Share this @internewscast.com

It’s a neutral pronoun that’s proving anything but: a non-binary pronoun added to an esteemed French dictionary has ignited a fierce linguistic squabble in the country.

Le Petit Robert introduced the word “iel” — an amalgamation of “il” (he) and “elle” (she) — to its online edition last month.

While the term is gaining currency among young people, it is still far from being widely used, or even understood, by many French speakers.

Education Minister Jean-Michel Blanquer went to Twitter on Wednesday to say that "inclusive writing is not the future of the French language."
Education Minister Jean-Michel Blanquer went to Twitter on Wednesday to say that “inclusive writing is not the future of the French language.” (AP)

Though at first the change went mostly unnoticed, boisterous debate broke out this week in a nation that prides itself on its human rights tradition but that also fiercely protects its cultural heritage from foreign meddling.

In one camp are the traditionalists, including some political leaders, who criticise the move as a sign that France is lurching toward an American-style “woke” ideology.

In the other is a new generation of citizens who embrace non-binary as the norm.

“It is very important that dictionaries include the ‘iel’ pronoun in their referencing as it reflects how the use of the term is now well accepted,” said Dorah Simon Claude, a 32-year-old doctoral student who identifies as “iel.”

“It is,” they added, “also a way of confronting the Academie Francaise that stays in its conservative corner and continues to ignore and scorn users of the French language.”

Education Minister Jean-Michel Blanquer is not in the same camp.

He went to Twitter on Wednesday to say that “inclusive writing is not the future of the French language.”

The 56-year-old former law professor warned that schoolchildren should not use “iel” as a valid term despite its inclusion in Le Robert, seen as a linguistic authority on French since 1967.

Francois Jolivet, a lawmaker from President Emmanuel Macron’s centrist party, also made his distaste plain.

Non-binary pronouns are, he suggested, a worrying sign that France is embracing a “woke” ideology.

Mr Jolivet wrote a letter to the bastion of French language, the 400-year-old Academie Francaise, claiming that Le Robert’s “solitary campaign is an obvious ideological intrusion that undermines our common language and its influence.”

The general director of Le Robert editions, Charles Bimbenet, jumped to the dictionary’s defence on Wednesday in a statement.

Far from dictating which terms should be used, he said, Le Petit Robert was elucidating the word’s meaning, now it is growing in currency nationwide.

Since “the meaning of the word iel cannot be understood by reading it alone,” Mr Bimbenet said, “it seemed useful to us to specify its meaning for those who encounter it, whether they wish to use it or … reject it.”

“Robert’s mission is to observe and report on the evolution of a changing and diverse French language,” he said.

Le Petit Robert introduced the word "iel" — an amalgamation of "il" (he) and "elle" (she) — to its online dictionary.
Le Petit Robert introduced the word “iel” — an amalgamation of “il” (he) and “elle” (she) — to its online dictionary. (AP)

In 2017, the Academie Francaise warned that moves to make French more gender neutral would create “a disunited language, with disparate expression, that can create confusion verging on illegibility.”

Gendered languages like French are seen as a particular hurdle for advocates of non-binary terms as all nouns are categorised as either masculine or feminine, unlike in English.

Not all European countries are moving at the same speed as France.

In Greece, where all nouns have not two, but three possible genders, there is no official non-binary pronoun, but groups who support them suggest using “it.”

In Spain, after former deputy prime minister and affirmed feminist Carmen Calvo asked the Royal Spanish Academy to advise on the use of inclusive language in the Constitution, its reply the next year was crystal clear: “Inclusive language” means “the use of the masculine to refer to men and women.”

Source: 9News

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

What does it mean to be ‘California sober?’

SAN DIEGO (KSWB) — Californians do a lot of things differently from…

Russian Forces Press Kyiv’s Last Stronghold in Luhansk Province

KYIV, Ukraine (AP) – Russian forces are pounding the city of Lysychansk…

Medical documents found by landscaper on busy Florida road

The documents include dates of birth, phone numbers and addresses of patients…

I’m Tired of People Putting Us Down

Nashville Hall of Famer Jeffrey Steele has released a new patriotic single…

Lightning Strike Causes Attic Fire In Ruskin Home

RUSKIN, Fla. – Hillsborough County Fire Rescue responded to a structure fire…

Kemp extends order suspending Georgia gas taxes until mid-August

ATLANTA – Gov. Brian Kemp extended the suspension of Georgia’s motor fuel…

Woman dies and boy critically injured in South Australian crash

Police were called to Donovans Road at Wye at about 12.30pm on…

Miami man sentenced to 25 years for attacking Gainesville Uber driver

Press release from United States Attorney, Northern District of Florida GAINESVILLE, Fla.…