiah and Robinson “were not engaged in a physical fight and it did not appear that Josiah was hurting [Robinson] in any way,” according to the affidavit. She further said, “There was no reason for [Robinson] to pull his gun out.”

The defendant is being detained in the Palm Beach County Jail without bond. He is slated to appear in court on Feb. 26, 2026.

You May Also Like

Mother Accused of Shooting 11-Month-Old Son to Keep Father Away

Background: Grant County Detention Center in Silver City, New Mexico (Google Maps).…

Drunk Boater Hit Airport Runway Pier, Launching 3 Women

Insets, from left: Elizabeth “Lizzie” Dankert (Conte Funeral Home) and Lawrence Shieh…

Woman Pulled Over for Phone, Woke Screaming After Hit-and-Run

Background: A section of West Colonial Drive in Orange County, Florida (Google…

Police: Gainesville Man Arrested in Battery, Handgun Display

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Tarry Lee Stine, 57, was arrested Tuesday…

Babysitter Sentenced After Toddler Fatally Injured 11-Day-Old Newborn While Mother Was Hospitalized

Inset: Taylor Flint (Mason County Prosecuting Attorney). Background: The Point Pleasant, W.Va.,…

Police: Golfer Rammed 15-Year-Old With Cart, Attacked Teen Over Slow Play

Inset: Rhett Drummond (Pinellas County Sheriff’s Office). Background: Lansbrook Golf Club in…

High Springs Man Accused of Punching, Kicking Dog Arrested

Staff report HIGH SPRINGS, Fla. – Nicholas Matthew Alex, 46, was arrested…

Judge Lets Trump Mail-In Voting Takeover Proceed, Warns Chaos

President Donald Trump speaks during an event at the General Motors Proving…