Share this @internewscast.com
Allegations of rampant employee underpayment at Coles and Woolworths that affected almost 30,000 staff remain unresolved two years after a lengthy trial.
On Friday, the Federal Court handed down a judgment on four cases against the supermarket giants after a watchdog argued there was tacit approval of illegal conduct in many stores.
Woolworths and Coles have repaid $330 million and $7 million respectively to managers who were not properly paid entitlements due to them as salaried employees, justice Nye Perram said.
But the Fair Work Ombudsman and former grocery store employees behind two class actions say the market leaders should be forced to pay more.
The watchdog argued the relevant award set out a 38-hour work week, but there was tacit approval to allow people to work overtime regularly.
It says there were failures in the use of “informal” rosters, time off in lieu and record-keeping on overtime, penalties and allowances.

According to Woolworths, some employees were authorized to work up to 45 hours a week without being required to do overtime beyond that limit.

People walking in and out of a Woolworths supermarket.

Woolworths has already compensated $300 million to managers who were not appropriately paid their entitlements. Source: AAP / Con Chronis

Coles argued managers had autonomy over their hours, and the estimates of working hours and days were overestimated by the Fair Work Ombudsman.

Perram found both supermarket chains did not comply with their obligation to keep accurate employment records.
He noted Coles failed to operate an overtime system for managers and its clocking records were unreliable.
One of the lead litigants, who mostly managed the customer service desk, likely worked on days when she was not rostered, so roster sheets were not indicative of the hours worked, the judge said.
Her phone records could better demonstrate when she was at work, the judge found, while dismissing Coles’ arguments she had not missed unpaid meal breaks.

The woman whose wages were reduced for wearing Coles-branded clothing was entitled to receive a clothing and laundry allowance.

‘Unacceptably complex’

The judge used his 82,000-word judgment to criticise all sides, including the Fair Work Ombudsman, for making the case “unacceptably complex”.
The parties mainly wanted answers about how the general retail award applied, but got bogged down presenting myriad case studies to the court.
The ombudsman’s case against Woolworths involved 32 managers at five locations across Sydney, Melbourne and Brisbane from June 2015 to September 2019.

The case involving Coles concerned 42 managers, some working in several locations, from 2017 to 2020.

The exterior of a Coles supermarket.

Coles did not have an effective overtime system for managers and had unreliable clocking records, as stated by justice Nye Perram. Source: AAP / Con Chronis

“Whilst I would not wish to [be] definitive about how litigation of this kind might be handled in the future, I am confident that they should not be handled the way these four cases were,” Perram said. “This should not be done again.”

A case management hearing will be held in October to address the next steps and compensation for the 27,700 affected employees.

Coles and Woolworths respond

In a statement, Coles said that it has now paid $30 million in remediation to affected employees.
said it hoped Perram’s judgment would provide “much-needed clarification” on the industry award and Fair Work Act.
“We [have] introduced new processes and safeguards to ensure this won’t happen again,” a spokesperson said.
“We again apologise to our team members who were affected.”
Woolworths pointed to the remediation paid to affected employees and said further payments would need to be scrutinised carefully.
“We are focused on resolving these underpayment issues,” chief executive Amanda Bardwell said.
“We are committed to ensuring that our team members are paid correctly.”
Friday’s decision would also provide guidance to other employers and workers affected by the general retail award, particularly those on annualised salaries, the Fair Work Ombudsman said.
The watchdog is seeking both rectification of underpayment as well as penalties against Coles and Woolworths.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
'Nothing holding him back': Dezi Freeman's mate hopes fugitive surrenders

‘No Barriers Left’: Dezi Freeman’s Friend Hopes Fugitive Will Surrender

A friend of accused cop killer Dezi Freeman has called on the…
weatherzone cold weather expected for WA

Australia Braces for a Winter Chill While Others Anticipate Sunny Skies

A blast of winter weather is coming for parts of Australia, bringing…
Cubicles made a comeback in the TV series Severance.

The Rise and Fall of Office Cubicles: Is Their Comeback Imminent?

Imagine having your own space at work. For most Australians working in…
Acting Superintendent Hunter Valley Police District Justin Cornes at a press conference

Incredible: Police Commend Passersby for Heroic Response in Dog Attack

The quick actions of bystanders might have been pivotal in saving the…
Wealthy US family 'matriarch' convicted of ex-son-in-law's murder

Prominent US Family’s Matriarch Found Guilty in Ex-Son’s Murder Case

The head of a wealthy American family has been found guilty of…
Melania Trump back in public spotlight with call for responsible AI

Melania Trump Returns to Public Eye Advocating for Responsible AI

US First Lady Melania Trump recently delivered rare public comments at a…
First speech by Member for Lingiari Marion Scrymgour, in the House of Representatives at Parliament House in Canberra on Wednesday 27 July 2022. fedpol Photo: Alex Ellinghausen

Labor MP Discusses Son’s Drug Struggles Following Court Appearance

Federal Labor MP and Special Envoy for Remote Communities Marion Scrymgour has…
Diane Sheehan gave birth in September 1976 but was told her baby had died. She wasn't able to hold him

My Baby Died at Birth, and I Never Got to Hold Him—42 Years Later, an Unexpected Email Revealed a Shocking Truth

Opening the email took me back over 40 years, to a stark…
Police release video of men who 'permanently' damaged Anzac Memorial

Authorities Unveil Footage of Suspects Vandalizing Anzac Memorial

Authorities have released video footage showing two individuals who allegedly defaced the…

Get Ready to Witness the Blood Moon in Australia: Key Details You Shouldn’t Miss

If you see the moon glowing red on Monday, it’s no illusion…
Senior Constable Vadim De Waart

‘Our Personal Hero’: Family’s Heartfelt Goodbye to Constable Killed in Porepunkah Shooting

The brother of Senior Constable Vadim de Waart-Hottart, who was killed in…

Camp Sovereignty Intensifies Security Due to Attack Concerns

Resilience is the prevailing mood at Melbourne’s Camp Sovereignty. A few days…