Accusations of plagiarism, AI use and author bullying: 'BookTok' rocked by recent scandals
Share this @internewscast.com

The book community on TikTok is currently embroiled in a scandal over plagiarism accusations, creating turmoil in what was once viewed as a refuge from internet toxicity.

The romance novel “Beverly,” authored by Laura J. Robert, had gained traction on the platform known for discussions and recommendations of the latest book titles among readers and authors.

However, some creators have removed their reviews after allegations surfaced claiming Robert’s book closely resembles “Obsessed” by indie author R.J. Lewis, published in 2016. Both stories revolve around a leading female protagonist and her romantic involvement with a childhood friend.

Some people posted excerpts of Lewis’ words juxtaposed with Robert’s, identifying what they described as similarities. Others accused Robert of using artificial intelligence to tweak and lengthen Lewis’ book to create her own version. A handful of people speculated the authors could be the same person — because Robert’s initials are Lewis’ initials backward — and that the controversy could all be a PR stunt.

NBC News was unable to reach Robert on Friday. Lewis declined to comment further.

On BookTok, some have cited the somewhat niche controversy as yet another example of the community’s shift away from lighthearted content around new releases.

“Does anyone miss just having a silly, goofy, fun time, having a bit of a laugh?” Lola Oluremi, a BookTok creator, said in a recent video discussing “Beverly” and “Obsessed.” “I feel like every time I log onto BookTok now, it’s something.”

The online space, which has been credited for inspiring a fresh wave of interest in literature, hasn’t been devoid of drama in the past. But this month, the “Beverly” accusations followed two other separate situations that had caused some division among BookTokers online.

Author Ali Hazelwood, who is behind popular novels such as “The Love Hypothesis,” left Instagram purportedly after she was “bullied” for a comment she made during a panel discussion at the Los Angeles Times Festival of Books in April.

Hazelwood weighed in on who she thought Katniss Everdeen, the protagonist of Suzanne Collins’ “Hunger Games” books, should have ended up with romantically, saying it should have been her childhood friend Gale, rather than her fellow tribute, Peeta.

“He’s a terrible, mean, selfish person,” Hazelwood said of the character Peeta, a baker’s son from District 12 who was reaped alongside Katniss in the books. The clip of Hazelwood’s remarks was widely circulated and blasted online by people who accused her of having a bad take.

Hazelwood didn’t immediately respond to a request for comment. Since she went dark online, several BookTokers have come to her defense, reflecting on how the community has seemingly become more prone to getting lost in meaningless discourse.

“The way y’all have lost the plot over a fictional bread boy has left me genuinely questioning the mental health of the book community,” Shelley Fleuridor, the YouTuber behind the channel “Book Chats with Shelley,” said in a recent video delving into the Hazelwood backlash. “We need to talk about what’s happening to this community and why some of you genuinely need to be placed in a reading timeout immediately, maybe permanently.”

Also this past month, Victoria Aveyard, the author of the “Red Queen” books, sparked a wave of backlash and speculation on BookTok after she post a video alluding to another author’s using generative AI in a novel without naming the purported writer. She said she didn’t name the person because she didn’t want to get sued.

“Using GenAI to come up with characters, plots and story ideas isn’t writing. It’s theft,” Aveyard said. “Using GenAI doesn’t make you a writer. It makes you a thief.” She said generative AI has been trained on copyrighted material that “has been stolen from artists without license or compensation.”

Some subsequent posts from users accuse Aveyard of being a “mean girl” obsessed with “drama.” In other videos, some try to guess which author she was referring to. Meanwhile, a handful of authors have also been posting videos of their writing and editing processes to prove their work isn’t made with AI.

With “Beverly,” it remains unclear whether there will be consequences for Robert beyond online fallout.

Robert’s social media pages and her author website were no longer online Friday. “Beverly” has also been removed from Amazon. The title remains on GoodReads, where several people have posted comments about the plagiarism accusations and given the book a one-star review.

A spokesperson for Amazon, which owns GoodReads, didn’t immediately respond to a request for comment.

Lewis posted about the plagiarism allegations on Instagram this week, calling the situation an indie author’s “worst nightmare.”

“I’m an author who does not have a big online presence and thank all who have reached out to bring this to my attention as I don’t have much visibility on the social media space,” she wrote.

She said she has contacted Amazon to raise a copyright infringement case and hopes “that people in the booktok space realize this author is stealing content and profiting from it.”

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Families Share New Video Showing Teens’ Confrontation with BCSO Deputy

BEAUFORT COUNTY, S.C. (WSAV) — Families of the involved teenagers have shared…

Prepared Pasta Meals Linked to Listeria Outbreak Cause 4 Fatalities

(NewsNation) — Four individuals have passed away and 19 others have been…

Most National Parks to Stay Open Amid Shutdown, But Liberty Bell Venue Shuts

NEW YORK – Wednesday morning saw crowds boarding boats to visit the…

Five Additional Homes Fall into the Ocean on North Carolina’s Outer Banks

In Buxton, North Carolina, two offshore hurricanes generated significant swells that led…

Daniel Day-Lewis Returns from Retirement, Rekindles His Passion for Acting Thanks to His Son

NEW YORK – It’s been eight years since Daniel Day-Lewis retired from…

Taliban refutes claims of internet shutdown preventing Afghans from contacting family members

The Taliban has refuted claims of an enforced internet shutdown across Afghanistan,…

Home Goods Opens in Statesboro Amid Ongoing Growth

STATESBORO, Ga. () — Statesboro and Bulloch County continue to see growth,…

Tampa Bay Food Bank Anticipates Increased Demand Due to Potential Government Shutdown

In TAMPA, Fla. (WFLA), Feeding Tampa Bay, a leading nonprofit organization serving…

Jannik Sinner Clinches China Open Title with Straight Sets Victory Against American Tien Ahead of Shanghai Masters

BEIJING – Jannik Sinner claimed victory at the China Open by defeating…

Florida Increases Penalties for Evading Police Pursuit

TALLAHASSEE, Fla. (WFLA) — Nearly 30 new laws came into effect on…

Champaign Co. Reveals Trick-or-Treat Hours: All Treats, No Tricks!

CHAMPAIGN COUNTY, Ill. (WCIA) — No, this isn’t a trick! Champaign, Urbana,…

Cuban Foreign Minister Warns Rubio’s ‘Personal’ Agenda Threatens Trump’s Peace Efforts in Latin America

NEW YORK – Recent U.S. actions in the Caribbean stem from Secretary…