'Right to disconnect' laws could be tested in Queensland case
Share this @internewscast.com
The case of a Queensland teacher suing her former employer for alleged wrongful dismissal has been suggested to act as an unofficial test of the federal government’s “right to disconnect” laws—though one expert has cautioned that this might not be accurate.

The teacher has reportedly claimed she was dismissed after she refused to respond to allegations of inappropriate conduct during school holidays.

The Australian Financial Review reported that the school insisted she respond, which she declined, leading the school to determine that the behavior claims were substantiated.

Right to disconnect laws were passed in Australia last year. (Getty)

The teacher has also reportedly claimed she was targeted by the school because she had raised issues around child safety.

In her claim in part, the teacher reportedly accused the school of breaching her right to disconnect.

The legislation, enacted by the Albanese government last year, provides employees the right to refuse to engage with contact or attempted contact from employers or a third party, except where it is deemed unreasonable to do so, such as in a work-related emergency.

Workers also can’t be disciplined or fired for refusing contact outside of work hours.

The five qualifications in hot demand for Australia’s future jobs

Employers can be fined up to $18,000 for violating the regulations.

RMIT University School of Law Professor Shelley Marshall said the Queensland case could raise the profile of the law, but was unlikely to provide a definitive interpretation of its legal limits.

“While the right to disconnect is a high-profile and novel element of this case, it’s important to recognise that it’s only one aspect of the teacher’s broader legal claim.,” she said.

“However, applying the law in practice is complex. In industries with genuine operational needs outside regular hours, such as education or emergency services, the line between necessary communication and unlawful overreach is far from clear.

“The proceedings appear to involve multiple alleged breaches, including unfair dismissal and general protections under the Fair Work Act.”

She said, the outcome could hinge less on the right to disconnect itself and more on whether the dismissal was unlawful for other reasons, “such as procedural unfairness or retaliation for exercising a workplace right”.

What are the right to disconnect laws in Australia?

Employees have the right to refuse to monitor, read or respond to contact or attempted contact from employers or a third party, unless that refusal is unreasonable, like in the case of a work-related emergency.

Employees also can’t be disciplined or let go for refusing contact outside of work hours.

If an employee feels these rights have been violated they should raise it first with their employer, then with the Fair Work Commission if internal mediation doesn’t work. Employers found to be in violation of the new laws can be fined up to $18,000.

What are the exceptions to the right to disconnect?

While employees can refuse contact from employers where reasonable, what counts as reasonable is up to interpretation.

Several factors must be taken into consideration when deciding what is reasonable, including but not limited to:

  • The reason for the contact
  • How the contact is made and how disruptive it is to the employee
  • If the employee is compensated for working outside normal work hours
  • The employee’s role and level of responsibility
  • The employee’s personal circumstances, including family and caring responsibilities

Aussies with a reasonable additional hours clause already in their employment contract may not be able to invoke the new protections.

These clauses are common in white collar jobs and allow employers to direct their employees to work overtime without additional pay, and could be used to “override” right to disconnect rules.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Police say 'FIFO criminal' syndicate is behind spiritual blessing scams

Police Reveal ‘Fly-In, Fly-Out’ Crime Syndicate Behind Spiritual Blessing Scams

A woman has been charged over an alleged spiritual blessings scam that…
Port Adelaide defender Brandon Zerk-Thatcher has had to flee his home in Glenelg East as a fire threatened to set the property aflame.

Port Adelaide Player Escapes Early Morning Fire Emergency

Port Adelaide defender Brandon Zerk-Thatcher has had to flee his home in…

Hidden “Ghost Stores” Deceive Australian Shoppers

A warning has been issued to Australians to remain vigilant about “ghost…
New Zealand sports reporter Tiffany Salmond has opened up on why she has not been seen on Fox Sports' NRL coverage this season

TV sports reporter alleges she’s been shunned by networks plotting against her.

New Zealand sports reporter Tiffany Salmond has claimed she has been ‘sidelined’…
The pilot tried to circle back and attempt to land the plane but was unsuccessful, he said at a news conference Wednesday evening.

Skydiving Aircraft Carrying 15 Passengers Veers Off Runway at U.S. Airport

A skydiving plane carrying 15 individuals veered off the runway at a…

How Can Antarctica Be Shielded from the Impact of Increasing Tourism?

The surge in tourists visiting Antarctica has been remarkable. From less than…

Victoria Unveils Major Changes Following Childcare Abuse Allegations

This article contains references to child abuse. Victoria’s Premier Jacinta Allan has…

Severe Rain and Wind on NSW East Coast Prompt Evacuations and Emergency Alerts

Hundreds of homes are flooded or have been evacuated, and thousands of…
Shirley-Anne Gardiner (centre) with other Momentum Mental Health staff members.

Concerns Arise for At-Risk Australians as Mental Health Provider Faces Uncertainty Due to New Hub Initiative

More than 800 vulnerable Australians are “in limbo” as the mental health…
ghost stores

ACCC Alerts About Online ‘Ghost Stores’ Deceiving Shoppers

Australians have been warned about shopping at alleged “ghost stores”, websites which…
Australian aircraft and submarines.

Experts Warn: Simple Drone Attacks Could Threaten ADF Ships, Planes, and Submarines

Most of the Australian military’s most expensive planes, ships and submarines are…
A NASA diagram shows the trajectory of 3I/ATLAS as it passes through the solar system.

Astronomers Observe an Interstellar Object Passing Through Our Solar System

A newly identified object racing through our solar system is causing much…