Share this @internewscast.com
Finding unexpected family through the truth hidden in our DNA can be life-changing, but is the knowledge worth the potential consequences? Watch Insight episode DNA Doesn’t Lie on .
Linda Rudman always knew cancer ran in her family. She’s now discovered the reason, which lies in her DNA.
Linda underwent genetic screening in 2019 that revealed she had the BRCA1 gene — which leads to a high risk of developing breast or ovarian cancer.
“The first thing the genetic counsellor said to me was ‘you need to have your ovaries out and as soon as possible’,” Linda told Insight.
Within a few months, she underwent surgery to have both her left and right ovaries removed, and eventually had a .
Knowing the genetic risk ran high in her family, Linda encouraged her three daughters to also undergo .

“My daughters have got a one-in-two chance of carrying the gene,” Linda says.

and elderly woman with a grey bob and pearls round her neck and a middle aged woman with blonde bob smiling next to each other in a backyard

Linda (right) and her late mother Avril, who had breast cancer and also possessed the BRCA1 gene. Source: Supplied

To test or not to test

Initially, they were reluctant.
Linda’s eldest daughter Sam, 31, told Insight that she worried that if she did possess the gene mutation, it would be “quite a heavy thing to bear”.
But eventually, she decided “it’s better to know than to not know” and she had genetic screening, which revealed she also carried the BRCA1 gene mutation.

She’s now engaged in high-risk surveillance for breast cancer and has been advised to remove her ovaries between the ages of 35 to 40.

Her newfound knowledge about her DNA and her subsequent recommendations for future surgeries have led to other unintended life decisions.
“I thought that, with my age and considering [the risk of] ovarian cancer, dating and starting a family were becoming important to me,” she said.
“So, I moved to Melbourne [from WA] to be closer to family and the [Jewish] community.”
But despite Sam’s health discovery, Linda’s middle daughter Meg, 28, has chosen not to be tested.
“One of her reasons to not get screened is because of the current discrimination that is happening with life insurance policies,” Sam said of Meg’s decision.

Linda’s youngest daughter Hannah, 22, is yet to decide whether she’ll undergo genetic screening, as screening for the for the BRCA gene is generally recommended from age 25.

three young women smiling at the camera, the woman on the left has blonde hair and red lipstick and the woman on the middle wears a black top and has brown hair, the woman on the right has blonde hair

Sam (left) has chosen to undergo genetic screening for the BRCA 1 gene while Meg has elected not to. Youngest sister Hannah (right) is still to decide. Source: Supplied

‘Legislation in limbo’

In Australia, if a person makes a life insurance application, insurers can legally ask if they’ve had genetic testing.
“If you say yes, they will ask you for copies of those results and you are required to give it to them,” said Dr Jane Tiller, a genetic counsellor and public health researcher from Monash University.
“If the results show that you do have an increased risk of disease in your future, they can decline to cover you altogether.

“They can double your premium, put conditions on that cover — and that’s something that happens all the time.”

Jane says that the practice has been legal for a long time in Australia, despite being banned or restricted in many other countries such as Canada and the UK.
She notes DNA screenings can be used to highlight those predisposed to disease in the hope of improving outcomes.
“We’re trying to move into the area where we can use this kind of information for prevention so that we can actually prevent disease altogether.”

She is one of the professionals who, for the past nine years, have been calling for a ban on Australian insurers using genetic test results to deny, increase the premium or change the terms of a life insurance policy.

Life insurance companies can’t access your [genetic testing] results directly. But it is perfectly legal in Australia at the moment for them to ask for your results and to discriminate on the basis of them.

Dr Jane Tiller

In September 2024, the federal government announced it would ban “the ability to discriminate based on adverse predictive genetic test results by banning their use in life insurance underwriting”.
The announcement was even welcomed by life insurance companies themselves.
“We’ve long been clear about the need for strict regulation to ensure that no one is deterred from taking a genetic test to proactively manage their health,” the Council of Australian Life Insurers said in a statement.

Although the announcement of the ban came six months ago, no legislation has been introduced — leading to calls for action from doctors union The Australian Medical Association.

‘I was a ticking time bomb’

Norm always knew his family had a history of heart issues — but he never thought much of it.
That was until he saw a cardiologist at his wife Nancy’s suggestion, after experiencing shortness of breath during a cricket match.

“I had my heart surgery the following day,” Norm told Insight. “My arteries were over 90 per cent blocked; I was a ticking time bomb”.

a young family - a mum, dad and three young children - smiling in front of a white table with a spread of food in it

Norm and his wife Nancy with their three children who also possess the same Type 1 gene as Norm. Source: Supplied

When Norm and Nancy decided to have children, Norm underwent DNA screening.

This is when Norm discovered his familial hypercholesterolaemia, a genetic predisposition to high cholesterol — which, it turns out, his and Nancy’s children also possess.
“There are two types of FH genes … Type 1 and Type 2,” Norm says. “The Type 2 gene is more aggressive.”
Norm and his children have Type 1, which they manage with ongoing medication.
Norm maintains that without DNA screening, his kids would not be receiving the medical attention they need. This includes daily medication and access to the two top hospitals in Victoria with leading paediatric cardiac specialists.

“You’ve got the gene but it’s not the end of the world,” Norm says. “DNA screening helps us give greater certainty to our future.”

Is it better to know than to not?

While uncertainty surrounds the future of the government’s proposed ban, people like Meg remain conflicted on whether to undergo genetic testing that could flag potentially life-threatening health conditions.
Linda said she’s “very unhappy” about Meg’s choice, but acknowledges she had to “respect her wishes and understand where she’s coming from”.
“At the end of the day … having knowledge of what you carry, genetically, gives you power.”
And for more stories on sex, relationships, health, wealth, grief and more, head to hosted by Kumi Taguchi. Follow us on the , or wherever you get your podcasts.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Jerome Powell Accuses Trump’s ‘Intimidation’ Tactics Amid Criticism of Federal Reserve Leadership

United States President Donald Trump has denied any involvement in the justice…

Michele Bullock and Global Central Bank Leaders Stand United in Support of Jerome Powell

Global central bank chiefs, including Australia’s Michele Bullock, have issued a rare…
Alleged Australian underworld kingpin reportedly arrested in Iraq

Breaking News: Notorious Australian Crime Boss Captured in Iraq Amid International Manhunt

An individual believed to be a notorious figure in the Australian criminal…
More than half of surveyed Australians say they have hit another car and not left a note.

Revealed: The Surprising Habit Many Aussie Drivers Confess To

A majority of surveyed Australians admit they don’t own up to hitting…
Jessica Evans

Expat Jess Faces $5K Cost to Legally Change Gender and Name in the UK: What You Need to Know

An Australian expat and trans woman says the United Kingdom refuses to…
Thomas Sewell has been denied bail over an alleged attack on an Indigenous site in Melbourne.

Neo-Nazi Organization Set for Complete Disbandment Ahead of New Hate Speech Legislation

Prominent neo-Nazi figure Thomas Sewell has announced that his white nationalist group,…
London, United Kingdom - March 7th, 2023 :   A new blue British passport with an airline boarding pass.  Since the United Kingdom has left the European Union in 2020, new British passports have returned to their original blue colour.

Why Simon Paid $3,000 to Surrender His Family’s Citizenship: A Passport Dilemma Unveiled

Exclusive: Frustration over the United Kingdom’s updated entry policies is leading some…

Revolutionizing Representation: How an AI-Driven Indigenous Avatar is Transforming Social Media and Challenging Cultural Narratives

To many, he’s an Aboriginal man building an online following – yet…
'Help is on its way': Trump urges Iranians to keep protesting

Trump Rallies Iranian Protesters: A Call to Action for Change

US President Donald Trump urged Iranians on Tuesday to keep protesting and…

Sydney Man Arrested in Connection to South-West Murder Plot Allegations

A man has been formally charged in connection with an alleged murder…
Six-year-old Amelia-Rose, who suffers from sever asthma, with her mother Sophie

Innovative Treatment Transforms Life for Amelia-Rose, Alleviating Severe Asthma Symptoms and Restoring Her Freedom

Watching her daughter struggle for breath had become an all-too-common, yet harrowing…
Australian money, in full-frame.  Fifty, twenty, ten and five dollar notes.

Aussie Credit Card Debt Soars to Record High Amid Unprecedented Spending Surge

Australians put a record amount of money on their credit cards in…