During Casey Anthony’s murder trial, her mother, Cindy Anthony (pictured above with husband George), testified that Casey told her that Caylee’s father was an old friend named Eric Baker, who had died in a car crash, per the Daily Mail. According to CNN, investigators found a death certificate for an Eric Baker, who died in a car crash, but they were unable to verify any connection between the two. Another possible father some someone Casey was recently known to have dated — Jesus Ortiz. He and Casey Anthony dated in 2007 before he died in a car crash. The Ortiz family was shocked. “Miss Anthony never told the family Jesus was the father or that he might be the father,”the family said (via People).
In 2011, Donna MacLean claimed that her son, Michael Patrick Duggan, was Caylee’s father. She claimed that Michael, who also died in a car crash, told her about Caylee before his death. She told The Daily Beast, “I would never in a million years bring something like this forward if I wasn’t 100 percent positive. My son wouldn’t lie to me.” N
Nothing has ever been conclusive about Caylee’s father. People close to Casey Anthony say she’ll go to the grave with the secret. “If she knows who the father is, she’s not telling,” one source told People. “She definitely won’t ever say anything publicly. I doubt anyone will ever know.”
