5 Fast-Food Add-Ons That Are Never Worth Your Money, According to Experts

Grabbing a quick meal on the go is always the easiest at a fast food restaurant. Whether you run in and get a sandwich or tacos from the cashier, order via the app, or hit the drive-thru for your fix, it’s one of America’s favorite ways to dine out. It’s also affordable unless you let those expensive little add-ons add up without noticing.

Over the years, fast-food chains have mastered the upsell. Would you like a large instead? Do you want to add bacon or get a bigger drink? How about an extra pump of syrup? 

We spoke with restaurant experts, chefs, and dietitians to see what the impact of adding on to your fast food order has on your wallet and your waistline, and what they think you should skip when placing your order. 

RELATED: 8 Fast-Food Chains That Never Freeze Their Burgers

Courtesy of McDonald’s

Almost every expert we spoke with cautioned against upgrading your meal from a small or medium to a large option, due to the cost, calories, sodium, and sugar.

“Meal deals with fries and a large drink included,” says Cheryl Orlansky RDN, LD, CDCES, “It may come out to be a better deal cost wise, however, they are marketing more food; more calories than you really need to eat at one meal.” 

“Supersizing drinks when that’s not your true desire literally just adds a surplus of additional sugar into your meal,” Shena Jaramillo MS, RD, told us. “Adding on the fries and soda to the meal when it wasn’t our intent can cause us to overeat and feel sluggish.” It will also boost the bill.

“Another fast food add-on that isn’t worth the money or extra calories is the ‘super-sized’ option,” says Raymond Neil, chef and contributor at TrishDevineKitchen.com. “The supersized option is often appealing because it seems like a great deal, but it’s actually a bad idea. Not only does it add extra calories, but it also often comes with a large amount of sodium, sugar, and fat. It can also be more expensive than buying two regular-sized items.”

starbucks syrup

Starbucks can be a lifesaver when energy’s lagging, but it’s easy to add dollars and calories to your coffee order, says Dan Gallagher, RD, Aegle Nutrition. “Many Starbucks drinks automatically come with a ton of sugar and artificial sweeteners, so those extra syrup pumps aren’t worth it. Your wallet—and your body—doesn’t need all that extra stuff! Additional pumps are $.80, which adds up when you are consistently ordering them time and time again.” 

It also adds up for Starbucks who is making billions on these little extras.

In-N-Out Animal Style Double-Double Cheeseburger

While your taste buds might like the cheese, the calories aren’t worth it, says Megan Wong, RD at Algae Cal. “If you ‘upgrade’ from a hamburger to a cheeseburger at In-N-Out, the amount of sodium (salt) jumps from an already high 650 milligrams to a shocking 1000 milligrams! This is a lot, given that most people should have no more than 1500 to 2300 milligrams of sodium throughout their entire day.” 

shake shack bacon loaded fries
Courtesy of Shake Shack

If you’re trying to keep your check average, and calories and sodium down, avoid bacon add-ons, says Wong. “At Shake Shack, adding two slices of bacon means 70 extra calories, 45 of which come from fat, and 290 mg of additional sodium,” she explained. 

Extra bacon at Shake Shake also adds $2 and fast-food bacon is never as crispy as it should be.

Epic Stuffed Crust Papa John's
Courtesy of Papa John’s

Adding stuffing to your crust means adding calories, cost, and not that much flavor, says Raymond Neil, chef and contributor at TrishDevineKitchen.com. “When it comes to pizza, stuffed crusts are one of the least healthy options,” he says. “These crusts are usually filled with cheese and other processed ingredients, making them a calorie bomb. In addition to the extra calories, these crusts can also be expensive. You’re better off getting a regular crust and adding extra toppings if you want to make your pizza more flavorful.”


Tanya Edwards

Tanya Edwards is a seasoned food and health journalist, who has held roles at Yahoo Health as Managing Editor and at Food Network as Programming Director. Read more about Tanya

You May Also Like

Drinking Habits To Help You Shrink Abdominal Fat, Say Dietitians

When it comes to the fat around your abdominal area, not all…

Lisa Marie was ‘back on opioids’ before awards season, says insider

Lisa Marie Presley was desperately trying to lose weight for the Elvis…

My heart rate is 100 beats a minute when I wake up. Would an ablation help? DR MARTIN SCURR answers

My heartbeat is rapid — very seldom below 100 beats per minute,…

Boy, 8, ‘was sent home from hospital twice’ before dying of Strep A

Muhammad Ibrahim Ali The four-year-old boy attended Oakridge School and Nursery in…

Stereotyping vets as ‘heroes’ may nudge them into lower-paying jobs associated with selflessness

The long-standing belief that military veterans should be designated ‘heroes’ may pigeonhole…

How To Prevent Avocados From Going Bad Too Quickly, According to Chefs

Avocados have proven themselves to be a powerful, healthy food that everyone…

Influencer shares recipe for ‘low calorie fluff bowl’

Dessert that won’t ruin your diet! Influencer shares recipe for viral 200-calorie…

Marie Osmond Reveals She Had Body Dysmorphia—Here are the Signs

Marie Osmond is opening up about her experiences with body shaming and…

8 Healthy Foods That Can Also Be Toxic—or Even Fatal

There’s no denying that if you want to live a long and…

Here are 3 things the end of the COVID public health emergency could undo

The Biden administration announced on Monday that it plans to end on…

This Expert-Approved Morning Routine Can Help You Lose Weight Faster

Did you know that the habits you establish in the morning can…

Costco Shoppers Are Slamming the Grocer's "Useless" App—Here's Why

E-commerce has never been Costco’s strong suit. The members-only club actively encourages…