Brett Sutton at a media conference where he announced his resignation as Victoria's chief health officer in 2023.
Share this @internewscast.com

Remember those bizarre days through the pandemic when knocking elbows replaced shaking hands because it was healthier?

Remember the obsession with cleaning everything with disinfectant wipes?

Pens, groceries, desks, even traffic light buttons were wiped every few minutes.

Well, according to the man who led the charge, it was a waste of time.

He also mentions there are “alternative methods” instead of harsh lockdowns to effectively handle a similar crisis, highlighting that even the widely-used hand sanitiser was not particularly beneficial.

This issue is like life insurance and next week’s huge rent bill.

We know we have to face it but just want it to go away.

Brett Sutton at a media conference where he announced his resignation as Victoria's chief health officer in 2023.
Brett Sutton at a media conference where he announced his resignation as Victoria’s chief health officer in 2023. (Joe Armao/The Age)

The bad news is that another pandemic is inevitable, possibly within the next decade.

For our own health, we need to work out what went wrong, what worked and what didn’t.

Here’s the expert with unmatched insight into the mistakes and accomplishments: Professor Brett Sutton, the chief health officer who crafted Victoria’s COVID-19 strategy, known as one of the strictest globally.

“Touching elbows was probably never necessary. They’re the things that we learn as we go.

“Throughout a century of infectious disease knowledge, we overstressed the belief that transmission occurs through surfaces, handshakes, or droplets, while the reality is, it’s mainly in the air we exhale.”

“It’s very unlikely to spread through surfaces. You didn’t have to wash down the groceries.

“It’s not like washing your hands and using hand sanitiser is a bad thing.

“This might be more relevant for bacterial infections encountered in hospitals rather than pandemic viruses, which primarily concern the air we breathe.”

In a rare interview, Sutton, who is now with the CSIRO, spoke to my Nine podcast Neil Mitchell asks why?

He described the pandemic as a “horror show” and said he woke up many mornings wanting to quit.

He says more than most he wants to forget it, but as a society we must not.

“We tend not to discuss it much. The truth is, we should diligently prioritize planning and prevention, aiming to facilitate easier response and recovery phases.”

Through those dark days, lockdowns were what damaged the people most.

In Victoria, there were also curfews and limits on travelling more than five kilometres from home.

Businesses collapsed, families were traumatised. Society was frozen.

It began with a national six-week lockdown then states took over.

An empty Bourke Street during one of Melbourne's marathon lockdowns.
An empty Bourke Street during one of Melbourne’s marathon lockdowns. (Getty)

After a second wave arguably caused by government sloppiness, Victoria reached a total of 262 days locked down by the time vaccination rates built.

NSW was less than half that, and with a million more people, had significantly fewer deaths.

So, did lockdown work and will the public ever accept it again?

“Maybe we will agree as a society that we never want to do that (lockdown) again,” Sutton said.

“There are other ways to manage stuff. And if we all wore masks and we all got vaccinated and we all kept distances without them being mandated.

That’s a potential path we can take.”

Today, some doctors argue that the COVID impact lingers, particularly with children, through increasing disengagement and school refusal.

Sutton agrees the kids did it hard.

“I think absolutely we should recognise that they made a significant sacrifice when they were least at risk, at medical risk.

“People made sacrifices to protect those most vulnerable, such as those undergoing chemotherapy, individuals with weakened immune systems, and the very elderly in nursing homes.”

“The children were constrained in their lives and that didn’t benefit them as much as it benefited others.

“But those other people, by God, needed the support of everyone.”

Brett Sutton (right) at a 2021 COVID-19 press conference with then-premier Daniel Andrews and COVID-19 commander Jeroen Weimar.
Brett Sutton (right) at a 2021 COVID-19 press conference with then-premier Daniel Andrews and COVID-19 commander Jeroen Weimar. (Paul Jeffers)

He says more work needs to be done to assess Victoria’s hardline reaction against other states and countries.

“We’ve got opportunities to make comparisons around the world for the places that had four weeks of lockdown, like WA, New Zealand and places that had really long lockdowns.

“My suspicion, and this is a personal view, is that there’s a larger global trend with youth that was maybe amplified through COVID-19 with all the challenges that it presented.”

Sutton is unable to speak about the details of his health orders, partly because of impending court action.

Although there has always been suspicion of undue influence by politicians in his decisions , he takes full responsibility and says he was “in the belly of the beast”.

“Probably a list that’s too long for this podcast. Speed is of the essence. And so I think decision making around the settings that you should have is probably something that I would reprosecute many times in my mind.”

Sutton mostly works from home, a business trend that emerged through the pandemic.

He is director of Health and Biosecurity at the CSIRO which means much of his job now is to plan for the future.

“I think I’m an emotional optimist, but an intellectual pessimist.

“We’ve got really profound challenges that will shape the nation and shape the world that are coming like a juggernaut.

“There’s no hard hat-wearing, ribbon-cutting solution that’s going to make it all good.

“I think we’ve got really, really challenging times ahead.

“A pandemic might be part of the juggernaut, I hope it’s not. We’ve got enough to worry about on our plate.”

The podcast Neil Mitchell asks Why is posted each Tuesday at 6am.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
US Vice President JD Vance, centre, walks with Pakistan's Chief of Defence Forces and Chief of Army Staff Field Marshall Asim Munir, left, and Pakistani Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Minister Mohammad Ishaq Dar

US and Iran Initiate Diplomatic Discussions in Pakistan

Negotiations began between the United States and Iran on Saturday, days after…
Residents forced inside as massive battery fire breaks out

Urgent Alert: Massive Battery Fire Triggers Evacuations, Residents Urged to Stay Indoors

A lithium-fuelled fire has erupted at a Perth recycling plant, sending toxic…

Pakistan Stages Historic Diplomatic Breakthrough: US-Iran Dialogue at Unprecedented Heights

In a surprising development, Pakistan has positioned itself as a mediator between…

Rescue Efforts Intensify for Missing Hiker in Victorian National Park

A large-scale search operation is currently underway for an individual named Andy,…

Overnight Tragedy: Hopes Shattered as Bombs Strike Amid Home Clean-Up Efforts

The people of Lebanon dared to let hope flicker for the first…
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese and Prime Minister of Singapore Lawrence Wong during a joint press conference at Istana Villa in Singapore on April 10, 2026. fedpol Photo: Dominic Lorrimer

Australia’s Fuel Deal with Singapore: Unraveling the Mystery Behind Persistently High Gas Prices

Singapore has pledged to Prime Minister Anthony Albanese its commitment to ensuring…
Trump threatens Strait of Hormuz blockade after ceasefire talks fail

Trump Warns of Strait of Hormuz Blockade Amid Ceasefire Negotiation Breakdown

Before the onset of hostilities, former President Donald Trump aimed to gain…

Unseen Struggles: The Forgotten Plight of Protesters Amidst the Chaos of War

Warning: This piece discusses violent content. In Melbourne, Emilia Nazari is gripped…

Artemis II Crew Celebrated Upon Return from Historic Lunar Mission

In brief The Artemis II crew took centre stage at Ellington Field…
Pictured: Melbourne coach Craig Bellamy gives forward Joe Chan (left, in the No.11 jersey) a severe dressing down at halftime of the team's loss to the Warriors on Saturday night

NRL Coach’s Dressing Room Outburst: Footy Legend Slams Public Shaming of Star Player

Former Warriors star and current television analyst Shaun Johnson has criticized Craig…
Petrol prices Australia

Australian Government Launches $20M Initiative Encouraging Reduced Fuel Usage

The federal government is rolling out a $20 million fuel-saving campaign to…

Unpacking Skepticism: Why Experts Question the US’s ‘Overwhelming Victory’ Declaration Against Iran

In Brief The US and Israel have hailed their operations in Iran…