Matt Hancock defends moving hospital patients to care homes in Covid crisis
Share this @internewscast.com

Discharging untested patients from hospitals to care homes during the Covid crisis was the “least worst decision”, the former health secretary Matt Hancock has told a public inquiry.

In his testimony to the UK Covid-19 inquiry on Wednesday, Hancock defended the decision – which was later ruled illegal in a high court judgment – to move hospital patients into care homes during the early weeks of the pandemic to free up space.

“Nobody has yet provided me with an alternative that was available at the time that would have saved more lives,” he said. “I still can’t see a decision that would have been less bad. None of the options were good. It was the least worst decision that could have been taken at the time. While I wish there had been a better option, I still can’t find one.

“The likelihood of things being worse if people had stayed in hospital was very high.”

Nicola Brook, a solicitor representing more than 7,000 people from Covid-19 Bereaved Families for Justice UK, said Hancock’s words were “an insult to the memory of each and every person who died”.

“He knew at the time that many care homes did not have the ability to isolate the people who would be discharged from hospital and that Covid was airborne,” she said. “It’s frankly ridiculous and insulting that he says they tried to throw a protective ring around care homes when his department’s policies caused Covid to spread like wildfire amongst society’s most vulnerable loved ones.”

Hancock said the discharge policy was “formally a government decision” but that it was “driven” by the then NHS chief executive, Simon Stevens. He also said that while he had not taken the decision himself, he took responsibility for it.

Brook said: “Mr Hancock claims the decision to discharge people into care homes was driven by Simon Stevens, the chief executive of the NHS, yet the inquiry is not calling him. We call for this decision to be urgently reviewed.”

Hancock was giving evidence as part of the sixth module of the inquiry, focusing specifically on the care sector.

Earlier this week, it was heard that a senior civil servant said there had been a “generational slaughter within care homes” in written evidence to the inquiry.

Almost 46,000 care home residents died with Covid in England and Wales between March 2020 and January 2022, many of them in the early weeks of the pandemic.

The decision to rapidly discharge hospital patients to care homes in order to free up beds, when testing and isolation facilities were not yet widely available, has been strongly criticised for causing rapid spread of the disease in care homes.

In 2022, the high court said the policy not to isolate discharged hospital patients in the first weeks of the pandemic without testing was “irrational”.

On Tuesday, a care home owner and manager giving evidence said she had refused to allow untested hospital patients into her nursing home, and was told she would be reported to the care inspectorate for bed blocking.

Hancock said that isolation of discharged patients had not been clinically recommended at the time, but “in hindsight” it should have been.

When questioned about whether there had been enough staff to care for the discharged patients, amid evidence of a widespread shortage of carers, Hancock said: “We knew that people would do what they needed to do.”

He has also been heavily criticised for his claims that a “protective ring” had been placed around care homes, previously admitting to the inquiry that it was not an “unbroken circle”.

The care sector module of the inquiry is expected to run until the end of July.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

A 49-Year-Old Mom Finally Discovers the Cause of Her Severe Gum Pain After Visiting the Dentist

A mum was taken aback when it turned out her dental pain…

A Warning Sign in Your Fingernails Could Indicate a Serious Heart Condition if Left Untreated

Around 1,500 people are diagnosed with endocarditis each year. This uncommon condition…

Leading Doctor Unveils Unexpected Lifestyle Factor Significantly Boosting Immunity—It’s Not Diet or Hydration

Socialising can boost your immune system and increase life expectancy, according to…

My Mother Passed Away Following an 11-Hour Ambulance Delay – Starmer’s NHS Proposal Falls Short

A son whose mum endured an 11 hour wait for an ambulance…

Doctors Misdiagnosed My Symptoms as a Sinus Infection, Leading to a Deadly Brain Tumor Discovery a Year Later

Long before becoming a patient, Ilene Sue Ruhoy was a prominent neurologist…

Understanding the Dangers of Antidepressants During Pregnancy: Why Leading Physicians Advise Expecting Mothers to Discontinue Use

Leading medical experts have called for women to stop taking antidepressants during…

I tested the enigmatic blue remedy praised by RFK Jr for jet lag—here’s how my body reacted

There’s no pill or instant fix for jet lag. But with more…

Urgent Alert: Sudden Hearing Loss Might Lead to Deafness – Misdiagnosed by Doctors as Earwax in 15,000 Brits Annually

When 47-year-old Caroline Norman woke up to the room spinning, a continuous…

Born Without Limbs and Adopted by Mormons: My Dream to Dance Despite Their Hopes for Me as a Motivational Speaker

As starts in life go, Briel Adams-Wheatley didn’t have the best; born…

Clint Eastwood’s Free Tips for Staying Healthy and Vibrant at 95

Hollywood legend Clint Eastwood has reached the remarkable age of 95, but you’d…

Exploring the ‘Baby Deserts’ of Britain: Uncovering the Reality of Declining Birth Rates and the Risks of ‘Underpopulation’ – Discover the Situation in Your Region

Plunging fertility rates mean nine in ten neighbourhoods face the terrifying threat…