Trump DOJ rips judge for motion to kill ICE obstruction case
Share this @internewscast.com

Background: Milwaukee County Judge Hannah Dugan in court (WTMJ/YouTube). Left inset: Donald Trump speaks at the annual Road to Majority conference in Washington, DC, in June 2024 (Allison Bailey/NurPhoto via AP). Right inset: Surveillance video shows Milwaukee County Judge Hannah Dugan speaking with ICE agents before Eduardo Flores-Ruiz’s detainment (WDJT/YouTube).

The Trump administration continues its legal battle against Milwaukee County Circuit Judge Hannah Dugan, urging a federal court on Monday to reject her motion to dismiss the ICE obstruction case against her. The administration claims that the case is based on a “factually unsupported and inaccurate storyline” and involves an attempt to “commandeer” a state courtroom, along with a “manufactured version of judicial immunity.”

Attorneys for the U.S. Department of Justice made the claims in a 25-page response to Dugan’s motion to dismiss that she filed on May 29.

Judge Dugan, 65, was indicted last month, accused of aiding an undocumented immigrant in evading federal officers shortly after a court appearance related to a domestic abuse case. She submitted a motion to dismiss the federal obstruction charges against her, arguing that she is entitled to broad judicial immunity, similar to the immunity a president has from prosecution for official actions while in office.

Love true crime? Sign up for our newsletter, The Law&Crime Docket, to get the latest real-life crime stories delivered right to your inbox.

“However, she cites no case in which a court has dismissed an indictment on either basis, and neither ground has merit,” the DOJ said in its response Monday.

“In her lengthy memorandum, Dugan concedes that ‘judges, like legislators and executive officials, are not above the law,’” the DOJ added. “Nonetheless, she claims that judges are entitled to absolute immunity from criminal prosecution except for ‘three categories of crimes,’ none of which — according to Dugan — applies here.”

More than 130 former state and federal judges have called for a dismissal of Dugan’s charges, joining forces in an amicus brief filed on May 30. The bipartisan collective — members of the group Democracy Defenders Fund — blasted Dugan’s arrest and prosecution as “an extraordinary and direct assault on the independence of the entire judicial system,” echoing statements made by Dugan in her motion. “This case directly threatens the ability of all judges to do their jobs without fear of retaliatory prosecution,” the brief charged.

In its response Monday, the DOJ said dismissing the charges because Dugan is “immune” would be what’s truly unprecedented.

“Dugan asks this Court for an unprecedented dismissal on grounds of judicial immunity, ignoring well-established law that has long permitted judges to be prosecuted for crimes they commit,” the DOJ said. “Such a ruling would give state court judges carte blanche to interfere with valid law enforcement actions by federal agents in public hallways of a courthouse, and perhaps even beyond. Dugan’s desired ruling would, in essence, say that judges are ‘above the law,’ and uniquely entitled to interfere with federal law enforcement.”

More from Law&Crime: ‘She knew nothing about it’: Judge accused of letting migrant out back door to avoid feds said she expected ICE to ‘do its job’

The DOJ went on to rip Dugan’s arguments as “inaptly” relying on civil law and “the notion that judicial immunity applies absent express Congressional abrogation.” The lawyers claim she does not point to any direct authority for her “theories” — nor could she, according to the Trump administration.

“The Supreme Court has made clear that judges are not immune from criminal liability,” the DOJ said, citing a 1974 ruling in O’Shea v. Littleton, which acknowledged that judges and magistrates can be held accountable in criminal proceedings or through civil rights lawsuits, when legally warranted.

“In the end, Dugan asks for this Court to develop a novel doctrine of judicial immunity from criminal prosecution, and to apply it to the facts alleged in the indictment, all without reasonable basis — directly or indirectly — in the Constitution, statutes, or case law,” the DOJ said.

Taking aim at her “commandeer” a state courtroom claims, the Justice Department said trial evidence, including video footage and audio recordings, will show that Dugan’s allegations are false. The agency described its arrest of Flores-Ruiz as being “planned” and orderly, rather than the takeover that Dugan says happened.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Man Sentenced in Quadruple Murder Case Stemming from Wife’s Complaints About Neighbor Harassment

Inset left: Jason Jones (Nebraska Attorney General”s Office). Inset right: Carrie Jones…

Prank Turns Tragic: Woman’s Fake Cheating Scare Leads to Boyfriend’s Violent Reaction

Inset: Shyhied Ivey (Mecklenburg County Sheriff”s Office). Background: A section of the…

Unraveling the Mystery: Police Investigate Hired Crime Crew Behind Infamous ‘Kill Car

Detectives are currently exploring the possibility that a crew was hired for…

Gunfire Targets Two Residences in Western Sydney

An investigation is under way after two homes in Sydney’s west were…

Probationary Offender Apprehended Near UF Campus on Several Warrants

Staff Report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Caleb James Martin, a 20-year-old with an…

Alachua Woman Charged with Embezzling Nursing Home Funds Meant for Mother’s Care

Staff Report ALACHUA, Fla. – Authorities have taken Lisa Jo Ann McKee,…

Tragic Shooting: Former Peace Corps Volunteer and Father of Two Fatally Struck by 45 Bullets After Dinner Outing

Inset: Jeremy Black (Legacy.com). Background: The 1400 block of R Street Northwest…

Bystander Intervenes in Alley Assault, Sustains Gunshot Injuries

Inset: Logan Dakota Stephens (Bonneville County Prosecuting Attorney”s Office). Background: The Melaleuca…

Police Report: Son Charged After 88-Year-Old Mother’s Body Found Decomposing in Basement Following Her Shopping Trip

Inset from left to right: Kevan Works and Daniest Graves (Chicago Police…

Man Arrested After Disturbing Crime: Roommate Shot and Hidden in Bedroom for Days

Inset: James Grossnickle (Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department). Background: The residence where Grossnickle…

Tragic Discovery: 9-Year-Old Found in Canal After Hit-and-Run Incident Involving Mother’s Car

Insets, clockwise from top: Timothy Chavez (Fresno police), Martha Hernandez (GoFundMe), Adrian…

Retired Police Officer Fatally Shot While Protecting News Crew on Day Off

Insets, clockwise from top: Kevin Nishita, Laron Gilbert, Hershel Hale and Shadihia…