Wife pleads guilty to conspiring to murder husband
Share this @internewscast.com

Left: Kathryn Restelli. Right: Kathryn Restelli and her husband Matthew Restelli (Law&Crime).

A woman from Utah has admitted to being involved in a plot with her family members to kill her estranged husband at their residence, attempting to present the act as self-defense, according to court documents.

Kathryn Restelli, 37, confessed to crimes including second-degree murder, conspiracy to commit murder, and first-degree felony discharge of a firearm in relation to the July 2024 death of Matthew Restelli, as outlined in the agreement. Initially, she faced a first-degree murder charge.

Weeks before the shooting on July 12, 2024, Kathryn Restelli left her husband unexpectedly in California, relocating with their children to American Fork, approximately 30 miles south of Salt Lake City, to live with her mother, Tracy Grist. During this period, she reportedly plotted with her mother and brother, Kevin Ellis, to orchestrate her husband’s murder.

As part of the alleged plot, Kathryn Restelli created a “ruse of possible reconciliation” with her husband to “lure” him to come to her home in Utah, with the intention that they would go back together to California. But, according to cops, she had no intention of doing so.

Grist allegedly told her daughter that she owned a firearm and that either she or Ellis would shoot Matthew Restelli. They also allegedly wanted to arrange it so the victim was driving his truck from California to Utah, which had an Apple AirTag hidden in the vehicle, allowing them to track him.

Restelli’s mother allegedly made some changes to the home in anticipation of her son-in-law’s arrival, prosecutors said.

“First, she removed the fabric screen door to allow easy access for Matthew. Second, she covered the couch in the living room with a blanket to avoid blood stains on the couch, according to Restelli’s admission of facts. “And third she moved all the kids’ toys from their normal location in the front room to a home office.”

Kathryn Restelli spoke with her husband several times as he made the drive, keeping him calm, prosecutors said. Just before his arrival, his wife told him to just come through the unlocked front door so he could help her gather her things. But this was part of the alleged plan to allow Grist or Ellis to say he walked into the home unannounced and uninvited, according to police.

The wife went upstairs while her mother and brother allegedly waited for the husband to come inside. When he did, Ellis fired several shots at him, prosecutors said. They then allegedly planted a knife on him.

But they made one crucial mistake.

“Matthew Restelli is left-handed, and he’s holding [the knife] in his right hand. Along with that, during the autopsy, a bullet wound was found in his right wrist … the same hand he’s holding the knife with,” American Fork police Officer Joseph Nordin testified, according to local ABC affiliate KTVX.

Restelli’s internet searches also revealed some interesting results, the station reported. Restelli was reportedly researching other \ homicide cases and “what attracts mountain lions to humans” in the days leading up to her husband’s. At the same time, her mother was allegedly doing her own online investigation about recent shootings and the state’s gun laws.

KTVX reported that Restelli cried as she entered her plea. She’s slated to be sentenced on Sept. 9.

Ellis and Grist are each charged with first-degree murder, criminal conspiracy, obstruction of justice, and two counts of domestic violence in the presence of a child. Ellis is also charged with the use of a firearm as a restricted person and possession or use of a controlled substance.

Both are scheduled to go on trial in January.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Lawsuit Claims Trump’s Expulsion of Migrant Children From Head Start Is ‘Illegal’

President Donald Trump, on the left, addresses the audience as Robert F.…

Court Overturns Rule Removing Medical Debt from Credit Reports

President Donald Trump delivers remarks during a luncheon with African leaders held…

Man Fatally Attacks Neighbor Over Driveway Dispute

Background: Robert Salone during his sentencing on Tuesday, July 15, 2025, in…

Sheriff: Man Fatally Harmed Former Partner’s Dog ‘as Revenge’ After Breakup

Inset: Marco Antonio-Manuel De La Cruz (Harnett County Sheriff’s Office). Background: The…

Georgia Father Proposes $2,000 to His Son’s Babysitter for Intimate Encounter

A Georgia man was arrested in Florida this week after he offered…

Man ‘regretted’ killing wife and then killed ex: Police report

Inset: Timothy Taylor (NYPD/CrimeStoppers). Background: Taylor being arrested by police and U.S.…

Immigrants Launch Lawsuit Against Trump Administration for Arrests at Courthouses

Background: A man feels unwell when U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE)…

Florida Woman Threatens to Be the ‘Next Shooter’ Targeting Trump: Police Report

Left: Miranda Perez (Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office). Right: President Donald Trump…

Jury Informed That Similar Allegations of MP’s Alleged Sexual Abuse Are No ‘Coincidence’

Two men who claim they were assaulted by a state MP should…

Board Deems Doctor a ‘Public Threat’ Following Death of Two Infants

Dr. Yolanda Lagunas (Lagunas” website). A Texas physician with almost 40 years…

Father of Teen Faces Additional Charges After Newborn Discovered at Walmart

Inset: Image of Jerry Lee Martinez (Kleberg County Jail). Background: The Walmart…

Mother Shoots Child’s Father in Front of Their Son, Police Report

Inset: Keosha Vester (Shelby County Jail). Background: Authorities at the scene where…