Judge strikes down Florida Medicaid policy excluding gender-affirming care
Share this @internewscast.com

A Florida rule excluding gender-affirming health care from Medicaid coverage is unlawful and unconstitutional, a federal judge ruled Wednesday, adding that the policy, which was enacted last year under the administration of Republican Gov. and presidential candidate Ron DeSantis, is based on politics rather than medicine.

Florida’s Agency for Health Care Administration (AHCA), which controls most of the state’s Medicaid program, in August adopted a rule barring transgender residents from using Medicaid to help cover the cost of puberty blockers, hormone replacement therapy, surgeries or “any other procedures that alter primary or secondary sexual characteristics” when those procedures are used to treat gender dysphoria.

The rule was immediately criticized by LGBTQ civil rights groups and health care professionals, who characterized it as “medically and scientifically unsound” and politically motivated. Two transgender adults and a minor then sued AHCA officials in federal court, claiming in a September lawsuit filed in the Northern District of Florida that the rule discriminates based on sex and transgender status.

In a 54-page decision on Wednesday, U.S. District Judge Robert Hinkle, who partially blocked the enforcement of another Florida law restricting access to gender-affirming health care earlier this month, sided with the plaintiffs, finding the AHCA rule and a separate statute prohibiting the use of state funds for “sex reassignment prescriptions or procedures” violate federal law and the U.S. Constitution.

“Florida has adopted a rule and statute that prohibit Medicaid payment for these treatments even when medically appropriate,” Hinkle wrote Wednesday. “The rule and statute violate the federal Medicaid statute, the Equal Protection Clause, and the Affordable Care Act’s prohibition of sex discrimination.”

“These plaintiffs are Medicaid beneficiaries who are entitled to payment, as a matter of medical necessity, for puberty blockers or cross-sex hormones as appropriately determined by their multidisciplinary teams of providers,” Hinkle added.

Hinkle in Wednesday’s ruling also suggested Florida’s Medicaid rule was adopted in pursuit of a political goal.

“For many years, Florida’s Medicaid system paid for medically necessary treatments for gender dysphoria. Recently, for political reasons, Florida adopted a rule and then a statute prohibiting payment for some of the treatments,” Hinkle wrote Wednesday.

Hinkle’s ruling also characterizes a June AHCA report asserting gender-affirming medical care does not meet the requirements for Medicaid because it is experimental as “flawed” and “from the outset, a biased effort to justify a predetermined outcome, not a fair analysis of the evidence.”

An AHCA employee in a June email to Christopher Cogle, the chief medical officer of Florida Medicaid, suggested state health officials did not follow customary procedures for developing generally accepted professional medical standards (GAPMS) in creating the report.

The administration of gender-affirming health care for transgender youths and adults is supported as medically necessary and often life-saving by every major medical organization, most of which have also explicitly rejected insurance exclusions for transition-related care.

In a statement on Wednesday, August Dekker, a 29-year-old transgender man and one of the plaintiffs in the case challenging Florida’s Medicaid exclusion, said he is “extremely relieved and pleased” with Hinkle’s decision.

“Florida’s policy effectively denied me the treatment my doctors recommended, because as a low-income Floridian with disabilities, I rely on Medicaid to afford my health care,” Dekker said. “I am also happy for other transgender Floridians that get care through Medicaid, as now access to that lifesaving, critical care can continue.”

Wednesday’s ruling comes on the heels of another legal victory for transgender rights in Arkansas, where a federal judge on Tuesday struck down the nation’s first law banning youth access to gender-affirming health care.

Copyright 2023 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

5 Natural Ways to Enhance Hair Growth and Volume

Achieving long, thick, and healthy hair is a common goal for many,…

5 Unexpected Ways Cocoa Can Enhance Your Life

Cocoa is more than just a delicious treat—it’s a powerhouse of nutrients…

Doctors Describe Symptoms of an Infectious Skin Condition That May Take Up to Eight Weeks to Manifest

Scabies is a common, yet often misunderstood, skin condition. It triggers itching…

Hollywood Star Alleges Officials Tried to Discredit Her Over Vaccine-Autism Claims About Son

Jenny McCarthy has claimed a government agency tried to smear her after…

Tucker Carlson Shocked by Doctor’s Explosive Claim on Covid Vaccines

TV personality Tucker Carlson was left stunned during an episode of his…

The Tradition of Floor Seating During Meals in Japan

In Japan, the tradition of sitting on the floor to eat is…

Healthcare Services Disrupted for Millions of Afghans Following USAID Clinic Closures

More than 200 health facilities run by the World Health Organization in…

I Lost My Hair at 20 and Battled Depression, But Now I’ve Transformed Without a Hair Transplant—Discover the Groundbreaking Solution Helping Men Everywhere

When Johnny Thain realised he was going bald at just 20 he…

7 Easy Lifestyle Changes to Get Your Body Ready for Summer

Embracing confidence in your own body is vital for feeling great throughout…

Doctors Advocate for Government Intervention in Poverty Amid Increase in Victorian-Age Illnesses

Doctors have reported a rise in the number of patients with Victorian…

Discover the Secret to Longevity: This Expert Believes this Simple Activity is Even More Beneficial than Hitting the Gym

An expert in longevity and reaching the age of 100 through diet…

Officials Announce Layoffs to Reduce FDA Food and Drug Inspections

Top officials at the Food and Drug Administration are preparing to scale…