Attorney of family seeking more charges against former deputy and neighbor
Share this @internewscast.com


BEAUFORT COUNTY, S.C. () — The Pepitone family has enlisted attorney Jared Newman to represent them in a lawsuit against former Beaufort County deputy William Squires and neighbor Brian Stahlheber.

Both Squires and Stahlheber were apprehended and charged by the South Carolina Law Enforcement Division (SLED) on Tuesday, October 28th.

In an exclusive interview with News 3, Newman detailed the events that led to the lawsuit, describing the incident that took place on Sunday, September 28th. A video captured by the teenagers involved depicted Squires drawing his firearm and aiming it at them.

“There have been all sorts of rumors, from the kids shooting BB guns at dogs to them threatening the deputy with a weapon. None of that is true,” Newman stated. “These were simply three kids whose mother encouraged them to go outside for some fresh air, and then this situation unfolded.”

According to Newman, Lauren Pepitone encountered her sons and their friends, including an unnamed minor, in the Squiresgate neighborhood while she was out walking the family dog.

“She arrived at the scene to find her children and their friends lying on the ground with guns pointed at them, being choked and restrained,” Newman recounted.

Lauren witnessed Squires holding them at gunpoint and Stahlheber forcefully holding one of the teens by the neck to the ground.

She allegedly tried to intervene.

“The mother actually had a gun pointed at her as well. I think they’re looking into that charge,” said Newman. He went on to say that it may have been missed in initial investigations and he’s looking to pursue that charge.  “I’m hoping to meet with the solicitor’s liaison and the solicitor from the First Circuit to see where they are. I think they are still investigating on how to charge and what to charge.”

Squires was arrested and charged with four counts of pointing a weapon and one breach of peace in an aggravated nature.

Stahlheber was charged with breach of peace in an aggravated nature and giving false information to law enforcement.

Five John Does were also mentioned in the lawsuit. Newman said there were several other people involved in the incident that are currently unknown but can be brought into the investigation if necessary.

“There was another civilian-type person who was also assaulting these children. We don’t know who that is yet,” said Newman. “We’re still looking into liability of possibly any other deputies. I don’t think there will be. But you put a John Doe in there so it’s filed, and if we find somebody we need to bring in to pursue, we’ll bring him in.”

According to SLED, Stahlheber initially told investigators that the kids had a gun. He later admitted that was untrue in a separate interview with investigators.

“None were ever found,” said Newman.

Newman said he believes there are reasons the kids allegedly having guns is not relevant.

“The very first time Squires rides by in the car, he’s telling them, ‘You need to get out of here’. He’s not telling them, ‘I’ve called the cops. You need to stay right here’. I think he thought he was disrespected and then said, “Watch this.” Jams the car in park, puts on the vest and pulls out the gun,” said Newman.

Squires and Stahlheber were also allegedly drunk.

Squires is said to have refused a breathalyzer on scene.

“According to the witnesses that were on the scene, I think it’s pretty clear that they were drunk,” said Newman. “I don’t know what the excuse is, ‘I was so drunk, I didn’t know what I was doing’ or ‘I wasn’t that drunk, I’m just mean.’ I mean, I don’t think there’s a good answer for that. But I definitely think with the deputy refusing a direct order to take a data master breathalyzer is telling.”

Newman said the incident has traumatized the Pepitone family and several of their rights were violated on that Sunday.

“You can imagine it cuts right through the family. There [are] two of your three sons getting guns [pointed] at, your wife, and then the father has to deal with all this. This is just a regular, normal family,” said Newman.

Newman explained that’s why they’re pursuing legal action.  

“We believe the deputy violated a number of policies. We’re seeking damages for negligence.  I think the main part of the case is going to end up in federal court, civil rights litigation. It’s clear that he was acting under the color of state law, his badge and his gun.  And he violated these people’s Fourth, Fifth, and Fourteenth Amendment. I could go on with a bunch of amendments, but he seriously, substantially violated their constitutional rights,” said Newman.

Newman said there will likely be negotiations like any other lawsuit.

“They’ve done serious damage to this family. If they don’t take it seriously, then we’ll put it in front of a jury of 12 people and see what they have to say about it,” said Newman.

News 3 reached out to the attorney representing the other juveniles involved. They said they would not be making a statement at this time due to the seriousness of the case.

Newman said they are in contact with the other attorney and they are working together to pursue legal action against the former deputy.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Heartfelt Farewell: Motorcade Honors Fallen National Guard Member Tragically Shot in Washington D.C.

On Thursday evening, a solemn procession departed from Medstar Washington Medical Center,…

Trader Joe’s Set to Open First Melbourne Location This December, Company Announces

MELBOURNE, Fla. – The eagerly awaited Trader Joe’s store in Central Florida…

Survivors of Hong Kong Apartment Fire Reflect on Their Next Steps

HONG KONG – It was a typical afternoon when William Li received…

Community Outcry Escalates: Arrests Spark Controversy 100 Days Post Rainbow Crosswalk Removal

In Orlando, Florida, a crosswalk near the former Pulse nightclub has become…

SpaceX Schedules Florida Rocket Launch for Early Monday Morning

MERRITT ISLAND, Fla. – In the early hours of Monday, SpaceX is…

African Union Temporarily Suspends Guinea-Bissau Following Military Coup

DAKAR – In response to a military coup, the African Union has…

Post-Thanksgiving Travel Alert: Snow, Rain, and Cold Weather Set to Impact Journeys

As the Thanksgiving holiday weekend continues, travelers should brace themselves for a…

Ex-CIA Employee from Afghanistan Commits Shooting in DC After Cross-Country Drive

Rahmanaullah Lakanwal, a 29-year-old who once served with an agency in Afghanistan,…

Brace for Impact: Thanksgiving Travelers Face Snow, Rain, and Chilly Weather Conditions

As Thanksgiving travelers began their journeys, snow and cold temperatures have already…

Legionnaires’ Disease Alert: Ocoee Gym Under Investigation for Potential Outbreak

OCOEE, Fla. – A cloud of concern hovers over a local fitness…

Bristol, Va. House Fire Attributed to Candle Left Near Flammable Materials, Reports Fire Chief

BRISTOL, Va. (WJHL) — On Thanksgiving Day, a house fire in Bristol,…

Jonesborough Illuminates the Season with Annual Christmas Tree Lighting Ceremony

The heart of Tennessee’s oldest town, Jonesborough, sprang to life as the…