CBO says tax piece of GOP megabill could violate Senate Byrd Rule
Share this @internewscast.com


The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) projects that the tax piece of President Trump’s “big, beautiful bill,” a core component of his agenda, would add to deficits after 2034, the end of the 10-year budget window, and could therefore violate the Senate’s Byrd Rule.  

Responding in a letter to Sen. Jeff Merkley (D-Ore.), the ranking member of the Senate Budget Committee, CBO Director Phillip Swagel said the congressional scoring agency “estimates that title VII,” the Finance Committee’s portion of the bill, “increases the deficits in years after 2034.”

Democrats asked the CBO to score the budgetary impact of making the 2017 expiring Trump tax cuts permanent by using a current-law baseline.

Under current law, the Trump tax cuts are due to expire at the end of this year, therefore any extension of those tax provisions is counting as adding to the deficit beyond 2034.

Democrats will argue that this is a violation of the Senate’s Byrd Rule, which determines what legislation is eligible to pass the Senate with a simple-majority vote on the reconciliation fast track.

The Byrd Rule requires that legislation considered as a reconciliation package not increase the deficit for a fiscal year beyond the “budget window” covered by the measure.

The budget window for the One Big Beautiful Bill Act spans from 2025 to 2034.

Merkley’s staff said the Republican bill is out of compliance with the rules of reconciliation by exceeding the spending limits outlined in their budget resolution by trillions of dollars and adding to the deficit beyond the 10-year window.

Swagel, who was appointed to his post during Trump’s first term, told Merkley that the tax portion of the bill would increase the deficit by nearly $3.5 trillion from 2025 to 2034.

Merkley could attempt to raise 60-vote point of order against the bill on the floor in an effort to block the legislation.

But Senate Majority Leader John Thune (R-S.D.) and Senate Budget Committee Chair Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) feel confident that the tax portion of the bill complies with the Byrd Rule.

Thune says Graham has authority under Section 312 of the Congressional Budget Act “to determine baseline numbers for spending and revenue.”

Graham has judged the extension of the 2017 expiring Trump tax cuts as a continuation of “current policy” and therefore as not adding to the deficit.

Republicans say they have offset the cost of language to make expired corporate tax cuts permanent by finding more than $1.6 trillion in spending cuts, including an estimated $930 billion in cuts to Medicaid.

Graham received a letter from Swagel on Saturday estimating that the Finance portion of the “big, beautiful bill” complies with the reconciliation instructions for the 10-year budget window and does not add to the deficit after 2034.

Swagel informed Graham that when using the current-policy baseline favored by Republicans, the Finance Committee’s text would increase deficits by not more than $1.5 trillion over the 2025-2034 period.

“In addition, CBO projects that the legislation and each individual title would not increase on-budget deficits after 2034,” he wrote.

Republican staff on the Senate Budget Committee have pointed to a publication on the congressional budget process issued by then-Budget Committee Chair Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.), who caucuses with Democrats, stating that the Budget chair “makes the call on questions of numbers.”

That Democratic publication asserted that the Budget Committee chair has the job of advising the Senate’s presiding officer to decide what estimates of the CBO and Joint Committee on Taxation should be used to decide procedural questions on the floor.

The bill narrowly advanced in the Senate late Saturday night, teeing it up for an expected final vote on Monday.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Rays VP Departs After 15 Years with the Team

Related video: Ownership group acquires the Rays Carlos Rodriguez, the Vice President…

Weather Update from Storm Team 3: Mild Friday Followed by a Warmer, Rainy Weekend

In Savannah, Georgia, Thursday afternoon brought mild and breezy conditions, which are…

Overnight Fire Damages Springfield Home

SPRINGFIELD, Ill. (WCIA) — The Springfield Fire Department is investigating after a…

Early Polls Indicate Trump and GOP Receive More Blame Than Democrats for Shutdown

WASHINGTON — The U.S. government is shut down, and Americans are more…

FDA’s Approval of New Generic Abortion Pill Sparks Conservative Outcry

Video above: Legal challenges following the Dobbs Supreme Court decision This week,…

Candlelight Vigil Draws Hundreds to Highlight Domestic Violence Awareness

SAVANNAH, Ga. () — Savannah residents gathered Thursday at Forsyth Park to…

Oviedo Mall Celebrates Album Launch with ‘Taylor Swift Day’

OVIEDO, Fla. – “Swifties” are taking over Oviedo Mall as fans celebrate…

Michigan Attorney General Cautions Public About Potential Scams Amid Shutdown

Residents of Lansing, Mich. (WLNS) are being warned by Michigan Attorney General…

Two Additional Suspects Charged in 2024 Murder of 14-Year-Old in Plant City

Video above: Homicide investigation underway after 14-year-old with ‘upper body trauma’ dies…

AP Decision Insights: Anticipations for Tennessee’s Special Congressional Election

WASHINGTON – Over twelve candidates are vying for their parties’ nominations on…

Two People Injured in Crash on Southbound I-81 in Sullivan County

SULLIVAN COUNTY, Tenn. (WJHL) — Two people were injured in a crash…

Russell County Sheriff Investigates Fire as Potential Arson Case

RUSSELL COUNTY, Va. (WJHL) — Sheriff Bill Watson stated that the Russell…